Supernatural Imagines 2

{71} The Winchesters

Requested By: Sans-Papy

Imagine: Your boyfriend turns out to be a siren trying to get back at your brothers.

Sam and Dean Winchester x Sister!Reader

Five months. That's how long you've been keeping a secret from your brothers. A pretty big secret. You had met a guy about seven months ago at a bar. He was nice and unbelievably charming. The two of you ended up spending the whole night talking and then you hooked up and that was the end of it.

You never expected to see that guy again. After all, most one night stands disappear the next day. But, the next time you went to the bar he was there, and then again the next time. It got to a point where it stopped being chance encounters; instead, the two of you were intentionally meeting up.

You started going out and doing things together, like going to restaurants or sight-seeing. You started to fall in love with him, and once you started falling it was hard to stop. But, it wasn't exactly easy. You knew you couldn't tell Sam or Dean, because if you did, they would be angry. Despite them being overprotective of you and wanting to make sure you were always safe, you were also a hunter. Hunters weren't meant to live the life where they find someone, fall in love, and happily ever after.

But, you weren't planning out a future in your head. You were just trying to take things one day at a time. And, that was working for you. The only problem was that every time you wanted to see your boyfriend, you had to sneak out of the Bunker. You always made up some lame excuse and you knew that your brothers never believed you, but they never pushed either, and you were thankful for that.

But, the longer this relationship was going on, the harder it was for you to keep coming up with lies and excuses. Not to mention the fact that you absolutely hated lying to your brothers. They were the only family you had left and you always told them everything.

However, that didn't stop you from going to them today and yet again making up another lie about how you have some errands to run. You gave both of them a hug and then you left the Bunker. But, you weren't on your way to run errands; instead, you were going to your boyfriend's house.

You had been to his house a few times, and tonight he told you that he wanted to cook dinner for you. You agreed, thinking it sounded like a great idea, and a short while later, you were knocking on his door.

He opened it with a smile and let you in. The two of you made small talk as he led you to the kitchen. "Everything is mostly done," he told you, giving you a hug. "I just have to finish up dessert," he continued. "Sounds good, it smells delicious," you told him with smile.

He smiled back and said, "Could you come help me with something downstairs?" You shrugged your shoulders, thinking no harm could come from it, and you followed your boyfriend down the stairs. But, when you got down the stairs, you realized there was nothing down there but a person. Actually, the dead body of a person.

"What the hell is this?" you asked your boyfriend, looking up at him in horror. "Her name was Maria. She was the most beautiful woman I had ever seen. She was the love of my life, until your brothers, Sam and Dean Winchester killed her," he told you, looking at the corpse with sadness.

You scoffed a little and replied, "That's not possible, my brothers would never kill someone that was human." Your boyfriend laughed which made you uneasy as he turned to look at you. "Who said anything about us being human?" he asked.

You let out a gasp as you tried to run away, but it was too late. He had you trapped and within moments, he had you under his spell. Knowing that you wouldn't run, he let you back upstairs with him and the two of you ate dinner. When it started getting late, Dean called you just like your boyfriend knew he would.

Your boyfriend instructed you not to answer the phone so you didn't. You just sat there watching as it rang. It stopped and went to voicemail and you looked up at your boyfriend. He was intensely watching the phone. It started ringing again and this time your boyfriend smiled.

He picked up the phone and said, "What's the matter, Dean? Can't take the hint? She can't talk right now." You could hear the anger in Dean's voice coming through the phone as he asked, "Where is she?" Your boyfriend didn't respond. Instead, he replied, "Here's the deal. You have one hour to find your precious, little Y/N. If you find her, I'll trade her for you and your brother. If you don't find her, she dies."

Your boyfriend then hung up the phone. "So, you won't kill me if they find me?" you asked. Your boyfriend laughed hard at your question before replying, "All three of you are going to die, I just want them to be the ones who kill you."

You wanted to fight, but you couldn't. Your boyfriend was a siren. He had complete control over you. You did as he wanted not as you wanted. So, all you could do was sit there and wait for your brothers to walk into his trap.

Sam and Dean came a little while later. They busted open the door and immediately ran to the room you were in. But, when they saw you, your boyfriend was standing behind you with a smile on his face. "Let her go," Dean stated.

Your boyfriend just smiled as he leaned down and whispered in your ear, telling you to attack. Instantly, you stood up and ran at your brothers. "Y/N, I don't want to hurt you," Dean told you, fighting off your attacks. You responded by kicking him hard, sending him across the room. Sam moved to attack you, but you dodged it, hitting him in the face, knocking him back.

You continued to fight your brothers, when suddenly, Sam got you onto the ground and held you down as Dean cut in your arm. "Sorry, kid," he told you as you cried out in pain. Sam continued to hold you down as Dean fought the siren and ended up stabbing him in the heart and killing him.

Instantly, you were broken from his spell and began crying as you held onto Sam. You were embarrassed, scared, guilty and heartbroken. Sam held you tightly, telling you everything would be okay. Eventually, your brothers got you standing and led you to the Impala. The three of you rode in silence as you made your way back to the Bunker.

When you got home, you sat in the living room, distraught. You felt stupid for letting yourself get played when he was a monster this whole time. "How are you feeling?" Sam asked, handing you a glass of water. He and Dean sat down next to you on the couch.

"Like I should have known better," you replied. Sam and Dean gave you a soft smile as you explained, "I just thought that maybe I could make it work. That I could have a little bit of both worlds. But, I was wrong. I'm so sorry. You guys could have gotten really hurt and it would have all been my fault."

"No, it would have been that son of a bitch's fault," Dean responded. "Look, Y/N, neither of us blame you for wanting a normal life, we both had a chance at it. We're just happy we got to you before anything happened," Sam told you.

You smiled at him and nodded your head before asking, "How did you know he was siren?" Sam and Dean shared a look as Dean let out an awkward laugh. "We've kind of been following him," he said quietly. "You guys were stalking us?!" you questioned. "You kept disappearing and lying about it! We were worried about you," Sam defended.

You laughed at your brothers, thankful for their overprotectiveness. It's what saved all three of you. "Besides, who needs a boyfriend when you have the best brothers in the world," Dean teased making you laugh again.

Sam stood up and turned on a movie as the three of you sat together on the couch. Your brothers just wanted to make you feel better. They weren't mad about you having a boyfriend, they were supportive of you. All Sam and Dean have ever wanted for you was to make sure you were happy and okay, and that's all you wanted for them. But, in order for all of you guys to be happy and okay, you had to stick together and stay safe. After all, family meant everything when you were a Winchester.

Always Keep Fighting!