How to steal a heart: 2 [COMPLETE]✔️

Chapter 27

"So have you told your grandma?" I said, clenching my teeth when I said her name. "Please don't tell her." He looks worried. "I won't, but can I ask why?" He sighs. "She doesn't approve of that." I sigh, how could she not? She's gonna get a piece of me when I see her again. "Do you know why?" I ask. "She said that no one in her family is gay........ so for her to have a gay grandson is a terrible sin." I felt bad for Elijah. No one should be told that. I reached over to grab his hand. "It's not a sin to be with the person you love, regardless of their gender." His face lights up and we continue to enjoy our time at the restaurant until I saw a text from Ben. 'Doesn't Elijah look just like his father?' I looked at Elijah and the memories of that night come rushing back. I try to push it out of my mind by shutting my eyes and focusing on spending time with Elijah but he keeps on sending messages. 'You can't fight it Natalie. Remember.' What the hell is wrong with him? He's so evil. I shake my head and turn my phone off to enjoy the time I have with Elijah, but it's always something. Out of nowhere, I see Ben walking up to our table. "Is this sit taken?" I stand up and quickly grab him to drag him somewhere that Elijah won't hear us. I told JP to stay with him. "What the hell is your problem?" He smiles evilly. "What? I'm just trying to make up with you-" "Cut the shit. I read those nasty messages you sent. You're a sick psycho." I punched him in the face before leaving. "Stop following me, this is my last warning." I yell over my shoulder.