July 5th, 2019
Noen Eubanks
Nothing had happened after those two weeks. Caleb and Ella got into an argument two days after they made love the second time. So, that being said, for the past couple weeks they've been ignoring each other. He would read Legend of Zelda books, she would read Beauty and the Beast or mystery books with a tint of romance in it. Ashley has came over but, she's caught onto Ella and Caleb fighting. Which meant the house was always super quiet. She would come home after work, make eye contact with Caleb and hide straight into her bedroom. When we were in the dog form. She'd leave us outside unless it rained.
Back to what I was saying... Ella ended up having a conversation with Ashley about Caleb. She said that they were arguing over Ashton but I felt like deep down there was more then that.
I knew it had to do with Ella. She didn't want to keep being affectionate with Caleb when she was technically still being with someone else. Caleb wanted to know what he was to her ... Ella being the way she is ...
Um... I'll just go back in time and see what happened that caused them not to talk at this previous moment.
~ Two weeks ago ~
"Caleb, I can't continue this anymore," Ella said sitting next to Caleb on the sofa. He pauses the movie he was watching and turns looking at her.
"What're you talking about?" He asked her. She ran a hand through her hair frustrated by what she's about to say.
"I mean 'us' Caleb... I still haven't broken up with Ashton... I'm technically cheating on him with you.." She did have a point but, she should've dumped Ashton when he was at her house last.
"You could've broke up with him when you confronted him about the incident but, you didn't. You also told me you didn't care about cheating on him, Ella!" He was beginning to raise his voice.
"Caleb, it's still wrong!"
"Ella, you shouldn't speak if you're not going to mean what you say.."
"I am so furious with him I can't even speak to him..." Ella said.
"You're infuriating me by still being with him!" Caleb raised his tone glaring at Ella. She looked at him highly offended and hurt by his words.
"You don't even care-"
"Do you even fancy me? What am I to you? Am I just your Play Date? Someone you fool around with then drop whenever you please? Or get enough pleasure off of me?"
Ella stands up glaring at him, "How dare you speak such a tone with me! I'm not a whore! You're definitely not one of my conquests cause I lost my virginity to you! I would never stoop that low, Caleb!"
"You never answered two of my questions, you brat," Caleb bursts.
"What did you just call me?" Ella asked.
"I called you a brat..."
"Look whose talking ... I gave you a home, food, a room to sleep in, clothes, movies, a life? And how do you repay me? By treating me like absolute shit like the arrogant egotistical asshole you are!"
"Arrogant? Egotistical? Says the bitch who made rules ... Noen and I are human! We like going outside and not having to worry about whether someone would discover if he and I are huskies or not!"
"I'm not a bitch." She defends herself.
"When we first kissed you ignored me for weeks, you told me I'm just your dog, you sleep with me not even giving me a definition to what I could be to you, you still consider Ashton your boyfriend, and you leave Noen and I in the fucking heat all day while you work or party or whatever it may be, and you still make us eat dog food!"
"I barely knew you when I called you my dog, and I apologized for even calling you that! Secondly, I panicked after we first kissed, you're the one who didn't stop it and it was completely consensual, and you are huskies by day, humans by night... I don't want y'all to waste my money after I bought dog food-"
"By Day, By Night," He said... " I'm still human but, if you wanna stay with Ashton who sent men to rape you ... Have fun..." He went into our room slamming the door behind him causing Ella to jump. She stood there angry letting Caleb have the last word.
~ Now ~
That is why they both are being ignorant. I hear the door open so I rush out of my bedroom to see Ella and Ashton walk in with Ashley behind them. Ella and Ashton walk into her bedroom. Caleb glaring at them both the entire time. Ashley walks towards me watching Ashton intently.
"Why is he here?" Ashley had asked me. I shrug not knowing why either.
-
"You are really going to believe them over me?!" Ashton yelled throughout the entire house. Ashley and I exited my bedroom going out into the living room.
"They're my friends, Ashton," He looks around seeing all of us watching. He shakes his head at her. "It's over, Ashton." Caleb's facial expression had the word 'shocked' scribbled all over. He ran his hand through his hair.
"I hope you have fun with her ... She doesn't love you," Ashton gets directly in Caleb's face. Caleb doesn't say anything he just remains deadpanned. Ashton shakes his head chuckling evilly.
"No response? You usually stick up for a bitch like her," It happened so fast I was stunned. His eyes were glowing yellow while he held Ashton up against the wall.
"Don't project on me because you know damn well how she feels about you. She just broke up with you. If I were you, I'd Leave," Caleb said. Ashton looked afraid but, now he just discovered our secret. And, so did Ashley.
"You're a Werewolf! A hideous monster," Ashton cried out in agony. Caleb's eyes glowed bright and it was the first time in a long time that I've seen this occur. Ella looked frightened by him as well.
"Go!" Caleb yells letting go of Ashton. Ashton rushes out of Ella's house slamming the door. He looks down closing his eyes shaking his head. When he looks back up his eyes are bright blue color. He turns to Ella hoping she'd say something. She just stares at him not knowing what to say.
"Is it true, Ella?" Ashley asked Ella. Caleb and I look at Ella in panic. Ashton could have someone come after us, murder us... Ashton was capable of anything knowing our secret now.
"Yeah... It is," Ella looked away in response afterwards. She kept her hands held together. Ashley rushes to the bathroom and all you hear is the sound of her puking her guts out. All three of us stand there listening because she had forgotten to close the door. At some point we hear her cough and the toilet flush. We hear her heels click into the living room again.
"Ella, why didn't you tell me? ... It explains all the suspicious acts and how inconspicuous your behavior has been lately I..." Ashley goes to the sofa setting herself down processing everything.
"They didn't want anyone to find out... I wanted to Ash... I did," Ella sits next to her. Caleb watches the scene in front of them then exits the room. I follow after him but, he closes the door behind him. I figured out he couldn't get over the fact that he risked his identity because he stood up for Ella. Why?
Because, he loved her.
_________________________________________
(A/N: FINALLYYY OMG Ella had finally ended things with Ashton. Smh. I'm currently re-editing my story or giving more depth to the story so it's more interesting. I hope you all enjoy!)
YOU ARE READING
By Day, By Night || Caleb Finn & Noen Eubanks (UNDER EDITING)
Werewolf"It's hard to explain," I say to her. "Really?!" She crosses her arms against her chest, waiting impatiently to explain. Why two guys are basically naked in her house.. "Ella, please..." I say desperately. She presses her lips together as she take...
