IT ALL STARTED IN HIGH SCHOOL

Rekindling Old Flame

"In your dreams. Now move." I whisper shouts at him. My voice was muffled by his lips on mine. My eyes shot wide open and I stood there frozen. 'What is he thinking' I thought to myself as I stood there. "Send that son of a bitch home. I am taking you home." He repeats. "No." I said firmly. "Well you're taking me home then." He says kissing me again.
This time the kiss lasts longer and goes deeper. His hands went under the side split of my dress and between my legs. I tried pushing him off but I couldn't. "Stay still." He commands me. He slowly finds his way through the foot of my panty and started massaging me with his fingers. He rubs my clit. God this feels so good. Its so wrong. I mean after all the bullshit he has said. "Caleb stop." I begged. "No. You're mine." He says refusing to stop. "Did you know I was yours when you were talking shit to Bailey about me?" I guess saying that was the safe word to get him to stop.
He suddenly starts hitting the wall of the stall with the palm of his hand. The sounds made me afraid. "I am sorry." He says leaning his head against the slightly bent wall. "Sorry for what? Hurting me or not being able to complete step two of your plan back then?" I pushed pass my fear and fright to say. He looks over at me and I can see the sorrow in his face. There is just something there that he refuses to tell me. The truth perhaps.
We stand there in silence for a while. I finally tell him I have to go because my boyfriend is going to come looking for me any minute now. "He is not your boyfriend. I am. Nobody else will ever be. I am not going to lose you again. I fucked up 8 years ago and I am going to get you back even if it takes the rest of my fucking life. You belong to me." He firmly tells me. "So either you come home with me or I will go home with you. Pick your choice and meet me outside." He says walking out of the stall and out of the bathroom.

I stood there for a while. Composed myself and went back to my table. "Hey are you ok?" Shawn asks once I sat down. "Oh yeah. Yeah I am. I huh waited for it to dry a little." I half lied. "Some people just walk without watching where they are going. That guy is lucky we are in a decent place." He chuckles but for some reason I am offended by his comments. "Huh can we leave now I am really tired." I tell him after I glimpsed Caleb walking pass the a couple two tables over and heading outside.
We talked a little on our drive back. Once he pulls in to the drive way we sat in the car and talked a bit more. He moves in for a kiss but I pulled back as if I have sensors that can predict he would try to do that. "We should call it a night. I am really tired." I said faking a yawn. "Ok. Let me walk you to your door." And with that we made our way to my front door. I opened the door and turn to bid him good bye. "Thank you for tonight. I had a wonderful time." I say hoping he would take that and go. "Huh..ok....I guess this is it." He says as if he was expecting more.
I stood looking at him until he turns and leaves. I closed the door behind me, took off my heels and plopped myself down in the couch and laid back.

The knock at the door made me feel upset. "Shawn did you le......" I trail off realizing who it is that actually knocked. "Caleb. What the hell are you doing here?" I asked looking over his shoulders to see how he got here. "I gave you two options and you choose this one." He says and pushes pass me.
I closed the door and followed behind him ready to curse him out for invading my home. "I told you...to...leave...." I said between kisses being planted on my lips. His tongue searches my mouth and plays with my tongue. With one swift lift I was in his arms. "Where is your bedroom?" And I directed him using eyes as the clue.

Once inside we started kissing each other passionately. He hovers over me as we continue to make out. "I missed you every day for the pass eight years. I am so happy to be here now." He says while continuing to kiss me. He pulls back and starts removing his shirt. He is so sexy. Damn. In two minutes we are both butt naked. He pushes me back further on the bed and made a trail of romantic kisses from my lips all the way down to my belly button. He caresses my legs. "Open up for me." I follow his instruction without hesitation. He lowers his head and kisses my pussy. My reaction made him look up. "Can see it's been a while." He smirks and goes back to kissing my pussy. I opened wider as if I wanted him to suck harder and deeper. He circled my clit and sucked on my pussy lips....I feel him tongue fucking me and then back to sucking on my clit. "Aaaaah...hhmmmmmm......yeaaaaah...." I kept moaning as I massaged my fingers through his hair. The more I moaned the more he sucked and tongue fucked me. My belly tightened and I tried moving his head away but he pushed my hands away from his head then gripped my legs harder and sucking up all my juices....I moved in synch to the movement of his head until he takes in every drop of my succulent juices. "Hmmmmhm..still taste the same." He tells me licking his lips. "Now open up...." He says showing me his dick. It somehow looks longer and bigger than I remembered.
I opened my legs and he climbs up towards my face and slowly thrust his dick inside me. I arched my back to accommodate him. Damn I longed for this. I love this moment. His rhythm is just perfect. Going deep inside me and then moving his hips side to side while still deep in.
Damn. He is going faster and smoother. I love every inch of this man's body right now. He looks down at me and takes my lips for a kissing tour. With every thrust there are two kisses and a tongue dance. I hugged him gripping his back. "Hmmmmhmmm.....ooooohhhhh......yeah.....more....." I begged him. "Am yours Caleb. Say it." He tells me while fucking me harder. I was hesitant but he bites my lips and goes real deep inside me. "Am yours Caleb." I moaned pulling him down for a kiss. With one quick spin I am on my knees getting fucked doggy style. His thrust are wild yet enticing. The bed is shaking real hard. My belly feels as if its about to tear apart. This man wants to kill me with his dick. I reached behind me to hold him off but he holds on to my hand and keeps it behind me and increase his tempo. We completed two other positions and then finally he pulls out and cum all over my sheet.

He drops beside me panting as if he just ran a marathon. "I missed this. It feels like fucking you for the first time all over again." He says and turns on his side and plays with my right nipple. "Caleb......" I was about to tell him to stop and leave but I don't want to seem like a two dollar bitch so I decided to ask him a few questions. "Why do you want to be with me so much now?" "It's not just now. Its all the time. From the day we met, the day I fucked up and everyday from then till now. Nessa you are mine." "Caleb why are you so possessive? You do know I am a free woman right?" "Am only possessive towards things I know should belong to me and you are one." "What about Casey and Bailey?" "Well......I don't want to talk about that right now. But as you can see Casey is doing ok so far. I just want to fuck you again and again. To make up for lost times." He teases by sucking on the same nipple. "Come on babe. Am so sore right now." Hearing myself call him babe shocked me. I don't know how that slipped out.

"Nessa let's start over. Let me make up for all I did. Please." He looks at me with pleading eyes. I don't know how to respond to that desire. I just can't get caught up in another web of lies. "Caleb please don't ask for something like that from me. I can't." I honestly responded. "What about saying you are mine? Doesn't that count for something?" He asks sitting up in bed. I sat up with him and leans over on his shoulder with my head. "I don't want to get hurt again. Its been so long yet the memory is the same." I wanted him to know I remembered everything like it was yesterday. "I had no choice. You wouldn't even understand. Do you think I really had a video of us fucking in the cabin? Or that any of what you read in the messages is the truth?" He asks looking own at me. "I don't know what the truth is anymore since that day. You are my first again in 8 years." I tell him a bit ashamed.

"I lied to protect you. I did it so that Bailey would not make your life a living hell. Being pregnant at the time means that she could do whatever she wanted and nothing would come of it. She threatened to do an abortion if I didn't leave you. So I had to do something to let her think it was only because of the stupid bet." Hearing all this is making more sense than what I had in mind back then and a few minutes ago.

I got up and straddle him. "Am sorry Caleb." "Its not your fault. You know that after you left I went to see your dad that evening to ask if you were at home and he said he sent you to a boarding school and its best to keep your whereabouts private? I was so mad for around four months. I got into a lot of fights too whenever your name was called into a conversation. I couldn't eat or sleep properly." Hearing him say all this made me realise that because of my selfish thinking he suffered too. I hugged him a little tighter and sobbed. "Caleb....please know that I am sorry." I repeated.
I can feel his hand soothing my head. I guess to make me feel better. We sit there in silence just holding each other.
"I want to leave my mark on your body.." Caleb's says and started squeezing my thigh. "Here." He points, indicating to a spot on my inner thigh. I pulled back and sit on the bed with my thighs ready and waiting. In less than three minutes two hickey are on my thighs.

His phone rings from inside his pants pocket. He got up from the bed to go and answer the call. "Hello...yes. I am coming home soon. The meeting is not over as yet. We are finalizing some details. Yes Casey and I have settled in well so far. Hope you wrap up your end and join us soon." He says looking over at me. I got off the bed and walked to him. I started massaging his dick. God I feel like a horny lonely woman. He looks at me and licks his lips then pull me in for a kiss. I returned his kiss then got down on my knees and begin sucking on his erected cock soaked with a little pre cum as if it is a giant lollipop. "Can we not fight right now. I am in the middle of something." Hearing him say this hinted that he is talking to Bailey. I stopped and moved away and headed to the bathroom as he continued his conversation with her.