5sos Preferences

Preference #38 He's your brother and he catches you with his bandmate Part 2

He's your brother and he catches you with his bandmate Part 2

Ashton: Michael and you both got dressed as quick as you could, still out of breath. Ashton was beyond pissed. You went downstairs and Ashton was sitting there with the other boys. They looked like they felt very awkward right now, but you were glad they were there, to be honest. If it was just you Ashton would definitely not be a calm as he was acting right now. “Someone explain this now.” He said in a serious tone, scaring you a little bit. You have never seen him this mad before. “It wasn’t what it looked like…” Michael started. Not a good way to start. “Really because it fucking looked like if I hadn’t walked in there that you would’ve ‘hooked up’ with my little sister. She’s my fucking sister, not some girl you picked up.” Ashton said, borderline yelling. “No! That’s what I mean! We aren’t ‘hooking up’ we’re, um, together.” Michael said awkwardly and Ashton’s face softened. “Aw you guys why didn’t you tell me.” He cooed bringing you into the most awkward threeway hug there could ever be. “We thought you’d be mad…”

Calum: You pulled a shirt over your head, answered the door, and Ashton was standing there. “Hey…” He said awkwardly and you stepped aside to let him in. “I really like you… A lot.” He blurted out after a few seconds of silence. “I like you too.” You smiled confidently. “I asked Calum and he said it would be fine if I, um, asked you out on a date, so that’s, um, what I’m here for. I mean, um, that’s what I’m doing right now.” He said and you raised your eyebrows, smirking a little. He was adorable when he was nervous. “Don’t be so nervous.” You said, signaling him to go on. He took a breath and said, “Would you like to go on a date tonight?” He said and you nodded. “Great. I’ll pick you up at 7.” He smiled. “It’s 7 right now, Ash.” You reminded him. “Oh… Right. How about we just leave whenever you’re ready.” He said and you laughed and nodded.

Michael: Great. Ashton had to interrupt right in the middle of what you’ve been wanting to here for a good year. “Hey.” You fake smiled. It wasn’t long after that when Calum got here and Michael got out of the shower. “(Y/N), wanna come with us?” Michael asked. “Oh, yeah. Sure.” You said. You weren’t sure what it was that you were doing since you were zoning out the whole time, but you figured how boring could it be? You all started walking up to the studio, and they were going to record some songs. After a while you started getting thirsty. “I’m gonna go get something to drink, anybody want anything?” They all wanted water. “I’ll come help.” Luke said. When you got to the vending machine you put in a dollar, and Luke turned you to face him, taking you by a surprise. He pressed his lips against yours and you pulled your hands from side, cupping his face. “I’ve wanted to do that for so long.” He said. “Will you be my girlfriend?” He smiled down at you. “Neh, I’m good.” You said and he laughed and shook his head, grabbing your hand. “I’m still taking that as a yes.” He whispered in your ear. He kept your hand held in his and lead you back to the room they were recording in. “Where is the water?” Calum asked, confused. “They were out.” Luke said, smirking. “Are you guys…” Michael asked. “If that’s ok with you.” I said. “I don’t really care, but instead of offering water to go makeout you guys could just tell us and not get our hopes up.” Michael laughed at your blushing face, but Luke just kissed your cheek.

Luke: “That’s really not what I wanted to walk in on…” Luke said, standing in the doorway. “Luke! Um… Hey.” You said, pushing Calum off of you, trying to play it cool. “Calum, please tell me this isn’t what I think it is.” Luke said putting his head in his hands. “That depends… What do you think it is?” Calum asked skeptically. “I think that you were about to fuck my little sister, and if that’s right, then I am going to kill you.” He said. “It’s not! I swear. I mean maybe if you haven’t have walked in- I mean no! Never! Well maybe not never, but no!” “Calum just shut up.” You rolled your eyes. That was not helping a bit. “Calum’s my boyfriend.” You told Luke. “Right… Then carry on. Actually no. Let’s go Calum.” Luke said, dragging Calum out of your room, leaving you laughing.