History Repeating

The Mysterious Man

SAM

Oh no. This isn't good. I woke up to Elena lying in my arms sound asleep. Guilt ran through my body. I was about to wake Elena up, but there was a knock at the door.

I got up and went to go answer it. I saw a woman standing outside of my door. It was the one person I didn't want to see right now. I cracked open the door and hid my body so she couldn't see in.

"Good morning Sam!" She said happily.

"Jess, what are you doing here?" I asked her.

"Well, I was going to ask if you wanted to get some coffee, but I see you aren't ready," she said laughing.

"Yeah, I-uh...I have to take a rain check," I told her nervously.

"Alright, well I'll see you tonight," she moved to me and kissed my lightly.

"Yeah," I closed the door and sighed. Then I heard a familiar voice.

"Who was that?" Elena asked. I turned around guilty.

"Uh... That was Jess," I told her.

"Are you two..." She paused "Together?"

I put my head down in shame.

"I'm going to be sick," Elena said as she started grabbing her things.

"Elena don't," I said trying to stop her.

"You're in a relationship Sam! You didn't think that'd be good for me to know!" She yelled.

"You're my student Elena! I didn't think I had to tell you everything!" I yelled back.

"We had sex Sam! You cheated on your girlfriend with me!"

"You don't think I know that!" I told her.

"Sam, I can't do this anymore!" She started crying.

"Elena don't," I said quietly.

"No Sam! I'm tired of being hurt. You're the reason that I can't be in a relationship. You're the reason I've been miserable these last few months. You're the reason I can't contain my emotions any more! I'm tired of you ruining my life!" She said in tears.

"Ruining your life? I am ruining your life Elena? Is that really how you feel?" I asked her angrily.

"I want to be with you so bad Sam! So bad that it hurts! Every time you talk my heart breaks just a little! So tell me Sam. Do you want to be with her or me because I'm tired of fighting Sam." She asked me.

"Elena," I started.

"Got my answer." She said holding back some more tears. She went to the door and started to leave.

"Elena don't leave," I told her.

"See you at school Mr. Winchester," she said before closing the door and leaving.

ELENA

It's been three weeks since Sam and I ended whatever we were. I've been sad, but I've started to move on. I've started to put myself out there again. I got ready for school and left. I had on my favorite AC/DC shirt and, as always, my favorite pair of converse.

Before school, I stopped by a gas station to fill up my car. It was a blue Mustang with a white stripe down the middle and a glittered license plate. I loved my baby.

As I was filling up, a beautiful 1967 Impala appeared before my eyes. A man, about six foot two, got out of the car. He was beautiful. He had dirty blonde hair and his build was as beautiful as his car. He had a hot back, but an even hotter front. The man turned around revealing himself. He had mesmerizing emerald eyes. He smirked at me.