Various Male characters x Male/GN/FTM Reader Oneshots

Crush - Arthur Morgan x Gender Neutral Reader

Y/N had only been in the gang for a year, but they were a respected member and a great asset. They fought well and got along with everyone, well almost everyone. You wondered why Arthur was distant with you, He'd only really talk to you if It's regarding a mission or dinner is ready.
Y/N hung out in their tent, sitting on their cot and did their best to remember if they did anything to piss off Arthur. Maybe, It was the time they got caught during a robbery ? The mission was a success but they did fuck up.

Arthur was done doing a small mission just outside of Rhodes, he decided to set up tent and relax. He gave his horse an apple. He goes through his satchel and pulls out his journal and a pencil. Arthur started sketching. He drew some flowers, his horse, and then you. He kept erasing the drawing of Y/N and trying it again. You were so beautiful, he needed to capture you perfectly.

Arthur returned back to camp two days later. It was night time, and everyone was asleep. Well, nearly everyone. Arthur headed to his tent to get some shut eye when someone grabbed his arm. "Hey, Arthur! How was the mission? Good I hope. Anyway, can we talk?" Y/N smiled, doing their best to be quiet. "I- Uh, what is it, Y/N?" Arthur asked nervously. His cheeks turned red, the darkness hiding it. "Come with me." Y/N dragged Arthur to his tent. "Hey! What the hell are you doing?!" He whisper yelled. "What the hell are you doing?! Why are you avoiding me? Did I do something to offend you?" They whisper yelled back. "No.." Arthur said. "Tell me. Arthur, This is getting annoying. You need to tell me what's going on-" "I like you okay!" Arthur interrupted, his cheeks blushing even harder. "What? I like you too, Arthur." Y/N was extremely flustered and confused, they weren't sure if Arthur was saying it in a friendly way or something else.. "No, I love you. I've always had." Arthur confessed, he covered his face with his hands. Y/N moved his hands out of his face and kissed him. "I love you too. You should have told me in the first place."