A Forbidden Love: A Finchel Story

Chapter 11 Part 2

Finn- Rachel, it's not what you think

Rachel was crying- not what I think?! You lied to me Finn. You told me that you weren't talking to her.

Finn- Rachel I swear it's nothing!

Rachel- if it was nothing why didn't you tell me the truth?

Finn- because I knew you'd get upset

Rachel- yeah I would have but I would've gotten over it because at least you were honest with me but now I can't even trust you

Finn- Rachel I'm sorry I should've told you. But they're just text messages. They mean nothing!

Rachel- have you seen her?

Finn- what?... No..

Rachel- don't lie to me Finn

Finn- ok... I did we started talking at the New Year's Eve party

Rachel- the party? The party that YOU said nothing happened at? You're telling me that you lied to me about talking to her and you lied to me about seeing her

Finn- Rachel it was nothing! Nothing has happened between us!

Rachel- how do you expect me to believe you? You've lied to me, twice, to my face.

She was sobbing now. Finn wasn't saying anything all he could see was the pain he had caused to her and it was killing him.

Finn- I'm so sorry...

He got closer to her but Rachel pulled away.

Rachel- DON'T.

Finn- Rachel please believe me when I say that nothing happened. We were just talking.

Rachel- I can't trust you anymore...

She began gathering her stuff in a hurry.

Finn- where are you going?

Rachel- I have to go.

Finn- Rachel. Please Rachel. Don't leave. Don't leave Rachel. Please talk to me. We can work this out Rachel. Please. I love you.

He kept trying to stop her but Rachel was determined to leave. She was still sobbing. He grabbed her and hugged her.

Finn was crying- Please baby. Please don't go. I'm so sorry I lied. I swear to you that nothing happened. I love you with all of my heart and I would never do that to you. I would never want to hurt you. *He cupped her face.* please just stay.

Rachel- the thing is Finn, you did hurt me. You lied to me. You may have done nothing with her, but you still lied to me. I thought that you were the one person who would never hurt me, ever. And now I just don't know anymore. *she took a deep breath* I think that I.. I think I need to be alone.

She pulled away from Finn's arms and walked out of the choir room.

Finn just stood there in shock of what had just occurred. He had lied to Rachel. Rachel, one of the only girls who truly loved. He caused her pain. And now he doesn't even know where they stand. His phone buzzed on the piano and he grabbed it and threw it against the wall angrily watching as it broke into pieces. He threw all the music sheets on the floor and kicked the closest chair he could see. He was so mad at himself for lying to Rachel. He fell to the ground crying over the girl he loved.

Finn- this can't be over. I can't.. I won't give up on her. I will not let something like this tear us apart.

Rachel was in her car in the parking lot of the school, sobbing. She couldn't believe that Finn had lied to her. She honestly didn't know what to believe anymore. She was completely heartbroken. She couldn't go home because her dads were gonna ask why she was crying. She thought of the one place where she felt could bring her peace and that not many people knew of. She started her car and drove off to the one of her favorite places, Louder.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

A/N: I wrote that little part with Louder after Lea's album came out, kinda paying homage to her. ^-^

Let me know what you thought of the chapter! I will post tomorrow, maybe tonight if I get.... 15 votes? Come on help a sista out!