The Killer Next Door {Jeff The Killer Romance Fanfiction}

•Part 5•

Jeffs pov
I sat through the next 2 periods, wishing I was out of here so I could kill. That feeling was built up in me, considering I haven't killed in two days. I bounced my leg up and down quickly, waiting for the bell to ring. Taylor glanced at me every now and then. I would always look at her and mouth the words, "I'm okay". She would nod and then look away. Finally, after what felt like forever, the bell rang, making all the kids get up and rush out the door. I got up and walked over to Taylor as she got up. "Okay...lunch is next- good" she sighed. "Taylor..." I said as we walked out of the room. She looked at me. "Do you wanna ditch with me-?..." I asked. "Jeff-! Are you kidding me??" She asked. "No- I'm serious. Make up your mind because I'm going like, now" I said. She sighed. "Fine...".
I smiled and grabbed her wrist, pulling her to the right. We walked down an empty hallway, witch led to a door down to the basement. There was a window that took you to the back of the school. That's how I usually got out of this hell hole when I needed too. No one came back here no matter what the situation was. It's basically an abandoned basement. We reached the bottom of the stairway, into the basement. I brought Taylor to the window and slid it open. "Okay..now I'm going to lift you up, and you'll climb out" I whispered. She nodded as I put my hands on her waist, lifting her up. I raised her out the window and let her down gently, then I climbed out. I landed on the ground and grabbed Taylor's hand. We looked at watch other, smiled, looked ahead again and began to run. We ran down the road as fast as we could, trying not to let anyone from the school see us. "Run faster!!" I panted. She sighed as she started running faster. I stopped as a turn came. "Alright...ill cross first then you can.." I said out of breath. I began walking across the road. I stopped as Taylor began to say something. I turned around towards her.
"What did you say...?" I asked.
"When are you-.." She cut herself off as her eyes grew wide with fear.
"JEFF MOVE!!!" She screamed as she started running towards me. At that second, I knew what was going to happen. My heart sunk as I looked to my right to find a truck speeding towards me. I knew I wasn't going to make it but I started running towards Taylor.
Before I knew it, I heard Taylor scream as I went flying across the road. I landed hard. My body thumped in pain, my heart racing uncontrollably. "Augh...what the hell~..." I whimpered, looking at my blood covered hands. "Jeff-!" Taylor yelled as she ran up beside me and kneeled down. I nervously looked up at her. She started crying as she looked down at my body. The driver of the truck got out and started yelling at me.
"WHY WOULDN'T YOU MOVE!? NOW LOOK WHAT YOU'VE DONE, YOU IDIOT!!!" He shouted. I groaned in pain as I laid my arm across my eyes. "SHUT THE HELL UP AND GET THE FUCK OUT OF HERE!!" Taylor yelled at the man. He rolled his eyes as he stormed into his truck and drove away. She looked down at me. My vision started to blur, from blood loss. "Jeff...Jeff?? Don't pass out!! Please! I'll get Jack and Toby!" She cried as she got up and sprinted towards the school again. I laid there panting, holding my arm across my eyes. I felt like I was dying. I didn't know if I was...or if this pain was just unbearable. I felt myself getting dizzy. My heartbeat was slowing...I whimpered in pain again. I felt a bit of relief when I saw Taylor and the guys running over to me. "Jeff- holy fuck, are you okay??" Jack asked me, kneeling beside me, along with the others. I just laid there. "Shit...Toby, help me. Get his other arm" Jack said, lifting up my arm and putting it around his shoulder, Toby lifting my arm around his shoulder. "Alright Jeff...we're taking you home..just stay with us" Jack said as they quickly began carrying me towards the house. Taylor ran beside them, worried as hell. She kept glancing at me, making sure I was alright. My eyes started to roll back in my head, as I let my weight fall. Toby and Jack struggled to keep me up.
"Jeff...come-...on!!" Toby groaned breathlessly.
I started panting as my heart beat slowed even more.
Jack and Toby stopped and looked at me. Taylor ran up in front of me and lifted up my face gently. Tears were falling from her eyes like a waterfall. "Jeff...don't you dare...please.." She whispered through her tears. I groaned as I tried to keep myself together.
For her.
Come on, we have to get to Slendy!" Toby yelled as Jack and him began walking again. This time faster. "Jack...I..I'm..I..c-can't.." I stuttered quietly. I seen two of everything. As Taylor ran in front of us, she had two bodies that were shifting through each other. This made my head hurt. I let my head drop as Toby and Jack literally dragged me through the woods. I glanced down at Toby. My blood covered his arm and torso, along with the trail of blood behind us. "Ugh..." I grunted as tears started to build in my eyes from the pain. "It's okay..it's okay Jeff- were here" Jack said as they lifted me up onto the porch. Taylor opened the door for them as they carried me inside.
Taylor's pov
I looked back at Jeff as the boys carried him through the door. He looked like he was about to pass out and his hoody was covered with a fresh layer of blood. He was panting quickly. His face, arms, and hands were all cut up and scraped, leaving blood trickling from the cuts. I sighed hopelessly as I quickly turned around. "SLENDY! JEFF GOT HIT BY A CAR!!" I yelled nervously. "HURRY!" Jack yelled afterwards. "I..think...I'm..going to p-..pass out.." Jeff whispered. Toby looked down at him, full of worry and impatience. Slendy came rushing down the stairs, along with Ben, masky, hoodie, and Sally. "Ogh..Slendy.." Jeff whimpered. "Shh- shh...come here child" Slendy said calmly as he took Jeff in his arms. "J-Jeff-!?" Ben asked as he started to cry. "Awe Ben...it's okay, don't cry" I said softly as I walked up to him. "Taylor! What happened to him!?" He cried. "He..he got hit by a car..".
Ben started sobbing as I pulled him into a hug. I looked up as Slendy carried Jeff upstairs. I looked down and brushed Ben's hair out of his wet face. He sniffed a few times and looked up at me. "Is he gonna be okay~?" He asked in a shaky voice. I paused for a second then shrugged as my eyes filled with tears again. "...lets all just stay down here until Slendy is done with him.." Jack said, sitting down on the couch. "Oh my god...how did that even happen??" Masky asked, sitting beside Jack. Everyone looked at me. I brushed Ben's hair with my fingers as I looked down, then back up at everyone.
"We...we're running down the road because we decided to ditch the rest of the school day, and a turn came. So Jeff told me that he would cross first then I could. He started to cross the road, as I asked him where we were going...and he turned around because he didn't hear me. I started to say it again-...but I seen a truck speeding down the road towards him. I screamed move, but it was too late....he started running towards me but the truck hit him..." I said. My tears covered my cheeks. Everyone looked at me sadly. I moved away from Ben and covered my face as I started sobbing.
Jeffs pov
......am i dead..? Why do I see blackness...? Ah. There's my vision.
Oh, good, slendys helping me. Wait...where's Taylor?? I want her up here. -ouch! God Slendy...be careful. What's he doing...? Why is he- OMG. HE CUT MY STOMACH OPEN!?
Wow...I must've got hurt pretty bad.
Ugh...I wish I would've seen that truck coming. How come I didn't hear it?? If Taylor wasn't with me...I most likely would've died. And if someone would've found me laying there, they would've recognized my face and realized that I was one of the killers going around murdering everyone. They would've killed me anyway.
Wait- is Slendy talking to me?...
Oh, he's talking to whoever is standing in the doorway.
"Yes yes...his bleeding slowed, and I had to stitch up his stomach. Something sticking out of the car must have jabbed him hard enough to rip his stomach open."
That was slendys voice. But who was he talking to??
"Oh...well..do you think he'll be alright? Taylor's downstairs crying...and I feel really bad. She's so afraid of him dying. Slendy...I think she loves him"
Oh. It was Toby. But...he thinks she loves me...? Does she??...do I even like her?... I'm pretty positive I do but, I don't think I can date a girl...my life would be so much different...the other proxies would never forgive me for dating a...normal..girl. I think I actually do love her though. I really need to stop being mean to her sometimes. I don't mean for it to come off mean, it just...does, because I'm a mean person. Well, until I met Taylor...she changed me.
"What-?...no. That can't happen. Jeffery is not allowed to date." Slendy said.
"Uh...okay..but I think Jeff likes her too. He's changed ever since Taylor came into our lives...he's better Slendy" Toby said.
"I don't care. Jeff is a proxy. Not a normal boy. He will kill and that's all he will ever do".
What!? No!! He can't do that to me!
"...whatever. You just ruined Jeffs life" Toby mumbled.
"He never had a life. He's nothing but a killer. And he's not allowed to see Taylor ever again. Neither are the rest of you, so go tell Taylor to get out now and NEVER come back" Slendy hissed.
No Slendy!!! What!? What are you doing!! Please don't do that!!
"But Slendy-" Toby began as Slendy cut him off.
"END OF DISCUSSION. GO."
I heard Toby storm out of the room, slamming the door behind him. Was I seriously never going to see Taylor again?? This can't be happening...No, no, NO!!! Say something Jeff!!! Before he leaves!! Hurry!
"S-..Slendy.." I chocked out. He looked at me. "P...ugh..please..don't.." I tried to say. It hurt to talk. "Don't what Jeff?" He asked. "I..n-n..need to...see her" I whispered. Whispering made it easier. "No. Jeff do you love that girl?" He asked me. For some reason, tears built up in my eyes. I shook my head "yes" quickly. He sighed. "How did this happen...? Jeff, I'm sorry but it has to be this way. Toby is telling her to leave now." He said. My tears started to fall.
"NO-!" I said loudly. It sent a sharp pain up my stomach but I ignored it. My voice was also raspier than usual. "YES. You need to not yell. Jeff, you most likely don't even love her. You just feel a connection with her, considering she's the first normal person you haven't killed".
"No, no- please!! C-...come on.." I said quietly. He put his finger over my lips, tears falling onto his finger. "Shh-shh...forget about her Jeff. She's gone" he whispered. I shook my head, denying what he had just said.
"Stay here...rest...ill be up to check on you every few minutes or so." He said as he stood up and walked out of the room, shutting the door behind him.
"T-...TAYLOR!" I yelled in my raspy, scratchy voice.
"No! I'm not leaving without seeing him!!!" I heard her yell from downstairs. "YES YOU ARE!" Slendys voice boomed.
"Slendy no-!!" I heard Ben yell.
*THUNK!*
"WHAT THE HELL DID YOU DO!!" I heard Jacks angry voice yell.
"NOOO! SLENDY STOP IT! YOUR HURTING HER!" Masky yelled.
Then I heard another loud bang. Was he beating her? I covered my face with my hands, knowing I couldn't do anything. I heard Taylor scream...then another loud sound. Then, Jack opened the door quickly, dragging Taylor in with him. She was crying hard. Jack slammed the door and locked it, then ran to the window and locked it, pulling the blinds down over it. He looked up at me. "She...she's safe...and...dude...we're you crying-?.." He asked, panting. I sniffed. "Jeff...you were.." He whispered, shocked. Taylor got up slowly, and shakily. She had bruises on her arms. "Jeff are y-you okay?.." She asked, tears rolling down her face. I just motioned her to come to me. She slowly walked towards me as I struggled to sit up. I got myself up finally. She looked at me confusingly. I grabbed her hoody and pulled her down to me, wrapping my arms around her. She hugged me back, hesitant at first. "I'm...o-okay..." I whispered. Jack looked down and shoved his hands in his pockets. "I-I...I can't..really talk..right n-now.." I whispered again. I felt her gently bounce in my arms as she started to cry. "Jeff your my best friend...I can't leave you..." She cried. "....don't..l-leave.." I chocked out as I started crying as well. "Guys- slendys coming!!" Jack whispered loudly as he ran over and sat on the bed next to us. Just then, Slendy ripped the door off its hinges. I jumped, as Taylor screamed, and Jack backed away a little. "TAYLOR...ITS TIME FOR YOU TO LEAVE SWEETHEART..." Slendy growled as he shot about 4 of his tentacles at Taylor and wrapped then around her. As he started pulling her away, I grabbed her, Jack helping me. "Please-!!" I cried. Jack was so surprised at the fact that I was crying. Actually crying. He stared at me as he held onto Taylor. "JEFF LET HER GO. NOW!!!" Slendy yelled. He yanked Taylor from Jack and threw her at the wall. She hit it hard and fell to the ground unconscious.
"SLENDY!!!" I screamed. I started to quickly get up, but Jack held me back. Slendy picked up Taylor's body and took her downstairs. I covered my face as I cried. Jack sat next to me, not knowing how to react. Every time I would take a breath between my cry, pain shot up through my torso. It hurt so bad. But I couldn't stop crying. What was wrong with me-?...I never cry.
I looked up at Jack as tears dripped from my face. "I...w-want to..be alone" I said quietly. He nodded and got up. I cleared my throat. "Wait.." I said. He paused and turned to me.
"Give me my knife..." I whispered. He stared at me for a second, then walked over to my dresser and grabbed my knife. He walked over and handed it to me. "Why..do you need that right now..?" He asked. "....because...I do." I said. My talking was getting a little better. He sighed. "I know what your going to do Jeff...I don't think you should" he said. "Jack just go. It's my arms not yours" I said quietly. He looked away from me and walked out, shutting the door behind me. I pulled out my left arm from under the blankets and laid it in front of me, my palm facing upward. I sighed before bringing the knife down onto my arm. With one, quick, motion, I put a slice in my arm going horizontal. Blood flowed to the surface and started trickling down my arm. I bit my lip as I did another right next to the other one. I did that over and over again until I couldn't handle it anymore. I looked up from my arm and chucked my bloody knife at the wall. It stuck into the wall, making a stab sound. I held my arm as I rocked back and forth, tears rolling down my cheeks. As some of my tears landed on my arm, it made me have a huge burning sensation. "Ugh-..." I groaned as I looked up at the ceiling with my tear-stained face. Suddenly, Ben creaked the door open and came in, shutting it behind him. He looked at my face then down at my arm. I just looked away from him as another tear fell from my face.
"Jeff....what are you doing?..." He said softly. I didn't look back up at him, I just kept my head down and held my bleeding arm. "Why did you cut yourself?" He asked, his voice starting to quiver. "This is all my fault...I'm the one who fell for Taylor. Now we're not allowed to see her ever again." I said. "What about school..?" He asked. "Oh- now I'm sure as hell going to school everyday. That's the only time I'll get to see her" I said. He shook his head. "Jeff...you really think your not going to see her again?? She can't go without seeing you. And your not gonna be able to go through that either. Jeff you love the girl for fucks sake-!" He said. He was being serious. "I know~..." I said quietly as my voice quivered. "It's just...she's the best thing that's happened to me...ever since she moved in next to us, I knew she was something different." I said. He smiled a little. "I think you two are perfect for each other".
"Thanks Ben...but it's never gonna happen.." I said. We looked at the door as Toby came rushing in. "Jeff...I'm gonna tell you right now, slendys out hunting, go see Taylor." He smiled. I smiled back as I started to slowly get up. "Ow...god dammit..." I muttered. "You okay-? You got it?.." Toby said as he got ready to help me. I nodded as I fully stood up. "Ahh...that feels wonderful..." I sighed as I stretched out carefully- making sure not to hurt anything. "Wow you look a lot better. After you got hit, you looked like a chunk of your stomach was missing" Toby chuckled. I smirked as I walked over to the wall I threw my knife into. Toby looked at the knife, then at my arm that was covered by my sleeve. He  walked over to me and snatched my wrist. He yanked my sleeve up, revealing the fresh cuts. "Jeff..." He said looking up at me disappointed. I sighed and pulled my arm away, putting my sleeve back down. "Your so stupid..." Toby mumbled. I shrugged and yanked my knife from the wall. I stuffed it into my pocket. "Alright, I'm going now." I said. They nodded. "Jeff..." Ben said. I looked back at him. "Will you kiss her?" He asked. I stared at him for a second. "I don't know Ben. I doubt she would want me to do that anyway." I said. He sighed as I turned back around and carefully jumped out the window. I walked next door to Taylor's house and climbed up to Taylor's window.
______________________________________________________