Decisions, Decisions (Andy, Vic, Kellin X Reader)✔️

My Worst Nightmare

I tore the note apart and drove to Kellin's house as quickly as possible. I parked my car on the side of the road and walked up to Kellin's front door, shyly. Ok, (y/n), you can do this. Do it for Vic. I pumped myself up and knocked on the door. Minutes passed and still nothing. I decided to break the door down. I went all the way to Kellin's front yard and sprinted into his door, the door gave out and I fell inside. THAT HURT SO MUCH, HOLY SHIT, OW. I got up and dusted myself off. "KELLIN!....HEY, KELLIN!" I called. I heard footsteps running up the basement stairs and a door opening. "Well, well, well...if it isn't little, miss (y/n)...whoa, what happened to my door???" he asked. "Forget about the fucking door...where's Vic?" I asked. "Come with me..." he motioned down to his basement. "I'm not going down there unless you can prove to me that Vic is actually down there." I said. He walked over to the basement door and called, "oh, Viccy-poo!!! Call up to your girlfriend, she's here for youuu!!!" he said. "(Y/N)! Please be careful! Don't let him hurt you!" Vic screamed. A worried look washed onto my face, I pushed past Kellin and ran down the stairs. I went through a hallway with one door at the end. The door was wide open, I walked in and the first thing I see is Vic. He has slash marks on his chest, arms, legs, he's in his boxers. His lip and nose were bleeding, his hair was on the ground, he still had some tufts on his head. He's tied up to the wall...chained. "....VIC! NO, NO. WHAT DID HE DO TO YOU!?!?!" I asked, full grief filled my body. I fell to my knees in front of him, holding his face in my hands, tears bursting out of my eyes. "Oh, Vic....I'm so sorry. I got you into this. I chose you and now Kellin has hurt you." I apologized. "It's not your fault, darling...Kellin's just a psycho who wants you all to himself. At least I was able to be with you in these last moments." he said. "DON'T SAY THAT, YOU'RE GONNA LIVE." I said. I kissed him softly and his head hung low. Kellin came in the room. "AWWW, SO CUTE. YOU GET TO SEE HIM DIE. TOGETHER FOREVER, RIGHT!?!?" Kellin laughed cruelly. I hugged Vic and cried into his shoulder. He can't hug me back, I long for his arms around me. Kellin yanked me off of Vic and I fell to the cement floor. "If you want him to live longer, I suggest you stay away from him." Kellin said. I slowly got up and walked to the other side of the room. I sniffled and wiped my tears. "(y/n)...he's gonna die...you staying away from him will stall his death." Kellin said. "You sick monster, Kellin please stop. Please...untie him and I'll drive him to the hospital." I pleaded. "MMMM....NOPE. Unless...you break up with him...and go out with me. You will go out with me for a while and Vic will be right here in the basement." Kellin said. "I'd never..." I started. But I thought of Vic. If I go out with Kellin, Vic can go to the hospital and live. "I...ok. I'll...go out...with you. BUT...untie him NOW." I said. "He doesn't get to die? No, he will die (y/n). You either go by my rules or no one's." he said. I wept and walked to him slowly, he held his arms out for me. I walked into his arms and pushed him. I then kicked his shin, he fell to his knees. I kicked him in the face and his head went back and hit the wall. He was knocked out, laying on the floor. I ran to Vic and he smiled weakly. I tried breaking the chain off of the wall. I remembered what I did to escape, I need scissors. "I'll look for scissors, I'll be right back!" I told Vic. He nodded. I ran up to Kellin's room and looked under his bed for the scissors and they were still there! I ran back downstairs and Kellin had a gun to Vic's head. Kellin turned to look at me. "Put those damn scissors down. Slide them to me." he ordered. I dropped the scissors on the ground and kicked them to him. "Your attempt to escape won't work this time. Say goodbye to your beloved Vic." he said. I crawled to Vic and held his hand. "Don't fucking touch him." Kellin said. I let Vic go and said, "Vic...I love you. Forever. I love you." He looked up and tears streamed down his face. "I love you too, (y/n)...I love you so mu-" a gunshot went off. I felt the blood splatter on my face. "....N-NNOOOOO!!!!!!" I screamed. "HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA" Kellin laughed. I took Vic's hand and broke the chains. He fell to the ground, lifeless. I hyperventilated, I'm panicking, this did not just happen! Kellin, made me look at him and he punched me in the jaw, I flew back and hit the wall behind me. I slid down the wall, slowly. I shut my eyes and sat there. I felt someone touch my arm, I looked down and Vic was pulling on me. Didn't he just die? He sat up completely and shook me by my shoulders. "(y/n), I need you to open your eyes." he said sternly. "My eyes are open, Vic." I said. He shook me harder, "YOU NEED TO WAKE UP, WAKE UP NOW, (Y/N), WAKE UUUPPP!!!!!" He shouted. My eyes shot open to see Vic shaking me to wake up. "(Y/n), wake up!" he screamed. "I..I'm up." I said. I realized I was in his bed with him, I'm still naked. I was dreaming, I had a nightmare. A horrible, terrifying nightmare. "You were screaming and talking in your sleep...What did you dream about that was so scary???" he asked. "I...you weren't here, Kellin took you. He threw you into his basement and I found you. Kellin killed you..." I explained. "(y/n)...he'll never get me, it's ok. " Vic assured me. I started crying, "It--it felt so real. I thought I lost you, Viccy." He hugged me, laid me back down and kissed my cheek, telling me that everything will be ok. I took Vic's hand and held it as I tried to go back to sleep. If anyone takes him, or if he gets up...I'll know. I slowly went back to sleep, afraid of what else I could dream about.