Boyfriends sister pt2

2.8K 72 15
                                    

A/n: some of yall wanted a pt 2 to this so here ya go! Hope u enjoy!

Summary: more than one night

Wc: 1621

Warnings: arguing, makeout
------------------
It definetley wasn't only one night. Hailee and I have continued to hook up whenever we get the chance to.

I feel bad for cheating on Griffin since he is a nice guy and treats me well but I can't resist Hailee. She's like a drug once you try it you can't get enough of her.

"Hailee" I moan as she traces kisses on my neck

"Yes baby?" She pulls away from my neck looking in my eyes

"I-I'm not feeling it tonight--can we just watch a movie?" I stutter playing with the hem of her shirt

"Of course we can" she kisses my forehead smiling "Don't ever feel pressured to sleep with me... it's okay if you don't want to" I smile at her words as we snuggle on my bed close together

As she holds me another wave of guilt washes over me. Griffin, my boyfriend is at work and I'm here cuddling with his sister in a not so friendly way. My body tensing up at the thought.

"Y/n you okay?" Hailee whispers

"Hm?" I snap our of my thoughts and turn my head facing her

"Are you okay? Your body tensed up" She asks a soft smile playing on her lips

"I feel guilty" I exhale, her face scrunching up in confusion

"Guilty? She asks, her delicate fingers tucking a strand of hair behind my ear. I unconsciously lean into her touch closing my eyes and taking a deep breath

"Yeah" I breathe "I'm dating your brother and I feel guilty for doing this with you" My eyes open immediately finding hers. Her eyes look into mine as a hint of anger mixed with sadness becomes evident in them

"I know" She says "I-I we can stop I do--" she rambles, tears pooling at the brim of her eyes

"Hey baby, calm down" I softly interupt her "I don't want to stop"

"Y-You don't?" She asks

"No" I place my hand on her cheek, seeing her lips curl into a small smile "I want to break up with your brother and be with you"

"Y/n--no you don't have to" Her eyes widen at my sentence as she shakes her head

"I want to" I reassure her

"B-but you're gonna break his heart, he really likes you Y/n and--" Hailee rambles her eyes averting from mine

"Hey, hey look at me" I straighten up sitting next to her and cupping her face in my hands. Her eyes instantly on mine as a small smile curls on her lips "I'm already hurting him, I wanna break it off before we get too serious"

"I think we are pretty serious" Hailee chuckles making me laugh "I mean this has been going on for 6 months"

"True, true" I laugh "I still chose you Hailee, I know it's so fucked up, but I chose you" I confess her smile growing even bigger

"I lo-" her words get cut off by my phone ringing. I let her go my brain racing at the thought of her saying those three words for the first time.

"It's Griffin" I sigh, Hailee nods before I pick it up

"Hey babe"

"Hi baby" I say turning my head to Hailee to see her with her arms crossed

"Whatcha doing?"

Hailee Steinfeld oneshotsWhere stories live. Discover now