I Hate That I Love You (JeffxJane)

Play Date

Hey guys! So this one is one of those scenarios where one of the pastas try to get Jane and Jeff together. On this story Sally will be the one to set them up, I mean who could ever resist Sally's charm? XD. Anyways, enjoy ^o^

Sally was the youngest among the Creepy pastas.
Which is why she would always be underestimated. They think she was just too young and innocent to understand some things. But that wasn't the case for her. She was not just a little girl, she was a sharp one.

Two people in particular would always find the time to play with her. They were special and dear to her heart, she was so close to them that they treated her like a little sibling.

It was Sally's birthday today and she'd want nothing more but to spend the time with her elder "siblings". But there was just one problem..... her Big brother and Big sister hated each other.

She could never spend time with the two together..... Not without knives flying around anyway.

The girl just wants to help them fix whatever happened with them. But if they didn't want help because of their stubbornness then she'd have to help them secretly.

Sally knows their only lying about hating each other. She could see it in their eyes, their movements and how they act. She notices those small hints that would ultimately lead you to the conclusion that they didn't hate each other at all. In fact she dare say, they had a crush on each other. They're just too blinded by their fake hate that they don't want to admit it.

But she was going to change that after the party.

"Happy Birthday Sally!!" The whole family greeted her.

"Thank you everyone!!" She giggled

"Now make a wish." She closed her eyes.

I wish Big brother and Big sister would stop hating each other.

Sally blew the candles.

"What was your wish, Child?" Slender asked carrying her.

"I can't tell because if I do then it won't come true." She stuck out her tongue. They all just laughed it off.

"Now that that's over. How else do you want to celebrate your birthday?" Slender asked putting her down

"Hmmmm..... I guess I'll play in my room all day." The brunette answered.

"Do you not want to spend the day with the other pastas?"

"I guess I do have some people in mind..." she whispered their names to Slender.

"You do realize he can read your mind right?" She heard Jeff say and a yelp was heard after. Jane elbowed him to give the message "Shut up."

"I see..." Slender nodded and went to the two said killers.

"Jeff, Jane come here." The tall man ordered. The two reluctantly looked at each other shrugged and proceeded forward.

"I guess that means we're the ones she chose?" The raven haired girl asked crossing her arms.

"I want you two to behave yourselves when you play with Sally for the whole day." He said with authority.

"Wait a second, you know how we act when we're in the same room." Jeff gestured to Jane and himself.

"That's why I told you to behave." He pointed out.

"Sh*t I can't do that! Especially with this b*t- oww." Jeff exclaimed.

"Don't cuss in front of the kid." She whispered after elbowing him....again.

"Remember, you two....BEHAVE. and I'm not just telling you. I'm warning you. If you two don't play nice and I find out...you two are going to the white room." Slendy threatened.