Pt.2 of this town
(Don't worry y'all are gonna get want you wanted! 😉)
&& also TYSFM for 9k reads! It's honestly astonishing how far I've made it, considering how crappy my writing is! It means a lot to me y'all ❣
Spencer quickly slide out of her Ford Explorer and to the door of the Hastings house.
She had told Patrick that she was staying at Alison's, having a girls night. When in reality, she was naked in her ex-boyfriends bed making love.
She loved Toby, she truly did. But the moment he feel asleep, she knew what she had done wasn't right. She didn't deserve someone like Toby, who would love and cherish her.
After all the shit she had put him through, he still wanted her.
"Where were you last night?" Patrick asked, breaking Spencer from her thoughts.
Why is he up? It's 6 o'clock in the morning? Those worried thoughts raced through Spencer's mind. She though she would be able to climb into bed quickly without Patrick waking up. But now it's too late for that.
And she didn't look like she was just at Ali's house having a sleepover. Her bra and underwear were in a tight fist in her left hand, her makeup was smudged, her hair looked horrendous, and she had her stilettos in her right hand.
"I already told you, I was at Alison's." She said smoothly. After the few years of having to deal with the cops and A, she had gained control of staying calm when needed.
"Well I called Ali last night, I tried calling you first, I wanted to see how you were, but you wouldn't respond to my text or calls. So I called Ali instead."
A lump formed in Spencer's throat, she had been caught. Not as smooth as she thought.
"Where were you Spencer? Wait, no, let me guess, after that lunch with that ex of yours, you decided to hang out a little longer. You kissed. Began feeling things you haven't felt since you two split up. You decided, hey, might as well. Text me, making up some stupid lie that you should have put a little bit more effort into, and then fucked him all night. That's how the story goes, right?"
Tears formed in Spencer's eyes. "You can't choose who you want to be with. It's taken me a while, but now, I've realized it. The heart wants what it wants. I left him, I didn't want to, but I did. I left him so I wouldn't be that girl, that girl who leaves her fiancé for her ex-boyfriend. I'm still in love with him, Patrick, and nothing's gonna change that. I thought if I came back and acted like nothing happened, everything would be okay. Sure, I wouldn't be as happy. But as least it's something."
"Your such a slut." Patrick grumbled pushing past her and up to the stairs.
"I want my ring back, and anything else I gave you, the jewelry, everything."
"Fine." She said effortlessly, sliding the ring of her slim finger and plopping into his hand. She did the same with the diamond chain necklace and bracelet he had given her.
"That's all I have with me, I'll ship the rest back to you later. Now if you excuse me, I have to speak to someone." She said prancing out of the House.
••••
The look of his crystal blue eyes that were now mixed with a hint of red broke her heart.
"Did you forgot something?" He asked with a strained voice, obvious that he had been recently been crying, hard.
"Yeah, actually, I did." She said standing up on her toes and pressing her mouth to his.
"Leaving you was the biggest mistake I've ever made. I need you, and only you. Your my everything Toby. And I'm so sorry."
A small, happy grin appeared on his face. He swept her from her feet and shut the door behind them.
"Promise me you'll never leave me, ever again. No matter what." He said, making a line of kisses down her neck.
"I promise."
