FIFTY-ONE

2.1K 38 12
                                    


Hailey sets down her phone, making her way into the living room where Ben was currently seated. Taking a deep breath, she sits down next to him without a word, concerning him.

"I think we need to talk." Hailey speaks with a small smile, taking his hand in hers. "Maybe it's just me but, I don't know, are you happy? With me?"

"Of course i'm happy." Ben replies almost instantly, his brows furrowed at her question. "Why are we having this conversation?"

"Do you feel like something's missing sometimes?"

Silence engulfs them for a minute as the blonde boy thinks, he wasn't sure if they were having an honest conversation or if these were just doubts she's having about them. Ultimately making the decision to be completely honest with her, for the sake of both their happinesses.

"Honestly? Sometimes, yeah." he sighs, making the girl let out a breath of relief. "How, uh, how long have you felt like that?"

"A little while after getting to Italy, I think."

"Hailey, I am happy with you, I swear and I do love you but-"

"We're just not in love. I know."

They sat there holding each other's hands, basking in the new situation they found themselves in. They were both somewhat upset over their, now finished, time together but at the same time, they were happy it ended like this. With both of them at a mutual agreement.

"I don't want us to be strangers." she confesses, turning slightly to look at him better. "You're an amazing person, Ben, and I still want you in my life. If that's okay."

"It's more than okay, Hailey." he chuckles, pulling the girl into a smothering hug. "But you have to promise me something."

"What?"

"Talk things out with Rudy. Honestly, it's painful watching you two interact."

Hailey only laughs at his words, knowing he was probably speaking about last night. She had to admit that as much as she wanted to, she was still scared. Scared of the Pankow boys indecisiveness and scared of getting hurt again, she wasn't sure if she could put herself through that.

















hello ladies

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.

hello ladies

bailey babe
i feel like this a very long overdue gc

aves<3
all of us were too lazy to make one

that is true
ANYWAYS
wait
where's Madelyn

bailey babe
sucking chases face off i think

maddie
i'm right here you bitch

aves<3
okay but were you?

maddie
that is none of your business

ANYWAYS
i will be picking all of you ladies up at 7
so be ready

aves<3
i mean sure
but what's the occasion

we're gonna be celebrating my newly single
status

bailey babe
YOUR WHAT?

aves<3
oh my gosh you did it??

maddie
did what?
what happened?

it was coming on for a while now
it was completely mutual
he's still my bestie
moving on

bailey babe
you know rudy's gonna flip right?

i know
but let's not make this night about boys okay?
and that includes chase maddie

maddie
i didn't even say anything!









AN: act two is almost over!!

HISTORY☆RUDY PANKOWWhere stories live. Discover now