Broken Souls

Lets Play a Game - Part One

// This chapter was recommended by my good Sinning Friend, TicciS~! I hope you all enjoy. Also be warned!!! Lemony lemons lay ahead in the next few chapters~ ;3

So ahead of time... I am sO SORRY--

Happy Sinning! ❤️💙 //

————————————————————————

*KITTENS POV*

Those words... they sent shivers up and down my spine. The voice sounded so evil, so malicious... so familiar. "S-Sans...?" I asked softly, slight fear pounding in my SOUL as I slowly moved to roll over and confirm my suspicions. As I turned onto my side, I could just barely make out his silhouette. The hoodie, the body structure... the one glowing red eye that seemed to be burning brighter than normal. "W-what are you doing here? I... I-I thought you were in bed."

Sans gave a dark chuckle, shaking his head as he drew closer and closer to where I lay. "Now Kit, how could I possibly go t'sleep when I know that there are secrets bein' kept 'round here, hmm?" His grin widened even further as he towered over my form, and I couldn't help but whimper. "T-th-there's no secret! W-we already told you what happened! You believed us, r-remember?"

Sans gave a 'tsk tsk tsk', waggling a finger in front of himself. "Key word there, Kitty Cat. 'Believed'. Ya really think ol' Sansy is that gullible? I knew you were lyin' ta me, so I decided to go along with your little game. Bide my time. Why, ya ask? Heh heh... cuz I realized somethin'..." He leaned in close to my face, his gaze causing me to shudder. "...three can play this lil' game." He looked truly insane. Was it all an act? Was he just trying to scare me? Or was he actually serious? I gulped.

"Papyr-mmph!" He covered my mouth before I could call out for help, 'tsking' once again. "Looks like ya really do think me ta be gullible." He snickered, the room suddenly flickering with a red hue. "I soundproofed the room. Ain't nobody gonna hear ya, Kit..." I began to whimper and struggle, fear evident in my eyes. Sans took notice.

"Shh-hh shh... easy there, sweet cheeks. Ya might hurt yerself. 'ere! Lemme help..." He removed his hand from my mouth, and instead, placed it over my SOUL as his eye flashed from yellow to red. As I made an attempt to struggle away, it dawned upon me... I couldn't move. "W-what did you d-do to me...?" I whimpered, completely afraid for my wellbeing by this point.

"Magic." He said with mock jazz hands, winking with a laugh. "Now ya won't be able t'hurt yerself. Pretty smart, huh?" He stared into my eyes, and I stared back. "P-please... d-don't hurt me..." I sniffled.

*HORROR!SANS POV*

"...!" Her words took me aback. 'Hurt her?! I'd never!' Though it's understandable why she would think that after all of this. But not to worry. She'd understand soon enough. "Kit... I ain't gonna hurt ya. We're just gonna play a lil' game. That's all." I stroked her cheek tenderly with my thumb, and she instantly relaxed. "A... a game...?" She asked with a shaky tone. "Yep!" I nodded. "A game. Wanna know what it's called?" I grinned deviously as she nodded. "Heh heh heh... it's called... 'Tell Sansy the Truth'."

I could feel her body tense once again. "I-I... I can't..." She blushed, looking to the side. I felt my SOUL sink. "...ya... ya like my brother, dontcha? That's what yer hiding, isn't it?" Without realizing it I felt a pang of jealousy and rage course through my bones, my eye flaring up intensely. "W-what?! No!! I-I mean we're best friends for sure! B-but... that's not what... not like that." She explained. My sockets widened, the intense jealous feelings immediately fading away.

"Eh? W-well if that ain't the secret, what th' hell is? What's so important between you two that you have to keep from me?"

*KITTENS POV*

Seeing the sadness on Sans' face made me feel a pang of guilt. Maybe I should just tell him... and pray to the gods above that he wouldn't try it. Or worse, learn my true secret. I gave a sigh. "H-he... he just played with me, that's all..." Sans arched a brow. "Played wiv ya? How so?" I felt my cheeks burning up. I just couldn't say the word. "Y-you know... l-like..." I bit down on my lip, blushing intensely. "...h-he just... t..tickled me... th-that's all..." I said in barely a whisper, wanting nothing more than to hide my face, but unable to thanks to Sans magic.

*HORROR!SANS POV*

I stared at her. My expression blank. I examined her face, her features, her body language. She was as red as a tomato. "..." Slowly, a diabolical grin spread across my face. "So. That's the big secret, is it? Hmhmhmhm... you're ticklish." I heard her give a squeak of embarrassment, trying to struggle beneath my magic hold on her SOUL. "Y-yes, I am! N-now please... just... d-don't say that word..." She practically pleaded, begged. Adorable.

"So uh... say I did somethin' like... this?" I ran my bony index finger down her side. "Does that... tiiiickle?" I drew out the word, wanting nothing more than to embarrass her further. "Mnnhyah! S-stop it! L-l-let me go... please? I t-told you what you wanted!" Her sounds were so adorable. And her begging? Oh yes... I wanted more. "And what if I say no? Ticklish... little... girl...~" I purred into her ear, sending a visible shudder throughout her body. "P-please.. ah..~"

Man. This was really getting 'under her skin'. I smirked to myself as I continued to tease, all the while wondering if there was something more to this than just embarrassment. The way her body trembled, how she blushed, begged... the sounds she made. I felt my skull heating up, tinting with a light dust of blushing blue. "Hmhmhm... time to do a lil' experimenting." A lot of experimenting. 'In the name of... science and things.' I thought to myself.  Time to let the tests begin.

"Kitten... I want to play another game...~" I purred into her ear once again. "I'm gonna ask ya a few questions, and you're gonna tell me the truth. Now don't even think about lying. I'll know. And if ya do lie ta me... you'll be punished." My eyes went dark and hollow, and like before, her body went ridged. Learning what makes her tick. That's my goal. 

She gave a nervous nod and a gulp, a whimper of embarrassment and fear escaping her lips. Though I could have sworn ... there was a hint of excitement mixed in. "Aiight. Now... for my first question, I need to make things a lil' more... interesting." I grinned evilly and spread my arms out to the sides. Soon after, a few red and blue magic-made tendrils appeared from behind me. She gave a squeaking cry of surprise, her futile struggling resuming. "N-no! P-please! P-put those away! Pleaaase!" She begged, blushing more intensely than before. 'So... she likes these, huh? Perfect...'

"Shhh... easy there, Kitten. They're just... ten-tickles." I smirked at my joke, and she whimpered in response. Focusing my powers, I allowed two of the tendrils to advance towards her, binding her wrists above her head, holding them there tightly. But not too tight. I looked at her to see her reaction. I didn't think it was possible, but her blush had darkened even further. 'This too, eh? Heh heh... well now. Let's see if she plays by the rules...'

"So, Kit, for my first question... do you like this? Bondage type stuff? Do you like bein' held against yer will? No lyin' now. Or else...~" The other tendrils behind me wriggled tauntingly, causing her to squeal nervously.

'This was going to be one hell of a night. Hmhmhm....'

*KITTENS POV*

I was memorized by the tendrils, the feeling of them against my bare wrists. It felt... amazing. Without even realizing it, I responded to Sans' question... with the truth. "Y-...yes..." I shivered, swallowing hard as I began to feel a strong heat growing in my nether regions. I didn't want this! ... did I? I began to feel like I did.

'This was going to be a... torturous night...'