Hate that I love you

•24•

(Stacy 👆🏼)

•1 month later•

•Finns pov•

I've been trying to get back Rachel but she won't even budge. I am talking to this girl Stacy though!

Rachel and I were never meant to be together. I actually think I might have a shot with Stacy. People might think of her as a slut but screw them.

I was already for my date with Stacy when I got a call from Kurt.

(Phone call)

K: We have a problem!
F: Kurt I'm busy!
K: Rachel is dating Jesse!
F: Whatever I have to go.

(End of phone call)

I honestly wasn't jealous... Ok maybe I am but who cares right? I got in my truck and drove to Stacys house.

I got to her house and got out of my car. When Stacy answered the door she looked hot but a little slutty.

F: Don't you think that's a little too tight and short?
S: No.
F: ... Okay can you sing?

S: OMG yes I'm perfect at singing. I honestly deserve a record deal.
F: I bet you do. *kisses cheek* That's good because we're going to a karaoke bar.

...Then We were off...

•Karaoke bar•

When Stacy and I got there, there was someone else singing already. I noticed the voice but who was it?

I got closer, Stacy close behind and saw Jesse and Rachel singing.

•Rachel's pov•

(Before Finn and Stacy)

Jesse and I are back together! He told me he's taking me out to a karaoke bar. I got dressed and put my makeup on. (Outfit in season 4 episode the the break up when Finn,Rachel and Brody got to the Karaoke bar)

I heard a knock on the door and went to get it thinking its Jesse. When I got to the door I saw Kurt standing there.

R: I'm busy and have placed to be.
K: Where are you going.
R: I'm going with Jesse to a karaoke bar.

K: Are you guys back together?!
R: Ya...
K: What about Finn?
R: I'm done with him.

Then another knock came and I just prayed it was Jesse. I opened the door and there was Jesse!

J: You look amazing!
R: Thanks, so do you.
K: You hurt my friend, I hurt you. *leaves*

J: Ready?
R: Yes.

•Karaoke bar•

When we got there I immediately wanted to sing! After a lot of begging Jesse finally agreed to do a duet with me.

We went on stage and grabbed two microphones.

J: We're go to sing 'listen to your heart'
(Starting song)

Rachel:
I know there's something in the wake of your smile
I get a notion from the look in your eyes, yea
You've built a love but that love falls apart
Your little piece of heaven turns too dark

Listen to your heart
When he's calling for you
Listen to your heart
There's nothing else you can do
I don't know where you're going
And I don't know why
But listen to your heart
Before you tell him goodbye

Yeah

Sometimes you wonder if this fight is worthwhile
The precious moments are all lost in the tide, yeah

Jesse and Rachel:
They're swept away and nothing is what it seems
The feeling of belonging (Rachel: belonging to your dreams)

I look and saw a couple come in. They got closer to the stage and I noticed it was Finn and some slut!

(Jesse: Listen to your heart)
When he's calling for you
Listen to your heart
There's nothing else you can do
(Jesse: I don't) know where you're going
And I don't know why
But listen to your heart
Before you tell him goodbye

Oh, oh, oh, oh

And there are voices
That want to be heard
So much to mention
But you can't find the words

Rachel (Jessse):
The sense of magic
The beauty that's been (beauty that's been)
When love was wilder (with Jesse: than the wind)

Jesse and Rachel:
Listen to your heart
When he's calling for you
(Rachel: Listen to your heart) (Jesse: Listen to your heart)
(Rachel: There's nothing) else you can do
I don't know where you're going
And I don't know why
(Rachel: But listen to your heart) (Jesse: Listen to your heart)
Before, oh!

Listen to your heart (Jesse: Listen to your heart)
(Rachel: Take a listen to it), whoa
I don't know where you're going
And I don't know why
But listen to your heart
Before you tell him goodbye.

(End of song)

Jesse and I got off the stage and went to get drinks. I heard music play and looked at the stage. There was Finn on the stage ready to sing!

(Start of song)

Lyrics
I don't like the way he's looking at you
I'm starting to think you want him too
Am I crazy, have I lost ya?
Even though I know you love me, can't help it

I turn my chin music up
And I'm puffing my chest
I'm getting ready to face you
Can call me obsessed
It's not your fault that they hover
I mean no disrespect
It's my right to be hellish
I still get jealous

'Cause you're too sexy, beautiful
And everybody wants a taste
That's why (that's why)
I still get jealous

'Cause you're too sexy, beautiful
And everybody wants a taste
That's why (that's why)
I still get jealous

I wish you didn't have to post it out
I wish you'd save a little bit just for me
Protective or possessive, yeah
Call it passive or aggressive

I turn my chin music up
And I'm puffing my chest
I'm getting ready to face you
Can call me obsessed
It's not your fault that they hover
I mean no disrespect
It's my right to be hellish
I still get jealous

'Cause you're too sexy, beautiful
And everybody wants a taste
That's why (that's why)
I still get jealous

'Cause you're too sexy, beautiful
And everybody wants a taste
That's why (that's why)
I still get jealous

You're the only one invited
I said there's no one else for you
'Cause you know I get excited, yeah
When you get jealous too

I turn my chin music up
And I'm puffing my chest
I'm turning ready to face you
You can call me obsessed
It's not your fault that they hover
I mean no disrespect
It's my right to be hellish
I still get jealous

'Cause you're too sexy, beautiful
And everybody wants a taste
That's why (that's why)
I still get jealous

'Cause you're too sexy, beautiful
And everybody wants a taste
That's why (that's why)
I still get jealous

Oh (that's why)
I still get jealous
Oh (that's why)
I still get jealous

(End of song)

Finn was staring at me the whole time! I looked at Jesse and he looked like he was about to Kill Finn. I took his hand and led him out of the Bar.

When I got home I got dressed in my Pjs and got ready for bed. When I finally hit my pillow I couldn't fall asleep.
There was only one question in my mind.

Who was that slut... Oops girl!