Same Mistakes (sequel to Kidnapped By One Direction)

Chapter 15

Ally's POV

"Put it down Ally, we can get you a place somewhere tropical if that's what you'd prefer." Harry reasons.

"No. Liam!" I yell to get him in here, the door swings open and the look of shock is clear on his face.

"Don't be irrational, let's talk and see if we can make everyone happy." Liam brings his hands up and I tighten my grip on the knife.

"Give me the car keys. Now!" I demand.

"You know I can't do that Ally, now just put the knife down." He takes a step closer and I put pressure on Harry's throat hard enough that he gags.

"Car keys" I repeat and this time Liam is more willing to listen. I watch carefully as he reaches into his pocket to pull them out, he brings them out and takes a few steps closer to me. I hold out my free hand and luckily Liam just drops the keys in my hand and backs away.

"Now put the knife down and let Harry go"

"No, now Liam you back up and stay in the living room, Harry walk forwards until you're out of the room then turn with me and walk backwards to the front door." I keep my voice low and monotone.

"Alright, just don't hurt him" Liam backs into the living room and I nudge Harry forewards. It's harder to keep the knife to his throat while we're moving because of his height but somehow I manage and we walk at a steady pace to the front door.

I take a second to put the keys into my pocket and Harry takes the chance to shove my arm to the side. I stumble and try to regain my grip but Harry had my wrist in his hands and my body slammed against the door within seconds. He squeezes my wrist tight and I'm forced to drop the knife.

"Just let me go!" I scream fighting with all I've got. I kick and hit him with my free arm but Liam grabs onto my other wrist, I still kick as best I can but Harry soon has his legs shoving mine so tightly against the door that I can't move. Harry uses his free hand to grab my other wrist and Liam walks off. I didn't want to cry in front of them but tears fall freely from my face.

"It'll be alright Ally, I'll get cleaned up and things will go back to normal" I look to Harry and see a long gash releasing blood across his neck, I must have cut him when he tried getting the knife off his neck.

"Be good and breathe" Liam comes back and brings a cloth to my nose I cry out but Liam forces his hand over my mouth giving me no other way to breathe, I give in and soon feel my body fall into Harry's arms.

"Stop!" I giggle struggling under Niall but he continues his tickle attack on my sides. My lungs struggling to bring air in after all the laughing.

"Make me" Niall brings his lips down to mine and I kiss back quick but roll over while he's distracted accidentally sending us off of the bed and onto the hard floor.

"Well, I guess that worked for you" Niall jokes bringing his hand to my cheek. We kiss again and I lay down on his chest listening to his steady heartbeat.

"I love you," I tell him while fiddling with the sleeve of his t-shirt.

"I love you too" I feel his lips touch my head and I shut my eyes letting my head rest on his chest.

Then memories flood back to me, Niall's leg is injured right now and I'm stuck with Liam and Harry. I bolt up off his chest and stand. He walks slowly towards me, looking hurt but I catch a glint of something else in his eye.

"You're not real!" I shout and he stumbles backwards.

"Of course I'm real Ally, come back over here." Suddenly he runs at me and I let out a scream and try to run but I'm caught in his grip. I struggle and scream trying to get away and realizing I'm back in the shared house in London. I'm dragged backwards by my hair and the only sound I hear is my screams.