Trouble (Eren/Reader/YandereArmin)

Chapter 5

A/N:I usually put this at the end, but just a fair warning this is a little cringe in my opinion. I wanted to do this to deepen certain characters feelings... yeah, jury's out on whether I think it worked or not. Also, I googled every single question or dare in this. Fair warning, in the next few chapters I plan on making this progress a little more maturely and perhaps intensely.

"So we all know the rules-" Ymir's eyes landed on (Y/N) who sat sandwiched between Armin and Eren on the smaller couch in the living room, "You don't. You sure you wanna play? We're not gonna go easy on you just because your Eren's new girlfriend."

A faint blush rose to her cheeks, maybe the reference to being Eren's girlfriend, or maybe it was the wicked grin the brunette wore on her face that made (Y/N) slightly nervous. She'd played truth or dare before... how bad could it be?

"Don't listen to her! It'll be fun, we will go easy on you!" Ymir's girlfriend, Historia, piped up easing the newcomer's nerves. Surely, she wouldn't quite get Ymir's sense of humor; it was more or less an acquired taste. (Y/N) was thankful for Historia's kind smile... she and Ymir were quite the opposites, but that made them all the more functional as a couple in her opinion. They were cute.

"Fine!" Ymir's smile returned, "Rules are simple, obviously truth or dare is pretty easy EXCEPT there's one twist here. All of our names go into a hat, and if you can't or won't answer a question or do a dare then a name gets picked and you have to send them a racy pic. Got it?"

"Define racy..." (Y/N)'s nerves began to bubble up a little bit. The only consequence to playing the games of truth or dare she had been involved in had been very mild bullying. Maybe this wasn't the best idea and she just wanted to watch.

"You don't have to play," Eren reminded her before going on to explain, "But just like you know, something you wouldn't want your parents to see. The other rule that should be unspoken but you know, the pictures do not get distributed."

If Eren didn't seem to be bothered, then it couldn't have possibly been too bad, right? She was friendly with most of the people there, so surely, they wouldn't be too mean to her. "Alright, I'll play."

"Historia's getting the hat ready... sooo... Connie goes first! We know you'll do anything," Ymir laughed before turning her attention to the boy who sitting beside Sasha on the floor, "Truth or dare?"

"Dare, obviously!"

"Alright, let Sasha look through your camera roll for a full minute."

Connie didn't even seem to think about it. He just handed his phone over, and looked over her shoulder while she scrolled. Apparently, he mostly had saved memes, a few embarrassing photos and videos of himself, Jean and Eren (that Sasha so kindly shared) and then Sasha shrieked and threw his phone back at him, "Gross! Hide your dick pics better!"

"Gross?! That's grade A dick right there!" Connie cackled along with the rest of them. After taking a moment or two to calm his laughter he turned his head a few times, eyeing everyone and trying to find the next victim, "Uhh... Mikasa, truth or dare?"

"Truth."

"Out of everyone here, if you had to sleep with someone who would it be?" Connie wiggled his eyebrows.

"(Y/N). The reason being, she seems the most normal." The faintest hint of a smirk could be found on her lips. Whether or not she had been telling the truth was up for debate, but she could definitely see the wheels turning in a few people's heads. "Armin, truth or dare?"

Armin had mixed emotions about being called next. He was simply enjoying the comfort of sitting so close to (Y/N), and didn't really want to be bothered, BUT if he had to get picked then it was always better to get Mikasa, Historia or Annie as they were generally the tamest ones to play. "Truth."

Mikasa ignored the few boos that came from various people, "Have you ever been walked in on while you were watching porn? If so, who?"

Armin had to admit it was a little more than he expected from Mikasa, but it definitely wasn't that bad and the quicker he could get through the question the sooner he could ask someone... and he knew just who he was going to ask. "Yeah, and it was Eren."

"That was boring, we all knew the answer to that one!" Ymir complained, but Mikasa just shrugged not seeming to be bothered by the complaint at all.

"Ummm... (Y/N)... truth or dare?" Armin tried to make it seem like he was thinking about it, but he knew exactly who the next player would be.

"Oh gosh... dare?" She answered cautiously and turned her full attention towards Armin, hoping he would show her some mercy. Of course he would. Not a lot, because there was definitely a part of him that wanted to see her squirm, but he couldn't be too obvious with his advances either.

"Hmm... Okay! I dare you to go commando and wear your underwear on your head for the rest of the game." That should have just enough silliness mixed in with it to make it seem like he wasn't singling out the fact he wanted to see her underwear and have her sit next to him without it.

(Y/N)'s face flushed, "I'm... not wearing any... I didn't want any visible lines with the dress!" She quickly defended, definitely not missing the low whistles she received.

"The hat it is." Historia announced feeling a bit of guilt for the other girl, but regardless she dipped her hand into the baseball cap and swirled around the papers before plucking one out, "It's Armin."

"Do I have to take a new photo or can it be one I already have?" Her face was still a little pink from the previous admission and the new task she'd have to accomplish.

"Doesn't matter," Eren felt for her, and honestly, he wasn't particularly fond of Armin now getting to see her probably half-naked. When she began to scroll through her phone, Eren leaned over whispering to her and pushing his luck just a tad, "You know there's nothing in the rules that say you can't send it to more than one person... just saying."

Armin was a little dazed; his stroke of luck almost completely unbelievable. Too dazed to notice Eren whispering, and definitely too dazed to notice Eren's phone buzzing as well. Armin opened the message ignoring the sorry at the top, instead he burned the image of (Y/N) propped on her bed wearing nothing but a pair of red panties and an unzipped sweatshirt... He needed to close this quickly, otherwise he wouldn't be able to act normal at all. "It's your turn."

"Oh! Sasha, truth or dare?"

"Dare!"

"I dare you to let Jean feed you some chips and after each bite you have to say Thank You Daddy." (Y/N) looked around for approval. Mostly everyone was laughing, so she assumed it was a decent proposition. It was even funnier to watch it unfold. They were all way to entertained by the whole ordeal to notice Armin's reddened face.