Three Times The Hummel Verse

Cheater

Kurt felt broken. As he laid in bed beside Blaine, one thought continued to appear in his mind.

He cheated on me.

Kurt wiped away a silent tear as he continued to listen to the soft snores of the boy beside him.

He's a cheater.

Kurt just wanted the night to be over. He couldn't sleep and it was killing him to lay beside someone he had trusted for so long. Someone who wasn't worth his trust.

Cheater.

Kurt couldn't take it anymore. He quietly slipped out of bed and went into the living room to sit in a chair.

He kept hearing Blaine's voice over and over.

"I cheated on you."

Another tear slid down his cheek. He didn't wipe it away this time. He let it fall. Then another. And another.

***

The swish of one of the bedroom curtains snapped him out of the little trance he had found himself in. He quickly wiped away the many tear tracks and tried to pull himself together a bit.

A few moments later Finn walked into the room, his bags swung over his shoulder.

"Going somewhere?" He couldn't help but ask. He also couldn't help but hear how shaky his voice was.

Finn swung around to face his brother, surprise written all over his face. The brothers talked for a few minutes before Finn decided to leave. He said goodbye before walking out the door.

After the door was fully closed behind him, Finn pulled out his phone and dialed a number. The other end rang a few times before someone answered. "Hey Chris." Finn said as he walked towards the building's elevator. "We need to talk. I've got some bad news."

***

Blaine felt sick. He was back in school Monday morning and he couldn't think of anything other than how much he had betrayed Kurt. Glee club was particularly bad since Finn was the teacher, but Blaine had somehow gotten through the day. When Finn dismissed everyone, Blaine was one of the first out the door. He didn't even make it five feet down the hall.

"Anderson!" Carson screamed angrily from down the hall when he saw the gel haired boy. He had been in Lima for the weekend visiting his dad when Chris had called and told him what happened. Understandably, Carson was beyond furious. In a blurred fury, Carson had drove over to the high school in search of the cause for his brother's tears.

Blaine visibly flinched when he heard his name screamed so angrily. When he looked up to see who it was, he became terrified.

Blaine had never really been afraid of anyone, but Carson was in a scary category all his own when he was in a raging fit.

When Carson finally reached him he grabbed fists full of Blaine's shirt and slammed him up against the nearby lockers. All of the other kids in Glee club stood back and watched on in silence.

"Do you have anything to say to me you dirty cheater." Carson spat in Blaine's face. He didn't pose it as a question.

Blaine already had water forming in his eyes due to both fear and sadness. He had no clue what to say.

Carson shook him roughly. "Huh? I didn't hear you! Why don't you tell me what you told him, huh? It seems you had no trouble telling Kurt so why don't you just say it to me?"

"Carson." Artie said in a attempt to calm the man down.

"Fuck off wheels." He said angrily, never taking his eyes away from the frightened hazel ones. Behind him, nobody moved or spoke. Finn had joined the crowd by this point and he didn't dare step forward and face his step-brother. For a moment, Finn was thankful that all he could see was Carson's back. He didn't want to see the hateful expression on the man's face. It reminded him all too much of the faggy lamp incident.

Meanwhile Blaine couldn't look away. He was scared to find out what would happen if he did. Carson's deep blue eyes bore holes through what ever they looked at. Blaine could feel them searching his own for something, a reason or excuse. Blaine didn't have any of those. While he had previously pinned it on him being lonely, he later realized he was trying to convince himself that that was the reason. He didn't have one.

Regardless, Carson seemed to find what he was looking for. He slowly let go of Blaine's shirt and took a step back. It had been silent for some time now, everyone scared that they too would be chewed out. Carson was the one to break the silence.

"I hope your happy, because I don't care if Kurt ever forgives you. I sure as hell wouldn't." Carson looked the boy in front of him up and down critically. He spoke much softer than he had before. He was over being blinded by anger, but now he just felt done. He was done with Blaine.  "You don't deserve my brother's love."

There it was. The words Blaine knew everyone was thinking but were too afraid to say aloud. He didn't deserve Kurt.

Carson finally turned away from Blaine and saw the giant audience that had gathered. More students than just the Glee Club members where present, including some teachers and Coach Sue. Carson wasn't worried about repercussions from the school. He hadn't said anything that wasn't true and he hadn't threatened him either.

Without another word Carson started to walk through the crowd and back towards the main doors. The crowd parted easily, all afraid that they would touch him and make him mad again. Once he was through the crowd he continued walking. After a moment, Coach Sue ran up beside him and kept pace with him.

"That was some show you just put on. I knew you had it in you." She said in her admiring and snarky way. Carson didn't grace her with a response as he left the building and headed back towards his car, leaving her behind at the doors.

***

There you guys go! A double update! I had a lot of fun writing this chapter and I left a lot of room to branch off of for future stories. Please leave a comment! Thanks for reading!! <3