Supernatural Season 1, Male OC insert

Bloody Mary pt. 3

~ Mirror Shop, Night ~

Sam picked the lock on the shop's door. It opened and the three got in, crowbars in hand.

"Well... That's just great" Dean looked at the many mirrors in the place, he pulled out the picture of Mary's dead body and looked at the mirror in it. "All right let's start looking"

The three splitted up and walked around the store.

"Maybe they've already sold it" Dean said loud enough for the two to hear.

" Yeah, i have this odd looking mirror but I don't think it's this" Ethan said. He was holding a hand mirror with a cracked lapis lazuli embedded in the back of it.

Sam flashed at the exact mirror in the picture, "Found it"

Ethan and Dean walked to where Sam was. When they got there Dean pulled out the picture and compared it to the real thing.

"That's it" Dean sighed "You sure about this?" Sam handed Ethan his flashlight.

" Bloody Mary. Bloody Mary" he looked at Dean and Ethan they were giving him an unsure look. He held his crowbar tighter "Bloody Mary"

Dean turned and saw lights coming through the store, "I'll go check that out. Stay here, be careful. Ethan come with me"

"Smash anything that moves Sam, be careful" Ethan advised before he and Dean walked away and Sam readied his crowbar.

Dean walked to the door, Ethan behind him. "Crap" Dean cursed as he looked at the headlight outside the shop.

"What?"

"Cops" Dean put down his crowbar and continued walking to the door. Ethan walked away, "Ethan!" Dean whisper shouted "Ethan!" But Ethan kept on walking away.

Sam heard a breath and looked at a different mirror.

Dean was now outside, facing the police. "Hold it" a police said

"Whoa guys, false alarm i tripped the alarm system" Dean reasoned

" Who are you?"

" I'm the boss's kid"

" You're Mister Yamashiro's kid?" The other police asked.

Sam saw Mary out of the corner of his eye, he bashed the mirror but she wasn't there anymore. He saw her in another mirror and bashed that too. He looked at Mary's mirror, "Come on. Come to this one" he mumbled. He stopped and looked at his reflection.

He started breathing heavily and a trickle of blood came out of his nose. He dropped the crowbar and gripped his chest.

"It's your fault. You killed her. You killed Jessica" his reflection accused.

Outside, Dean saw Ethan walking behind the cops. "Like I said i was adopted" Dean reasoned

"Yeah" The police was about to search Dean for anything when two arms went around their head.

"Night night" Dean said before Ethan bashed the police's head to the other. The cops fell down unconscious.

Inside, "You never told her the truth-who you really were." The reflection pointed out. Sam sunk to the ground still struggling to breath. "But it's more than that, isn't it? Those nightmares you've been having of Jessica dying, screaming, burning- you had them for days before she died. Didn't you!? You were so desperate to ignore them like that? How could you leave her alone to die!? You dreamt it would happen!!" The reflecting added.

Before it could say more, a crowbar went through it. Ethan bent down to the floor to Sam, Dean did the same after he dropped his crowbar.

"Sammy! Are you okay!?" Ethan asked

"Sam, Sammy!" Dean shook him.

" Yeah and it's Sam"

"Come on, come on." Dean and Ethan helped Sam up. They put Sam's arms over their necks and began to walk out.

They hear glasses crumbling and they turned around only to see Mary walking towards them. The three fell to ground gasping for air. Ethan flailed around for something to grip. Dean grabbed the mirror beside him and made it face Mary.

"You killed them! All those people! You killed them!" Mary started choking to death as she melts into a pile of blood. Dean threw the mirror he was holding to ground and it shattered.

"Hey" Dean called out to the two

"Yeah?" Sam asked and Ethan looked at Dean.

"This has got to be like...what? 600 years of bad luck?" Dean joked

Ethan snickered weakly while Sam chuckled weakly.

~ Day after ~

Dean was driving, Sam in the passenger seat as always and Ethan and Charlie were in the backseat. Dean pulled up in front of a house.

"So this is really over?" Charlie asked.

Dean nodded, "Yeah it's over"

"Thank you" Charlie said before holding up her hand. Dean reached back and shook her hand. She opened the door and got out of the car, Ethan was waving at her.

"Charlie?" Sam called out Charlie turned around. "Your boyfriend's death...you really should try to forgive yourself. No matter what you did, you probably couldn't have stopped it. Sometimes bad things just happen" Sam advised.

Charlie smiled faintly before walking inside the house.

Dean hit Sam gently, "that's good advice" Ethan held a thumbs up to Sam. Dean drove off

"Hey Sam?"

"Yeah?"

"Now that this is all over, I want you to tell me what the secret is" Dean instructed.

" Yeah, what is this secret?" Ethan asked

"Look... you're my brothers and I'd die for both of you, but there are some things I need to keep to myself" Sam said

" Understandable" Ethan said and looked out the window.

Sam did the same and Saw Jessica in a white dress standing on the side of the road. A pole blocked her for a second but Sam didn't see her again