The Unwanted Daughter [An SVU and Bensler Fan Fic]

-Thirty-Eight-

"Don't you dare try to act like this is my fault, Bay. If Liv or that baby gets harmed, it's your fault." Maureen spat at her youngest sister.

"You are the one down here shit talking me to my mother! Now, if you have anything else to say to me, say it to my face. Don't be a pussy." Bay spat. Elliot watched his daughters and could see the anger in their eyes. He knew that he should've stopped this even before it started, but he knew that maybe this is the blood letting that could get rid of the fighting in his family.

"First you say that you want nothing to do with Loren, but you run straight to her once Liv and Dad call you out on your slutty ways." Maureen spat.

"I'm not a slut, Maureen! I had sex with my boyfriend, which is a very normal thing for people to do! And if I recall what Lizzie said about you, you might be the slut. Sleeping around when you were younger." Bay spoke, smirking the last part. Maureen stood up from where she sat on the couch and walked over to her sister. Maureen was taller than Bay, and much stronger. But that didn't scare Bay away. 

She was fighting because she needed this to stop. Before the newest Stabler arrives.

"What did you just call me?" Maureen growled.

"A slut. Do you want to argue otherwise? Because I slept with a guy that I'm dating and in love with. Sleeping around isn't what you call it when you are in a relationship with the guy you fuck."

"You will regret that, Bay." Maureen huffed, before going to shove her sister. Elliot stepped in right then, because Bay was still not fully recovered. She didn't need to hurt herself again.

"Okay, that's enough. Maureen go up to your room and cool off."

"Don't take her side!" Maureen yelled.

"I'm not taking sides. We will talk about this later. Go."

[=]

Maureen went up into her room and slammed the door. Bay slowly climbed the stairs and shut herself in her room too. Bay went back to working on homework, while Maureen called her mother and bitched about Bay.

"What do we do if they can't make up?" Lizzie asked, as the rest of the family sat down and started to eat dinner. They had set aside plates for Maureen and Bay.

"I don't know." Elliot sighed, as he looked over at his wife. Olivia kept just pushing her food around on her plate.

"I want to be around to spend time with the baby." Kathleen breathed, and Olivia reached her hand out and grabbed Kathleen's hand and squeezed it gently.

"Just because they are fighting doesn't mean that Bay is fighting with you guys. You will be able to be around." Olivia replied.

"Livvie?" Eli asked, and Olivia looked at him.

"Yeah?"

"They scared me earlier." He frowned. Olivia bit her lip before excusing herself from the table. 

She didn't want to talk about the fighting earlier. All she wanted to do was thinking about possibly getting her blended family back together. She loved all of Elliot's kids, and she didn't want to lose Maureen because she has very bad feelings towards her sister. Olivia was Bay's mother, legally, and she didn't want to lose her to depression again.

"Did I say something wrong?" Eli asked, and Elliot shook his head.

"No, bud. You are okay. Liv is just upset. I'll talk to her after dinner."

[=]

Olivia didn't end up finishing dinner. She just sat in her bedroom upstairs and cried. It wasn't just her emotions being weird because of the baby. She was just upset about the girls fighting. Bay had went downstairs to face her sister because she had walked into Bay's room while she was still crying. She hated herself for not calming down before going into Bay's room.

"What are you thinking about?" Elliot breathed, and Olivia swallowed hard.

"It's my fault that they girls started to fight."

"Why would you say that?" Elliot asked, and Olivia frowned.

"Because I went to see Bay after Maureen started to say those things about her. I was still crying so she knew what was happening. She also heard everything that Mo said."

"It's not your fault."

"Do you ever wonder what life would've been like if we didn't hook up? Like if I ended up just taking care of Bay? Adopted her by myself?"

"Life would suck because I wouldn't have you."

"Everything will be better before the baby comes, right?"

"Yeah, I can promise you that. And until this all gets fixed, you and I will see the kids outside of the house."

"No, I want this fixed tonight, El. Before the kids go home."

"They are leaving soon."

"Then go fix it, Elliot. Go fix it now so we don't mess this family up anymore than it already is."

[=]

With direct orders from his wife, Elliot walked into Maureen's room. He was ready to tell her to make up with her little sister before this stress causes harm to Olivia.

"Get out, side taker." Maureen huffed. She sounded like a 12 year old, not a freshman in college.

"Okay, that hurt me deeply, Mo." He huffed.

"Why are you even in here? Shouldn't you be praising the slut next door?"

"Okay, stop calling your sister a slut."

"But-"

"No, Maureen. Please, just stop. You don't need to be friends with her, but you two need to apologize to each other."

"Why? Why should I apologize to her for saying the truth."

"Because what you said wasn't the truth. I thought it was when she first ran away, but I was wrong. We made up, and so do you two."

"Then go tell her to apologize to me for calling me those mean names."

"Then you need to apologize to her for calling her equally mean names." Elliot replied. Maureen shook her head.

"I'm sorry for what I said, Maureen." Bay breathed, from where she stood in the hall. Maureen looked up from where she had been staring at her crossed arms and found her sister.

"Why did you run away to Loren of all people?"

"Because you didn't like me. Because Wes wanted nothing to do with me. Because Mom and Dad didn't want me here either. I had to go somewhere, and I didn't want to sleep on the streets again. So yes, I'm sorry for calling you a slut and a pussy. And I'm sorry for messing everything up from the start. But I'm not leaving your life any time soon because I'm your sister."

Hey guys! Thanks for reading and please vote and comment all of your feedback below! :D