Decisions, Decisions (Andy, Vic, Kellin X Reader)✔️

Oh...Halloween

The guys said they'd pick me up in Vic's car and go to Spirit Halloween. Now...where are they?? I soon saw a neon green and black dodge challenger drive up and roll the window down. "Well, helloooo, pretty lady." Kellin greeted me. "Haha...hey guys." I said. I jumped into the back seat with Andy and we went to shop for costumes.

You: So what is everyone gonna be for halloween?

Vic: Idk, I'll see when I get there.

Kellin: I think I'm gonna go with a vampire.

Andy: BATMAN.

Vic: what about you, (y/n)? What are you gonna be?

You: I'm gonna be a werewolf!

Andy: Oh, cool!

We got to the store pretty quickly. I walked in and it was dark with neon lights, spiderwebs, all that kind of stuff. I went to the teens section and looked for a werewolf costume. Vic tapped my shoulder, "what about this one?" he asked me. He held up a Sexy werewolf costume. "Yea right, Vic. XD never. Go put it back." I told him. I looked through all costumes. Too real. Too hairy. Too slutty....and then, I found it. A grey werewolf dress with a hoodie, a tail, and little ears. It's so cute! I grabbed my costume and went to search for the guys. Andy already had his costume in hand. A full batman costume with a cape XD. I looked for Kellin and he was in the vampire section. He had a cape, some fangs, and a white, ruffled shirt. "(y/n), what do you think?" he asked me. "I like it, kells. You should get some dark red contacts too. That'd be super cool.....HEY, I SHOULD GET SOME YELLOW CONTACTS CUZ I'M A WOLF." I said excitedly. I searched for Vic and some yellow contacts too. I found him with a skeleton costume, face paint, and white contacts. "Hey, Viccy, I found my costume...and I like yours!" I told him. "Your costume is so cute, (y/n)! I like yours too. um...I want to be a skeleton, but I'm not good with face painting...could you do it for me?" he asked. "Sure! I'm actually pretty good with that stuff. Where did you find those contacts?" I asked. "Right over here, come on." he told me. I followed him to the makeup section and I found some cool neon yellow ones. Perfect! Andy and Kellin found us and asked if we were ready to go. We payed for our stuff and went to my apartment. It's 5:38pm, trick-or-treating usually starts at around 8:00pm, we should really get ready, the makeup takes time. Andy used my bathroom to change into his one-piece batman costume and Kellin used my room to get his vampire costume in order. Andy came out faster, so I rushed Vic into the bathroom. He got his costume on and I pulled his hair back with a scrunchy. "Ok, so I'm gonna make large, dark circles around your eyes and some shading on your cheeks, also, some teeth on your lips. ready? " I asked. "YEP! PAINT ME LIKE ONE OF YOUR FRENCH GIRLS." he said. "OMG, OK, THEN. HAHAHAHA!!!" I laughed. I drew some large, black circles around his eyes and colored them in. He squirmed when I was coloring his eyelids. I then, outlined where his cheekbones were and made two more large, black shapes. I got to painting his whole face that wasn't black with white. He looked pretty good, all we need is the nose hole and teeth. I put an upside down, heart on his nose and colored it in. aww..he looked at me so adoringly. I stopped for a second and smiled. He can be so cute. "What?" he asked. "Nothin!" I said with a smile. Then, I made lines on his lips to make his teeth. "Done!" I said. He turned around and looked in the mirror. His mouth dropped open. "WWWOOOOOWWWW!!! IT LOOKS AWESOME, THANKS!!!" he thanked me. He picked me up and spun me around, jumping. "You're welcome!!!!" I said, laughing. Andy and Kellin came in to see what was going on. "Wow! Vic looks great! Good job, (y/n)!" Kellin said. "Ok, Vic, get your contacts in and your costume is complete. Anyone else need makeup? Or can I get ready now?" I asked. "We're good, you can get ready." Andy said. I ran to my room with my costume and changed quickly. I fixed the skirt of my dress and put the hood up. I looked in my mirror, I look so cute, I love!!! I put some grey eyeshadow on, some eyeliner, and red lipstick. Finally, the neon yellow contacts. Now that my face is on, I put my flats on and walked out of my room. As soon as I made eye contact with one of the guys, they started clapping. It's like homecoming all over again. "You look so pretty..." Kellin said. "You loOK SO FUCKING CUTE. OMG" Vic said, walking over to pet me, fangirling. "AAWWWW, LOOK AT THE EARS, AND TH-THE TAIL, AWWW." Andy fangirled as well. He walked over and snuggled his head in on the side of my neck. "Guys, it's 8:07pm, we should go. Who's neighborhood are we going to?" I asked. "We should go in my neighborhood, my brother's throwing a halloween party later, we should go." Vic suggested. "Sounds fun, we'll hit a couple houses on the way there." I said. We drove to Vic's neighborhood and started trick-or-treating. Yes, we received weird glances from other people, we were asked, "aren't you too old for this?", but we still got candy. XD. We got to Vic's house shortly. The house was pumping with music and people. There were like, 15 people. All guys, really. Mike came up to us and greeted us. "Hey, (y/n), wow, you're even prettier than Vic says you are." he said. "MIKE SHUT UP." Vic ordered. Mike laughed. "Welcome to the Fuentes residence, have fun, pretty one." he said and walked off to join his friends again. Mike talked to them for a little bit and they turned their heads to look at me and they all "OOOHHH" at me. Vic covered his face, blushing and I laughed. I sat on the couch and chatted with the guys about school and other things for a bit. I saw Mike come over with drinks in his hand. "Do you drink,(y/n)?" he asked me. "No, but...could I try it?" I asked. "Here, have this margarita. It's watermelon flavored." he handed me the drink. I took a sip and puckered. It's sour and definitely has alcohol in it. I'm sure I can handle it tho. XD I only had two...because they did the trick. I felt kinda funny...