5SOS Preferences

One - His POV

Calum-

Take my hand and my
Heart and soul, I will
Only have these eyes for you

"Hey (Y/N)," I greeted when I walked into the kitchen. They were sitting at the bar, a magazine resting in front of them. I stood behind them and kissed the back of their head. "What's that?"

They flipped the magazine closed and on the cover was a picture of me and Nia hugging and laughing. I sighed and rested my forehead on their shoulder.

"The paps are funny," (Y/N) chuckled. "They really think that I am going to believe this? I know that you and Nia are just friends. Hell, Nia is my best friend. She's the one who brought this over. She was so worried that I would be mad at both of you. I just flashed her the ring," they lifted their left hand and wiggled their ring finger, "and said that I wasn't worried and for the paps to do their worst."

They finally looked at me and smiled. I wrapped my arms around their waist and kissed their nose. "Exactly, I only have eyes for you."

Ashton-

Just promise me, you'll always be a friend
'Cause you are the only one

"Ashton," (Y/N) sighed. "I think we need to talk."

I nodded and gave them my attention. "I think you're right."

"You and I know that we were never meant to be more than friends." (Y/N) crossed their arms. "I've tried, Ashton."

"I know," I gave them a small smile. "I should have seen this coming."

(Y/N) came to sit next to me. "I'm so sorry. I know how much you've tried to make us work. I promise you that I've tried to love you more than a friend."

"(Y/N)," I put my hand on theirs. "I'll be okay. I want you to be happy, even if that means that you are not with me. Just promise me that you'll always still be a friend."

(Y/N) hugged me tightly. "I promise." I hugged them back just as tight. They pulled away first. "I should go." They patted my hand before getting up.

I stared at the spot where they had been sitting and listened to their retreating steps. I sucked in a shaky breath as the door opened and closed. I wiped the tear that was threatening to fall from my eye.

Luke-

Tell me that you turned down the man
Who asked for your hand

"Hey," (Y/N) smiled when I walked up to them. Their smile vanished when they saw how serious my face looked. "Luke?"

I stopped and kneeled in front of them. "Tell me that you turned him down."

"What?"

"I know that Jake proposed to you," I looked at their hands and noticed the lack of ring on their left finger. "Did you turn him down or is he getting the ring resized?"

(Y/N) put their hands on my face and smiled softly. "I turned him down. My parents want to try and give a boy false hope, then that's on them. They knew very well that my heart belongs to you and it will always belong to you."

I let out a sigh of relief and placed a kiss on the inside of their palm. "Thank god." I looked at them and held their hands in mine. "One day, I will ask you to marry me. I promise you that. I can't promise you everything money could buy, but I can promise you a life full of happiness and love."

"Good," they leaned down slightly. "All I want is a life full of happiness and love with you."

I smiled and kissed them.

Michael-

I listen to sad songs, singing about love
And where it goes wrong

"Tell me, where did the inspiration for The Only Reason come from?" The interviewer asked. We were on a radio show and were currently answering fan questions. The boys looked at me.

"I was in a relationship that ended out of nowhere," I started after clearing my throat. "I was very much into them but I guess at some point, they fell out of love and didn't want to drag me along while they hoped the love would come back. I kept asking them how I could fix what was broken in the relationship and what I could do to make them stay, but they said they didn't know and they didn't think the relationship could be fixed."

"Would you by chance be talking about (Y/N) (Y/L/N)?"

I nodded before remember that the listeners couldn't see. "Yes. I spent the rest of the day just listening to sad songs as well as love songs, just to see if I could pick out where the relationship turned south. Eventually, that just turned into me writing the song."

"In case (Y/N) is listening, is there something you want to say to them?"

I thought for a moment. "I just hope that they managed to find someone that takes care of them and loves them as much as I did. We weren't meant to be, but I will always love them."

Sorry it has been a while!

I don't have a chapter question for you this time.

If you would like a personal imagine, I am doing those. Just comment/message me:

-Your name

-Which boy
-A prompt/idea of what you want it to be about (NO SMUT AT THIS TIME, PLEASE)

Much love,

~M

Update Schedule:

Tuesdays & Thursdays: 5SOS Preference

Wednesdays: Tolkien Universe