Chapter 12

3.4K 102 1
                                        

Was it possible for someone to go into shock from sex? Probably.

Cas sat in her disheveled bed shocked emotionally and physically, she didn't really know how to process everything.

Mind-boggling to say the least, Sin..or Lust had revealed himself to be this supernatural being; too unrealistic to even believe.
Sure, Cas had watched and read all the supernatural things out there and loved it. But this was reality, not a storybook from her bookshelf...right?

He did just supernaturally fuck your mind out of your body last night, Cassidy's mind reminded her cheekily. Aside from her sore muscles she didn't know if his words were true, or if he was just saying anything to get in her pants.
He had definitely succeeded whether true or not.

He had left early that morning leaving Cas a disgruntled mess of a woman thoroughly considering if all supernatural things existed, namely; unicorns.
Her inner fiver year old self would pee her pants if that was the case.

She yawned as Pickles meowed loudly signaling it was time for his breakfast. As she peeled out of bed and walked to the kitchen to grab cat food, she simultaneously flicked the TV on.
The local news channel was lit with bold letters advertising the headline: MISSING WOMAN, FOUND DEAD
Cas' eyes flicked to this screen, passively paying attention whilst making her coffee.

The reporter spoke fluidly, "Around 8:30 last night the local police found the body of a local woman Hailey Wells, a teacher, found in the Chop'ta River. No signs of struggle or wounds on the body. Police are still l-.." Cas couldn't hear much after the words Hailey Wells were uttered. Her mind raced to the day in the studio, remembering the sweet blonde girl with sparkly blue eyes.

She was shocked, but what worried her was the last moment they were together, she recalled that strange feeling she experienced during the appointment. She wondered if she could send a sympathy card to her fiancé, he was probably devastated.
It was not her place to help figure out the mystery of her death but Cas couldn't shake the memory of that day at the studio.

She sighed heavily, feeling the soreness in muscles ache as she ate her breakfast in quiet reverence.
After her oatmeal, she knew she'd be skipping yoga to take a much needed bath.
The hot water poured into her ceramic tub as Cas added lavender oil and vanilla bath salts. She dipped in once the the tub filled, releasing a satisfied groan as she sunk into the water up to her neck.
Pickles came waltzing into the bathroom, his tail flicking as he peered over the tub to sniff Cas.

She laughed and booped his little brown nose and he took that as a sign to leave Cas to her soaking.
Her mind relaxed but her thoughts still circled around Lust.

He really was the true definition of player if he was the sin Lust; it also clicked in her mind why he was so amazing in bed.

Seriously.

She never had someone so big.
There had been a saying it doesn't matter the size of ocean just the motion of it...or something along those lines. But that ocean was....impeccable in both aspects.
Aside from sex, Cas wondered if he really was this supernatural god. He hadn't shown any remarkable powers explicitly, except those in bed.
Cas felt relieved that her one-night stand had finally taken place, and she had no regrets.

Just as her bath finished and wrapped her body in a fluffy towel she heard her apartment open and close.
Footsteps crept up her stairs and for a brief moment Cas feared it was an intruder.
The familiar broad-shouldered man stepped into her bathroom holding coffee and a bag filled with what could possibly be muffins.

She had a keen sense of smell when it involved pastries.
He smirked, seeming to remove her towel with his eyes as they slowly admired her wet towel-covered body.

A heat caressed her cheeks as she stood a foot away from the man that had ravished her in such a way the night before, and absent-mindedly she clenched her legs together.
"I brought breakfast," he expressed, still locked onto her figure. She moved closer to him to grab the coffee and took a long sip.

"Thanks," Cas spoke shyly, turning around to go to her walk in closet to change.
"Wait," Lust grabbed her elbow gently, turning her around to face him.

He inched closer to her face, his hands finding their way to cup her chin. She leaned into him, pressing her toweled body to his chest.
His lips pecked her nose, then caught her mouth with his. Lust bit her bottom lip a little while brushing her hair back.
He broke them apart smiling, proud that he had removed Cas' towel without her even realizing it.

She bent down to pick up the towel again but he caught her hand, holding her still. "Let me look at you," he whispered, his gentleness made Cas shiver through her spine.
Every hair seemed to stand on end as goosebumps outlined her skin, letting him drink in her appearance.

He looked at her like he was admiring the first addition piece of the Mona Lisa, memorizing and painting a picture in his head so he'd never forget.

"You are so..' - he exhaled softly - "Beautiful."

Her heart thudded like a hammer on a nail, no man had ever revered her in this way, in this intimate way.
The moment wasn't even sexual, it was quiet.... and tender.
He picked up her towel offering her coverage, she grabbed it with a small smile spread on her face.

"Can I ask you something," Cas called from her closet as she changed. "Sure, anything.." was his reply.
"Are mermaids, unicorns or leprechauns real?" She hoped her question wasn't offensive, she honestly wanted to know. The sex had detracted from talking more about his true self.
He erupted with a deep chuckle that echoed off the walls of her small bathroom.

"No, there is my family, and a few others. We have groups that are divided, but the most powerful beings are within my family."
Cas emerged biting her lip again, interesting in hearing more from Lust's background.

"What do you mean the most powerful?" She continued while brushing out her wet locks.
"Well, for instance I have the power to instigate attraction."

Cas giggled childishly, "kind of like a cupid?"
Lust rolled his eyes in response giving her a lopsided smile. Cas grew quiet for a moment with sudden seriousness. Her voice squeaked out, "Did you use it on me?"

Lust took her hands in his big ones, a mocked expression of shock on his face. "I would never, sorry - have never."
Cas let out a breath she didn't realize she was holding. The smile returned to her face as she grabbed his hand and led him downstairs.

The TV remained on, still with the news channel reviewing the morning's headlines. Cas walked over to the cupboard, pulling a plate to place her muffin on.
Lust remained quiet as she took bites of the blueberry deliciousness.
"Did you hear about the missing woman Hailey Wells, my client from the other day?" Cas asked, her mouth partially full.

Lust faked disinterest but she could clearly see something was awry. "What woman?"

Cas' skin chilled as she saw him tense up. Did he know something....
Or worse..... do something.
She was dammed sure she was going to find out.

My Date With LustWhere stories live. Discover now