Same Mistakes (sequel to Kidnapped By One Direction)

Part 2 Chapter 1

Ally's POV

"I can't deal with you anymore! How long have you been seeing her?"

"Four months" Joe looks down to the floor.

"We've only been dating six months! You know how hard it is for me to trust people and yet you went behind my back and did this to me!"

"I didn't want you to find out about her like this"

"Then how the Hell did you want me to find out?"

"I didn't want to hurt you Ally, you've been through enough but I didn't have the heart to tell you I couldn't tell you that I fell in love with a different girl. I'm sorry Ally."

"Get out Joe"

"No please we can talk this out"

"I said get out!" I scream as tears roll down my cheeks.

"I can't leave you like this" Joe walks closer to me and reaches for my arm but I shove his hand away.

"Leave me alone!" I yell.

Joe looks up from the floor and our eyes meet, Joe's crying but I'm not sure if he's guilty or just upset he got caught. I thought Joe was better I thought Joe was a good person, I don't even think Niall would have cheated on me. I give Joe a pleading look and finally, he turns and closes the door behind him.

I fall to the floor with my head in my hands, I can't stop the sobs from escaping my mouth. I never thought Joe was capable of anything like this, do I not deserve love? I don't move from my spot for what feels like hours, I have no reason to.

But there's a knock on my door so I force myself to stand, I practically drag myself to the door and I don't even bother looking through the peephole. When I open the door Kat is standing behind it, she pulls me into a hug and I sob once again, how have I not run out of tears yet?

"Joe told me what happened, he didn't want you to be alone so I went out and bought a bunch of ice cream and came over here as quickly as I could."

"I can't believe he did that to me, I trusted him!"

"I know, I don't think anyone saw that coming"

"I need to leave," I tell her.

"What?"

"I need to leave, get out of this country and get a fresh start. I'm gonna move to LA"

"Are you sure you'd be okay there, life is a lot different down there," Kat warns.

"I've been thinking about it for years and after this, I have no reason to stay in the UK there are too many bad memories here."

"If you think it's going to be best for you then I'll support you."

"Thank you"

"When are you going to leave?" Kat asks.

"As soon as I can"

"Let's at least make tonight as fun as we can make it and deal with all that stuff tomorrow." I nod wiping my eyes with my sleeve not caring if I get mascara on it or how bad I look.

"Let's go watch Lilo and Stitch" Kat suggests. I laugh and nod once again, Kat and I have loved Lilo and Stitch since we were young.

We go into the living room after grabbing spoons for the ice cream, Kat turns my Xbox on and opens Netflix. It takes her awhile but she eventually finds the movie and puts it on, throughout the night we laugh and cry but somehow spending the night with her cheered me up and made my mind drift away from the thoughts of what happened earlier today.

************

When I wake up I see that the tv is still on and that I'm on the couch, I don't see Kat anywhere. Was that all just a dream? I rub my eyes and stand up walking into the kitchen, I go to the fridge and pull out an apple. I take a bite and try to remember where my phone is, I'm pretty sure I left it in my room when Joe came over.

I walk up the stairs and into my room, I see my phone sitting on my bed and pick it up. When I turn the screen on I see a lot of missed texts from Joe, a couple from Kat telling me that she had to leave early for work and one from Niall.

My heart drops and I open the message,

Niall: How have you been?

The simple question scares me, Niall has left me alone since I punched him six months ago. Did he find out what happened between Joe and I? God, I sound insane, there's no way he found out. Still, I don't bother texting Niall back just in case.

I grab my laptop and start researching how to move to the US from the UK and after a few hours of research I find out that I'll have to stay in the UK for at least six months until I can move. I sigh but fill all of my forms out and send everything in that I need to. I go get a snack and turn my TV on to binge watch the new season of Stranger Things, I get so into it that by the time I check my phone to see the text's I've gotten it's already 12:42 AM.

Niall: Please answer me I need to talk to you

Niall: Come on Ally

Niall: Ally?

Niall: It's been like 10 hours since you've been on your phone I'm worried.

Niall: I know my number isn't blocked, just answer me. I need to know you're okay.

Niall: It's been 12 hours if you don't respond soon I'm sending someone to check up on you.

I take a deep breath before deciding I have to respond to him.

Me: What the Hell Niall!? I'm fine.

Niall: We need to talk.

Me: About?

Niall: I miss you

I stare down at my phone and my stomach drops, Niall saying he misses me probably means he wants back into my life.

Niall: I need to see you again

Me: Please Niall just stay out of my life I have too much going on already.

Niall: Just one-time lunch or at least a coffee anywhere you want. Is that too much to ask?

Me: Niall I can't deal with this right now.

Niall: I'm coming over for a bit I need to talk to you in person get dressed if you're not already and be ready in 10 minutes, don't try getting out of this.

Me: Niall, please

Niall: I need you right now and I know you need someone too.

Me: I'm perfectly fine. Leave me alone Niall.

I'm out of ways to talk Niall out of coming over, I can't believe this is happening.

Niall: 7 mins darling.

Lazily I move from my spot and into my room, I change into black leggings and a white knitted sweater. I don't see the point in doing makeup or trying to look good, I run a brush through my hair and leave it at that. I leave my bedroom and when I walk out Niall is sitting on the couch on his phone, my eyes widen and I feel my heart race in fear. The cause of my nightmares is here in front of me.

"Glad to see you listened," Niall says putting his phone away and standing up my breath hitches.

"What do you want?" I ask backing up a bit as Niall advances forward.

Next thing I know Niall slams me against the wall and holds me there, I yelp in fear. There's nothing I can do to stop him and that terrifies me.

"I want you darling" Niall whispers with his thick Irish accent in my ear. He then picks me up throwing me over his shoulder, I'm being kidnapped for the third time. I scream, punch and kick but it has no effect on him. When he removes his hand from me to open the door I throw as much of my body weight backwards as I can and I can feel him lose his balance before falling forwards. The last thing I remember is my head smashing against the door.