Decisions, Decisions (Andy, Vic, Kellin X Reader)✔️

He's A Psycho

"Hello, Kellin." I greeted him. By the sound of my voice, his eyes widened, and his friendly smile went sinister. 

Kellin: Hey, baby! It feels so good to hear your voice again. Where were you two weeks ago? I invited you to court to watch the show. I'm sentenced to life in prison.

You: I was a depressed mess, I didn't leave my bed for anything. 

Kellin: oohhhh, so are you here to bail me out, sweetheart? 

You: no. How could you even think that? I'm here for an apology. 

Kellin: an apology for what? The killing of your beloved Vic? *places hand on window in between the both of you* babe, I was doing you a favor. I ripped him out of the picture so it would be you and I and no one else. You'd be so happy with me, (y/n). I would give you the world if that's what you wanted. 

You: Ugh! Kellin, please! You killed Vic out of jealousy, hatred, and rage. 

Kellin: I slaughtered for those reasons and for you. I'm not apologizing for what I did. I don't regret anything. 

My grip on the locket tightened, I sighed heavily and stood up out of my chair, making it squeak behind me. 

You: you're a sick, disgusting human being. It's great that you'll be behind bars for the rest of your life. 

Kellin: HAHA, I'm still determined to make you mine, (y/n). Yes, I'm locked up, but that'll never stop me. 

You: Bye, Kellin.

Kellin: I'll see you soon, (y/n). 

I walked out of jail, shivering a bit from what Kellin said. "I'll see you soon, (y/n)." He's a psycho. I called Andy as soon as I got home. 

Andy: hello?

You: Andy, I just talked to Kellin. 

Andy: what did he say? 

You: I said I wanted an apology and he said he didn't regret anything. But dude, when he  saw me, it was like the crazy came back to him. He still hasn't given up on me. 

Andy: did he threaten you? 

You: he said he'd see me soon. Idk how to feel about that.

Andy: I wouldn't worry about that, he's no escape artist. But how bout I get your mind off of that? Are you doing anything tomorrow? 

You: uuuhhh....nnaaahhh

Andy: well, wanna see the 4th of July fireworks with me? 

You: that'd be great. Thank you. 

Andy: awesome, I'll pick you up at 8:00pm. 

You: ok, I'll be ready. 

Andy: see ya then

You: byee.

Andy always knew how to make me feel better. Now we're gonna see beautiful fireworks tomorrow. I'm so excited! I love having fun with Andy! He's so fun, hilarious, caring, sweet...he has  such a cute smile...I love his laugh...his beautiful blue eyes. Wait...I've thought the same things about Vic. I loved Vic's personality and looks...now I'm thinking the same with Andy? Well, Vic...your plan has fallen into place. I think I'm admitting that I like Andy more than a friend. 

*the next day around 8:00PM* 

I pulled  band tee over my head, quickly put some shorts on, and tied my hair up in a messy bun. I took a nap and slept past my 7:30PM alarm. Andy's waiting for me outside. I always was like a bear in hibernation when I slept. I hurriedly poured some food and water for Raina and ran outside my door. Andy honked his horn for me to hurry the fuck up XD. I yanked his car door open, threw myself in the passenger seat, and off we went to see the fireworks. 

"I'm sorry I wasn't ready, I slept past my alarm." I apologized. "It's ok, it's only 8:15, we still have time." He calmed me. 

After 10 minutes of driving, Andy parked next to 'Carl' s Ice Cream'. "Oh, are we getting ice cream?" I asked. "Yea, I thought it would go nice with fireworks." Andy laughed. Whoop, there's the laugh I love so much. I stepped out of Andy's car, walked to the front of Carl's, and  got in line for ice cream. Carl's is one of those places with traditional vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate ice cream, basic sundaes, and  basic milkshakes. That's ok, I love strawberry. 

There were large, cement blocks in front of Carl's that people use as seats, so Andy and I sat down and waited for the fireworks to start exploding. "My parents always took me here to watch the fireworks when I was  a kid. It was so fun. My dad actually took my mom here when they were friends in  high  school. He asked her out here too." Andy laughed.  "Aww, that's really cute. Thanks for inviting me." I awed. I scooted a little closer to Andy. Then, I heard the first explosion of the night. The sky filled with beautiful colors and intricate designs of fire. Everyone ohhhed  and aaaaed at the pretty sparks. 

(Andy's P. O. V.)

I watched (y/n) more than the fireworks. She's the most beautiful girl in the world. I can't help but to  stare. Her eyes filled with color as the fireworks sparked in the sky. Her smile widened, her face held an awed expression from all the amazing designs the fireworks gave off, I...I love her so much. I would like for her to go out with me, but I don't know if she's ready to move on from Vic. It's been a month since he...ended. I don't wanna make her upset by asking her out. But what if she's ready? I would make her really happy. I stared into space as I thought of what to do. 

(Your P. O. V.)

Multiple fireworks sprayed the sky with lights, I could tell this was the grand finale, the fireworks are giving the sky all they've got. And then it all stopped completely. Everyone around me cheered and clapped. "That was awesome, wasn't it?!?!" Andy asked me. "I LOVED IT, IT WAS AMAZING!!" I answered. I finished my ice cream and Andy took me back home. 

Andy walked me up to my apartment. "Well, goodnight, Andy. This was great." I told him. I was just  about to close the door, but Andy kept it open with his hand. "Uh...(y/n).." he started. "Yess?" I asked.  "I need to tell you something." He let out. "What's that?" I asked. He let out a heavy sigh and spoke. "I love you, (y/n). I love you, I LOVE (Y/N)!!! I love every single thing about you. You're my everything. You're beautiful, amazing, sweet, loving, truly an amazing girl. I've loved you ever since you were seated next to me in math. Remember? I've loved you ever since then. I've died inside so many times trying to hold my feelings in, but I couldn't keep them in anymore. I HAD to tell you how I felt. So there you go...I love you." I smiled as he admitted  his love for me....again. "Andy...I honesty feel the same about you, I love you too. I really, REALLY do." I blurted out. "Will you be my gir-" I cut Andy off with a kiss. There's his answer. I wrapped my arms around his neck, and wrapped my legs around his waist. Andy and I just couldn't kiss anymore cuz we're giggling and smiling so much. I nuzzled my nose under his chin as he held me up. He was so happy, he spun around slowly and we kept giggling. He soon placed me down gently and held my face in his hands. We rubbed noses and smiled. I placed my hands on his waist. He leaned down for another kiss and I gladly gave it to him. I also gave him multiple little kisses on his cheeks and one more kiss on his mouth while I twirled his hair. "It's late, (y/n), I gotta go, BUT I'll come back tomorrow, my love." He said sadly. "Awww, ok. I'll see you tomorrow then....just..one more...kiss." I pleaded. He smiled and pulled my waist towards him. His soft lips connected with mine and I savored every second. "Ok, bye. I love you." He said. "I love you too...bye." I waved goodbye to him. 

(A/n: next chapter will be on the same night)