The choice is yours (Until Dawn x reader)

*Welcome to the shitshow (chris)* (10)

My head pounded as I lifted it from the table in front of me, the familiar rattle of chains sounded when I tried to move my wrists. The rough metal dug into my skin as I pulled against them. "Oh god not again."

"Oh shit, y/n, Ash?" The voice was male. "Jesus, what did they do to you two?" Chris's voice asked, I blinked, trying to get my eyes to adjust to the darkness.

It was a useless attempt, blinding light turned on and blinded us momentarily. They created a circle of light, but until the lights in the room around them were on, all we could see was each other.

Ashley's eye was dark and puffy, I couldn't see myself but I could feel the blood trickling down my nose and over my lips. "I tried to get away. Bastard broke my nose." I replied.

"I think he hit me." Ash added.

"I swear I'm going to murder his fucking face off!" The anger in Chris's voice was evident.

"What is this?" Ash asked. I tried to pull my hands through the cuffs, hoping that maybe my hands were slick enough to slip through. Or maybe they weren't tight enough and I could get free.

"It's him. It's the man that killed Josh." Chris answered, one of his hands ran through his hair, the other was tied to the chairs arm rest.

"No Chris... oh god no. Oh god Chris!" Ash cries out.

"This is bullshit! Fucking bullshit!" I yelled into the darkness after noticing the gun laying on the table. The saws above our head had been a mere after thought, but of course those would be another thing threateningly lives.

"You murdering piece of shit! You MONSTER!" Chris yells at the man that may or may not have been in the room.

"Chris look around. We are going to die. I don't think I'm ready to die." Ashley mumbled.

"You two won't die. I won't let that happen." I said, "you hear that?" I asked the darkness.

"I wish I could tell you Chris! It's not fair." Ashley wailed.

"What? Tell me what?" He asks.

"We're always talking around it and I mean now- we've wasted everything!" She replied.

If Chris likes you and not Ashley, option 1:

"Ash what are you talking about?" Chris asks again, he sounded genuinely confused.

"Chris are you stupid? Obviously she is talking about how you two are madly in love!" I snapped, I was tired of these two. Ashley was always going to be the one that Chris picked, it was easier to avoid when You weren't tied to a chair between them.

"What? Ashley is she being serious?"

"Of course she is Chris! We've been avoiding the subject for so-"

"Ash," he cut her off. "If this is truly the last thing I will ever do I need it to do this. I'm sorry if it seemed like I was leading you on. But y/n, every second I spent with you was all I wanted in my life. All I wanted was for me to be able to protect you, be there for you... love you. I'm sorry I didn't say something sooner!"

"Chris, please tell me this isn't some prank." I said, "please tell me you aren't fucking with me right now."

"I swear Y/n," he said, hanging his head. Ashley had gone very silent now. "Y/n I swear when we get out of this-"

—

If Chris likes Ash, option 2:

"Ashley, none of it was wasted. Every second that I spent with you was all I ever wanted to do with my time."