This Side of Paradise (Peter Parker x Reader)

8. Party

"I don't wanna seem the way I do, but im confident when Im with you.."

Y/n's POV

You were walking down the bustling sidewalk on your way to school when MJ's voice called your name. You turned and greeted her with a smile as she walked with you,

"So, Y/n, we're best friends right?" She asked fiddling with her hands. You responded with a nod and motioned for her to continue, "So why didnt you tell me your a superhero?" She asked whispering the last part. You stopped walking taken aback by her question,

"What? No. What makes you say that?" You asked laughing nervously,

"Cut the crap Y/n, I saw you last night." You stifled a laugh and continued walking, you couldn't help but feel somewhat relieved. 

"So, you really saw me?" you asked, seeking some confirmation.

MJ nodded, her gaze focused ahead. "Yeah, I did. It was late at night, and I happened to be passing by when I saw you walking down that alley. At first, I wasn't sure if it was really you. I mean, who would have thought my best friend is secretly involved in something like that?"

A small smile tugged at the corners of your lips as you glanced at MJ. "I guess my secret life isn't as secret as I thought."

She chuckled softly. "No, it's not. But don't worry, your secret's safe with me. I won't tell anyone."

A sense of gratitude washed over you. It was reassuring to know that you had someone you could trust with such a significant part of your life. "Thanks, MJ. I appreciate that. And don't worry, I'll make sure you're not involved too much. I don't want to put you in any danger."

MJ smirked, her eyes glinting with a mixture of curiosity and excitement. "Well, just because I don't want to be involved doesn't mean I'm not interested. You know I have a knack for uncovering mysteries."

You chuckled, realizing that MJ's relentless curiosity would always find a way to push through. "I'm well aware of that. Just promise me you won't go poking around too much. The less you know, the better."

She raised an eyebrow, a mischievous glimmer in her eyes. "No promises, but I'll try to restrain myself. After all, I don't want to spoil the excitement of your 'double life." She said making air quotes

You shook your head, chuckling at her persistence. "You're something else, MJ. But seriously, thank you for understanding and for keeping my secret. It means a lot to me."

MJ shrugged, a small smile gracing her lips. "Hey, what are best friends for, right?."

***

As Steve Rogers appeared on the screen, clad in his iconic red, white, and blue suit, you struggled to stifle a laugh. 

Ned, who was seated next to Peter, leaned in and asked if he knew Captain America. Sitting right behind them, alongside MJ, you caught every word of their conversation.

"Yeah, we met. I stole his shield," Peter replied, causing you to shake your head in disbelief. The audacity and lightheartedness in his response left you both impressed and amused.

The attention of the room shifted as Captain America, or rather Steve Rogers, announced that the gym teacher, Mr. Wilson, would be conducting the Captain America fitness challenge. The screen changed, displaying a slide with the caption "sit-ups." You couldn't help but roll your eyes at the prospect of physical exercise.

The room fell silent, and the thoughts of your classmates bombarded your mind, giving you a slight headache. Mr. Wilson, observing the crowd's reaction, acknowledged the tension by remarking, "Thank you, Captain. Pretty sure this guy is a war criminal, but I have to show these videos. It's required by the state." His comment hung in the air, creating an uncomfortable atmosphere.