Requested by Irishroadie
*Andy's POV*
I can't love them both. I really can't.
Well I mean I shouldn't. But I do and I can't help it. The only problem is they have to be brothers. That's like the worst thing possible.
Family's suppose to be everything and if it's not then there is something wrong.
I can't break a brothers bond. But I can't stop loving them. Equally.
So the only thing I could do was sit in my room and write. Write, sing, and play my guitar. The things I was best at.
But it didn't last long. I heard a knock at my door. I didn't want to answer I knew who it was and when one came so did the other and then my emotions got in the way again. I was going to go crazy from this.
I continued playing my guitar and humming letting lyrics run through my head. I tried to not focus on any other sound just hoping that he would go away.
"Fovvs," I heard the voice at my door. He was in my room now. I could feel his eyes on me and finally I looked up to meet his chocolate eyes. He was gorgeous just like always.
"What is it Rye?" I asked trying to act busy so he'd leave me alone. But I knew it wouldn't work. It never did.
"I want to cuddle," he said almost in a whiny tone. I sighed. I couldn't say no to him. I got up and set my guitar back in it's rightful place. Not wanting any harm done to it. I quickly cleaned up everything I had out and then I held my arms out for Rye.
He was quick to crawl into my bed and pull me against him. It was so hard to focus on just cuddling. I wanted to kiss him. I wanted to show him that I loved him. But I couldn't.
No if I did then I'd have to explain the whole truth. I can't love only one. I tried to forget one and focus on the other but it hurts. I love them both with my entire heart.
I was so deep in my thoughts that I didn't realize another person was in my room till I felt their body against mine. I knew who it was.
And with both of them here my head was in a whirlwind. I couldn't think straight. I couldn't stop the thoughts anymore.
*Rye's POV*
I loved Andy. I really did and I knew Robb did too. We've talked about it. We had to. I could see the longing for Andy in his face and he could see it on mine but I couldn't hurt him.
But we had decided together that we would both tell Andy. We needed to. We were both in love with the same boy.
We agreed that whoever he picked was it. That that would decided everything.
"Andy?" I heard Robb say and his eyes met mine and he nodded slightly. He say up and I was soon to follow pulling Andy up with me.
He looked at both of us. Confusion written all over his face. "We have something we need to tell you," I said. Robbie sighed at that but he was the first one to admit everything. "I love you," he said and Andy's eyes widened.
"And I love you Andy," I said. "We understand if you only Love one of us back or either of us but we couldn't keep it from you anymore," I continued and I could see tears forming in his eyes as he started shaking his head.
"N-no, that is no where near the truth," he said. He tried to focus on both of us but as he started talking again his eyes drifted to the ground. "I-i love you both. I love you both with all of my heart and I can't get either of you out of my head. I can't choose one. I can choose just one of you dammit. I've tried. I tried to pick or even forget about it all but I can't. I love you both," he said.
I was completely shocked. He loved us both. Robbie was the first one to realize it and he brought his lips to Andy's. I was quick to react then pulling him away from Robb and kissing him.
"Then we'll figure this out. Together we will be our own little family," I said and Andy was quick to cuddle back into my chest as I laid back down. Robbie once again wrapping his arms around Andy.
Not exactly what was asked but this is what came out. It's probably trash cause I am half asleep but here it is. I'm sorry if you don't like it. Also I am really trying to get back into this my mind has just been everywhere and I haven't been able to focus. And then I had a major writer's block and couldn't do anything. So I'm still really trying to get back to where I was before.
YOU ARE READING
Roadtrip Oneshots
FanfictionThis is a boyxboy one shot book of these amazing boys. I take an requests including smut, fluff, ect. All the boys included. I am not posting anymore with Mikey but I will leave the ones I have up because at the time there was no bad blood. Started...
