The choice is yours (Until Dawn x reader)

Tragedy (1)

Just going back and editing some things!

I stare out the window as the fluffy snow falls to the ground, a sigh escapes my lips. The others had gone upstairs, giggling and whispering. So now I was alone, leaning over the counters in the kitchen to get a good look of the night sky. Well, not all alone, Chris and Josh were here. They are both passed out drunk and slumped on the island though so.

Beth entered the room, "Hey (y/n) have you seen Hannah?" I turned my attention away from the outside world and back to reality. "No, can't say I have." She looks around the room and spots her brother, Josh, laying on the counter.

"Wow Josh, you really out did yourself." Beth patted his shoulder, which caused him to groan, not opening his eyes. "What's this?"

"What's what?" I questioned and walked over to her side, Beth held a piece of paper in her hand.

"You look so damn hot in that shirt...
But I bet you're even hotter out of it.
Come to the guest room at 2 AM :)
Mike xxx"

"What did she get herself into?" Beth set down the paper and went to the window, starring outside for a moment. Suddenly she ran to her jacket, "Try and wake up Josh, I'm going to find the others." With that she ran out the door.

"Josh, Joshua wake up!" I shook his shoulder, Beth seemed in a hurry and I was staring to get a bad feeling. I gave up on Josh and ran outside, the cold snow hitting my cheeks and bare arms.

"It was just a prank Han!" Emily's annoying voice met my ears as I caught up to them. "what prank?" I asked as I shoved her out of my way, "Where's Hannah and Beth going?"

"It was just a harmless prank." Mike explained, "Yeah 'harmless'. Just wanted to teach that little B to stay away from my man." Emily finished, I looked at her in disbelief, quickly turning to catch up with the twins. A hand gripped my arm, "Beth will find her. Just let them be." Mike pulls me back inside, which I hated, and sat me down on a chair in the living room.

The fire was cracking and popping in front of us, filling the silence that fell within the group. A grunt came from the kitchen and clumsy footsteps followed along with a bottle falling and shattering. A very drunk blonde entered the room, his glasses crooked and hair a mess. "You look like shit." I commented, Chris leaned against the wall, slouching slightly.

"Shhhh I feeel gReAt." He stumbled over his words and made his way over to me. He swatted my leg and I pushed myself off the chair, moving to sit on the armrest. Chris threw himself in the chair and put his head on my lap, he and I have always been best friends since as long as I could remember.

I sat playing with his hair, light snores left his mouth as he drifted off to sleep again. "I hope the girls are OK," Sams voice filled the void. "Should we go find them?" She was the only one brave enough to state what we were all thinking.

"I feel awful, the prank was my idea." Jess threw her head in her hands and her shoulders shook violently, soft sniffles came from her. "Not our fault she can't take a joke." Emily received some glares as these words left her mouth, she shrugged and crossed her legs, examining her nails. "Right babe?" She looked at Mike who sat next to her, he was staring at his hands, studying them.

"Mike?" She nudged him and he looked up, "I'm sorry what?" He seemed pretty out of it, hehung his head while shaking it. "We shouldn't have done that. It was stupid and we hurt her." A few moments of silence passed before Emily pushed herself off the couch and stomped to where she was staying.

The others slowly began to follow her example, just less aggressive. The only people that were left in the room were me, Sam, Chris, and now a very drunk Josh. Sam's leg was bouncing and she was glancing out the window, looking for them. Josh had come into the room just a few minutes ago, bumping into a wall, which he then proceeded to yell at. Chris continued to snore, and I haven't been able to move due to his head still being on my lap.

Josh wandered over to me, "Heyy you're cute. Do I know you?" He slurred with a smirk on his lips. "Josh, we've known each other since 3rd grade. Alright that's it, Chris wake up." I patted his head and set a hand on Josh's shoulder. Chris mumbled unhappily but gave in and slowly sat up, rubbing his head.  "Let's get you boys to bed, come on hun, up." I took both of Chris' hands and pulled him up, he swayed a bit before regaining balance. "Sammy, you should get some sleep. I'm sure B-" I glanced at Josh, deciding not to mention Beth and Hannah, the last thing we needed was him running off. "I'm sure they will be here soon."

"Yeah.. yeah, I'll go in a bit." I gave her a sympathetic look before putting a hand on Chris' back and linking my arm with Josh's. "Okay, let's go you two." We slowly made our way up the stairs and I brought Chris to our room, we were sharing one due to there not being enough rooms for all of us. Sam and Jess were also sharing a room, along with Mike and Em.

"Alright Chris, you lay down. I'm going to take Josh to his room and I will be back soon." I gently pushed him onto the bed, but he stood and slowly walked to his bag, grabbing a change of clothes. The dirty blonde man turned shooed me out of the room. I pulled Josh away and down the hall, "Where's my sisters?" The sudden change of tone in his voice caught me off guard.

"What?" He stopped walking and turned me towards him, his hands on my shoulders. "You heard me, I may be drunk but I'm not stupid. Why aren't my sisters here?"

"The others pulled a really mean prank on Han. She ran off into the woods and Beth chased after her, they haven't come back yet." I saw the worry and sadness fill his eyes as the words leave my mouth

"Why didn't you get me, I would have gone after them."

"I tried. I guess part of me didn't want you to wake up either. I don't want you to run off too." He started walking again and I tried to follow but he shook his head, not looking back at me. I got the hint and decided to go back to my room, but then I heard soft whimpers coming from the living room.