5SOS Preferences

This is Why - His POV

Calum-

You came on so strong then you backed it off
When did you get the nerve to call it love

"I have a bone to pick with you," I walked up to her. "At first, you and I were going good. You were always cuddling with me and being all lovey. Sometimes, I had to lock myself in my room so that I could have some space to myself, but I always knew that you would wait for me. I always knew that when I walked into the house, you would be there to greet me with kisses. But now that (Y/N) is in my life, you backed off!" I looked at my English bulldog who looked at me with a guilty look. "No, that look isn't going to work on me. How could you call what me and you had love when you are loving on my girlfriend?"

"Cal, baby, why are you practically breaking-up with Roxy?" (Y/N) laughed. Roxy looked at her then looked at me. "Just sit down on the other side of Roxy."

I grumbled and sat down. Within seconds, Roxy had turned around and laid her head in my lap and (Y/N) got up to sit on my other side. She leaned into my shoulder and I smiled. I pet Roxy's ear and rubbed her belly a little then I kissed (Y/N)'s forehead.

"Roxy knows that you and I have a different love than you and her. Just like Roxy and I have a different love than you and her." (Y/N) explains. "You should see her when you are on tour. It breaks my heart. She refuses to sleep anywhere but your side of the bed. Do you still not want to call that love?"

"No, that's love. That's the love of man's best friend."

Ashton-

So if you're wondering why I'm leaving
Stop a second and count the reasons

"Ashton?" (Y/N) was confused when she opened the door and saw that it was me.

"We need to talk." I said seriously. It took a lot to not grab her and take her upstairs and love her.

"Yeah, come on in." She stood to the side and let me walk in. She kept her confused look as we just stared at each other. "What's up?"

"Whatever we are doing, I'm done." I said easily. "I can't do it anymore so I'm leaving."

"Wait, why? I thought we were doing alright?" She looked shocked.

"We were, except that I can't do it anymore. It's not like you are not going to be on your own anymore. You have other friends with benefits to play with. I have been in love with you for years and I thought maybe, just maybe, I could handle this kind of relationship, but I can't. I tried and I can't. This is why I am leaving." I shrugged. "I have to get over you because no matter how much you say that you are going to try and be in an actual relationship, it never lasts more than a week. So, I came over to say good-bye. The boys and I are leaving for our tour and I am ending things. I'm sorry."

She looked at me in shock as I walked up to her and pressed my lips to her forehead. With one finally look, I went to the door and walked away, breathing a sigh of relief as I closed her door.

Luke-

You're a part of my past now
I'm making you history

"Hey, Luke, look, is that (Y/N)?" Calum asked me, pointing to a (your hair color) girl with some guy.

"I think it is." I shrugged.

"Aren't you going to go talk to her? Maybe ask her out again?" Calum looked at me with curiosity.

"Why would I?" I laughed. "We haven't seen each other since high school and she is clearly with her boyfriend."

"So, you are just going to let her go again?" Calum was shocked.