The choice is yours (Until Dawn x reader)

•Rejoin with the others (mike)• (10)

Mike and I had been wandering the halls for what felt like hours. I would run my hand over the walls if I felt myself getting weak, leaving a bloody trail among the dirt. There was a door up ahead, and a few noises coming from there.

"Maybe it's a way out." He offered the thought as if it hadn't been spoken multiple times before.

"Mike we are lost!" I reminded as he pushed on the door.

"Locked. Of course it's locked." He mumbled, "sit down, I'll find a way to get it open."

I didn't fight back, immediately taking the opportunity to rest. He looked through the wall grate and into the next room. "No fucking way. Sam.... Sam wake up!"

I looked over at him and tried to see past his head, "Sam?"

"Mike, Y/n, Is that you?" Sure enough Sam's familiar voice called from the other room. Mike hushed her. "What?"

"Get over here!" Mike instructed. I used the wall to help me stand, making my way over to him to see Sam as well.

She was tied to a chair on wheels, convenient. She rolled over to him, back facing us.

If Mike cut off his fingers:

He uses the machete to cut the ropes, passing it to her and letting her do the ones around her feet. "Ow... ow... argh! H-h-hurry... hurry!"

•••

If Mike broke the machete:

He pulled out his lighter, holding it under the rope and burning a hole through them. He let Sam undo the ones around her feet.

•••

Sam got off the chair, kneeling in front of us to talk. She held her towel tightly around herself. "What are you guys doing here? Y/n, what happened to you?" She paused for a moment, noticing the other thing that was off. "Where's Jessica? She's not with you."

"He killed her, Sam. There's some maniac on the mountain who is trying to kill us. All of us. And I swear to God, when everyone is safe and accounted for I am gonna hunt that fucker down and rip his nuts off one at a goddamn time."

"You absolutely are not going to do that Mike!" I said, "you are not leaving my sight."

"Woah." Sam mumbled, taking in the information that he just dropped on her. "Listen, this guy who you're talking about... he attacked me. He showed me these videos, too, and one of them showed Josh being killed... just... ripped appart by this huge fucking saw blade..."

I gasped, putting a bloody hand over my mouth, "no. No no no!"

Mike put his arm around me, "Jesus Christ! What the fuck is happening? Hey there's a door that's locked over here, think you can open it?" He asked, holding me close to him.

"Yeah, yeah I'll try." She picked her backpack up off the ground and walked through a doorway.

"There has to be a logical explanation. There's no way Josh is- he can't be." I rambled, "No this isn't real. Mike this can't be real. Maybe if I had gotten to them instead of being caught I could have saved him. Maybe Sam didn't see what she thought she did." I started to panic, feeling the overwhelming guilt find it's way into my mind. "Shit!"

"Hey hey hey, it's gonna be okay. You had nothing to do with this. Take a deep breath, we will find out what's going on together okay? It's going to be okay." He pulled me towards the door that Sam was opening. "Hey," he said as she appeared behind the now opened door.

"Jeez, you two look like hell."

"Nice to see you too."

Sam walks past us, placing her backpack on the ground and rummaging through it. "What are you doing?" I asked.