Don't Judge a Book By It's Cover: Male Reader x Erza Scarlet

Chapter 14

A/N: Hey Guys! This weeks finally thanksgiving break for me! I finally get a few days to relax from college. I wanted to let you all know that since it's thanksgiving break, my family is bringing me back home for the time being. Sadly, I won't be able to upload for a bit since I'm trying to do this without my parents finding out. So, it might be a bit before I upload another chapter. Anyways, that's all the update I have for y'all. Now, let's jump right into the story!

*Warning for violence, bloodshed, and killing. I do not condone the use of violence to solve problems. If you use violence to solve a problem, you may not say to have gotten the idea from me.*

Y/N = your name

F/F = favorite food

F/D = favorite drink

E/C = eye color

H/C = hair color

"Talking"

'thinking/voice in head/talking in your head'

"Beast talking/Demonic voice"

[Y/N's POV]

Another day, another morning. I woke up a bit later than usual, which is odd since normally my alarm goes off at around 9:00 am. I took a look at my alarm and saw the time stuck at 3:17 am. I sigh since I'm now going to have to check what the problem is and possibly buy a new alarm clock. I pick up the alarm and place it on the kitchen table as a reminder for me to check it later. I then got dressed, ate some breakfast, brushed my teeth, combed my hair, and finally packed my bag. I put on my headphones and started my walk to the guild listening to some Three Days Grace.

As I got close to the doors of the guild, I sensed a lot of tension in the air from within the guildhall. I paused my music, took my headphones off, and prepared for what lied in wait behind those doors. Opening the doors to the guild, I see a pissed off Erza and a frustrated Makarov by the bar. My curiosity took control and caused me to walk over to the bar. Pulling out a new light pen I had bought, I asked them what was happening.

Y/N: *writing* Hey, what's going- *Erza takes pen from my hand*

Erza: *glaring* "I thought we agreed that you would start talking more often."

Y/N: 'My poor pen! I just bout that as well. *internally cries* I swear this woman is trying to kill me' "....."

I really don't feel like dealing with Erza lecturing me on talking more often, so I just decided to get it over with. I'm going to regret this later on.

Y/N: *quietly and avoiding eye contact* "What's going on?"

Erza: *stern* "It's Natsu, he took an S-class quest and brought Lucy along as well."

Y/N: *sighs* *quietly and stuttering* "Which one did he take?" 'Knowing Natsu, he probably took the Galuna Island Quest so he could bribe Lucy to come along due to he reward. It's funny, that quest shouldn't even be an S-class quest. The most dangerous thing on that island is a demon that's 98% dead.'

Erza: *stern* "He took the one on Galuna Island. I am going there to bring them back to the guild for their punishment."

Y/N: 'Knew it.' *quietly and stuttering* "Leave them be. The quest shouldn't have been an S-class quest anyways. There's nothing that dangerous on the Island there."

Erza: *stern* "How can you be so sure?"

Y/N: *quietly and stuttering* "Research, and a past quest I did took place on an island. I was sent there to find an assassin who was hunting demons and the only thing that was really 'dangerous' was Deliora, who's 98% dead and still dying."