Same Mistakes (sequel to Kidnapped By One Direction)

Choices(8)

Surprise update because I finally finished a chapter and am getting back into writing. Enjoy.

Niall's POV

I walk down the stairs quietly and towards the kitchen where the yelling is coming from. I listen in on what they're saying outside of the door.

"We can't let her do this to Niall we have to take her again and bring her to America with us. We have to make her seem like she wants to go so Niall won't get upset, so I suggest we just threaten people she loves so she will cooperate easier." I hear Harry's voice say.

I can't believe what they're saying I walk into the kitchen shutting everyone up when they see me.

"We are not taking Ally again, it's bad enough she can't even feel safe in this house and that she is still thinking she has to listen to everything we say. We really messed her up the first time she was here and this is our second chance with her" I tell them.

"Hear me out first, it's not like we want to do it for no reason. I over heard her talking to Zoey on her phone saying that she's just playing you, I have it recorded if you want to hear it" Harry tells me. I believe him already, I have no reason not to but I still want to hear Ally say it.

"Show me the recording"

Harry plays the recording and sure enough I hear Ally's voice say she doesn't know if she likes me and that she'll dump me and leave if she realizes she doesn't. I bite my lip trying to decide what to do now.

"What do we do now?" I ask.

"Mate, you need Ally in your life to be happy and were leaving for the states in 8 days but we could get our flights changed and leave tomorrow and if you get Ally's password we could give her phone to one of our friends here and get them to keep texting Zoey and telling her everything's alright so she doesn't come after us. If we think this through a little more it'll be perfect" Harry suggests and the rest of the boys give slight nods indicating they agree.

"Okay so I'll bring a couple drinks up with me when I go back upstairs and put sleeping pills in hers and that way we should be able to get her on the plane easier, one of you can re-schedule the flight and I'll get her phone password and take the password off but if we bring her phone with us it can be tracked easily, and we shouldn't trust anyone else to send messages to Zoey so I'll tap Ally's phone so I can send the messages from America but have Ally's phone say they were sent from here. Other than that we should bring all the clothes for Ally that we still have from last time." I tell everyone.

"Sounds good, now get the drink ready and we should all go upstairs the flight leaves tomorrow at 8 A.M." Harry says looking up from his phone I'm assuming he was just texting our private pilot for our private plane.

I nod and everyone else leaves while I stay, I grab the pill bottle and crush a few pills and walk over to the fridge pulling out two bottles of sprite. I slide the powder into one of the bottles and swirl it around a bit until the powder is dissolved, I tighten the cap on it a lot before grabbing mine and walking upstairs. I make sure to keep mine in my left hand and hers in the right.

I walk into my room and toss Ally her drink and open mine and take a sip.

"Does yours taste funny to you?" Ally asks.

"Kinda they've been in the fridge for a month or two so they're not the freshest" I say trying to cover.

It takes about an hour but eventually she falls asleep on my chest, I waited a few more minutes to be sure she was asleep before lifting her off me and gently laying her back onto my bed. I lean down and kiss her head gently. I know what I'm doing is wrong but I can't live without her and if she decided to leave me I would have gone right back into a slump.

I walk over to my closet and pull out a few suitcases and start packing clothes in them, once I'm done with all my stuff I grab a few more suitcases and go out to the hall and into Ally's room. I pack everything I think that she'll need or want and set the suitcases out in the hallway.

I walk back into my room and lay down with Ally, it takes awhile but eventually I fall asleep.

I'm woken up by Harry shaking my shoulder telling me it's time to start getting stuff into our cars and we have to leave in half an hour, I nod and he leaves my room. I unwrap my arm from Ally's waist and stand up rubbing my eyes for a second before walking over to my closet and picking a pair of sweatpants and a hoodie, since it's a pretty long plane ride to America.

I changed Ally into the same so she could be more comfortable, I made sure to be careful and respectful while doing it. I'd never take advantage of her, I'd never have the heart to do that to her. 

I grab my bags and bring them down to my car, I'm going to have to make three trips to get everything in my car. One for my stuff, one for Ally's stuff and a third for Ally, I try to be quick with my runs and soon enough all that's left to grab is Ally. As I'm walking into my room I see Ally just laying on my bed so still she almost looks dead.

I take a minute to re-think what I'm doing, I'm ruining her life. She's being treated like she's less than human, I'm forcing her to come with me to a country that she's never been to without her permission or even knowledge on what's going on. It's going to be almost impossible to gain her trust again after this. I don't deserve her and she definitely doesn't deserve this.

"You gonna stop gawking at her and grab her and bring her to your car or are you gonna stay here?" Louis asks walking into my room.

"She doesn't deserve this" I whisper.

"I know mate that's why I helped her last time, I love Kat just as much as you love Ally but I knew she was better off without me in her life"

"I need her though, I'm nothing without her" A warm tear slides down my face.

"This is your choice not mine but if I were you I'd let your relationship play out and if she leaves you later on decide then, right now she is just having a really hard time trusting. I'd give her a chance and let her make her own decisions before you do this"

"You're right, you guys can go to America and just tell our managers that I'm taking a break for awhile, we don't have any shows in the next six months anyway and if I don't go to America I won't have to sit through those five hour boring talks about tour."

"Well I have to get going so I don't miss the flight but good luck with Ally." Louis says walking out of my room.

I'm then left alone with my unconscious girlfriend, I lean down and kiss Ally's cheek.  I'm glad I made this decision, I don't want to lie to Ally so I'm going to tell her the truth. If she tries to leave I have to lock the doors because I need to fully talk this out with her. 

I sigh and leave my room heading back down to my car to bring all the luggage I just brought down to my car back up to our rooms. It'll probably take a few more hours before Ally wakes up, so I have plenty of time to unpack everything.

After I'm done with all the unpacking I see it's only 10 in the morning, I think of what I can do to occupy myself and eventually come up with the idea to make Ally and I lunch. I walk downstairs and to the fridge and look inside looking for anything that could make a good meal. A jar of Alfredo sauce catches my eye and I instantly want to make pasta, I think of what else I could put with it and remember that I bought breaded shrimp a while ago.

I pull the shrimp out of the freezer and grab pasta noodles from the cupboard then I grab a pot and fill it with water and set it on the stove turning the element on high so it'll boil faster. I then quickly set the table.

I cook the shrimp and pasta and then just add the sauce into the noodles putting the shrimp on a platter and covering them so they stay warm and putting the pasta into a large bowl covering it too. I grab a pasta scoop and a spatula and set them on the table to serve the food.

I then take a deep breath and walk out of the kitchen, up the stairs and to Ally's door. I hope she forgives me, it would be best if she did. I'll have to take her if she doesn't, I just want her to be happy with me.