Supernatural Imagines 2

{22} Sam and Dean

Requested by: foreverfandom03

Reader is the middle sister of Sam and Dean and comes out as gay to one or both of the brothers she is absolutely terrified.

SLIGHT SMUT WARNING BETWEEN READER AND CHARLIE 

You had always thought you were different from others. Besides, being a hunter. You couldn't quite put your finger on it at first. But then you met her. Charlie Bradbury. The moment you met her you were instantly attracted to her. Her personality, the way she acted, her beauty. Then everything began making sense.

You realized that not only had you never found any guy attractive, but the only people you had every found attractive were girls. You had thought it was something that you could just push away. After all, you knew your brothers wouldn't approve. 

How could they? They were the Winchesters. 

You tried to act like you weren't gay. But, you and Charlie began hanging out more and more, and soon it was just the two of you hanging out as your brothers went on hunts. You began falling for her, and little to your knowledge, she began falling for you as well. 

The two of you were doing research one day when Charlie got bored. She decided to have some fun by teasing you. One thing led to another and she began tickling you, making you beg for mercy. 

Charlie finally stopped for a moment, letting you breathe. You breathed heavily as you tried to regain the air you had lost from CHarlie's onslaught of tickles. When you had finally caught your breath, you realized that Charlie was lying on top of you, looking into your eyes.

Your breath hitched and your heart skipped beats as you looked into her eyes as well. Slowly, she leaned down, and you were frozen. She placed her lips on yours and it felt right. Wanting more, you leaned up into the kiss, making her deepen the kiss. You ran your fingers through her hair, and she placed her hand on the small of your back pulling you up to her. 

The two of you continued to kiss, exploring each other's mouths with your tongues and running your hands up and down each other's body. Everything felt right about this. But then, Sam and Dean came home. 

You and Charlie quickly broke apart. "They don't know I'm gay, please don't tell them yet," you told her quietly. She nodded her head, and the two of you began looking through your lore books again as Dean and Sam opened the door to your bedroom.

"Hey, how's it going in here?" Dean asked. "Amazingly," Charlie replied with a smirk. "Good, you are having some fun right, not just working?" Sam questioned. "Oh yeah, we are having tons of fun," Charlies replied, biting her lip. "Alright, well Sammy and I are going to get some rest. The spirit we just took out was one tough son of a bitch, but call us if you need anything," Dean told the two of you before walking out of the room. 

"You should tell them," Charlie said when they were gone. "I know, I just don't know how. Dean, he's my older brother. He's always wanted me to find the perfect man. Who knew I wasn't attracted to men. And as for Sammy, he is my little brother. He looks up to me. He thinks I am perfect, how am I supposed to tell him that I'm not?" you responded. 

Charlie gave you a small smile before pulling you into another kiss. You both shifted so that you were laying back down on the bed, with her on top as you continued to kiss. She broke her lips from yours and began kissing down your neck, sucking on your collar bone, definitely leaving a mark. 

You moaned out her name as she continued to nibble and lick the area. Her hands traveled to your hip and her thumb just barely slipped underneath your panties. She rubbed circles with her thumb, and all you could do was moan as you silently begged for more. 

After another moment, Charlie removed her thumb and whispered in your ear, "If you tell Dean and Sam, we could do so much more together without worrying about waking them up." You shivered at the thought of all the things the two of you could do. Then, you nodded your head. 

Charlie smiled and placed another kiss on your lips before leaving. You let out a small sigh and then went down to the Bunker's kitchen and began making an apple pie. You were going to need all of the help you could get.

As the pie finished baking both of your brothers came down into the kitchen. "I smell pie," Dean stated. "Yes, I made your favorite, apple," you replied, handing him the pie. Dean looked at it skeptically before taking it and asking, "What's going on?" You inhaled sharply as you said, "There is something I have to tell you guys, and I know that you aren't going to like it, but I have to tell you," you told them. 

"Okay, what is it?" Sam asked. You hesitated for a moment, wondering if what you were doing was right. But, then you thought of Charlie and your confidence came back. "I'm gay," you told them, refusing to make eye contact. 

No one spoke for a moment, and your heart basically stopped beating as your stomach dropped all the way down to the floor. You were about to leave, when Sam asked, "Like gay, gay?" "Yes, Sammy, like gay, gay," you replied. "Um, well are you sure?" Dean questioned. "Yes. There's something else too," you responded. 

"What is it?" Dean asked. "Charlie and I are together, I think," you replied. Another moment of silence. "Well. congratulations, I guess," Dean responded, forcing you to finally look up into his eyes. "What?" you questioned. "We're happy for you guys," Sam added. 

"You mean, you guys don't hate me?" you asked. "What?! Of course not, Y/N, we could never hate you, especially not over something like this," Dean told you. "Yeah, we love you, no matter what, so don't for a second doubt that," Sam said. You broke into a smile as you pulled the boys into a hug. "Thank you for being the best brothers ever," you told them. They just chuckled in response. 

When you all broke away from the hug, Dean asked, "Does this mean Charlie is officially a part of this family?" You smiled at the idea and nodded your head, happy that you had finally gotten the girl of your dreams and that your brothers were okay with it. 

Hello my little monsters,

This was so bad. OML I was cringing while writing. I hope you guys don't hate me for this. Thank you for the support anyways. I love you all and all of you are amazing!

Always Keep Fighting!