The Shield Preferences

You Get Back Together | Pt. 3

Seth: You were sitting in the canteen with Foxy when she brought up Colby. Since he'd cheated on you things hadn't been the easiest. He was on your mind a lot and trying to keep Jeffrey satisfied was becoming harder. "He doesn't look good. I overheard Kurt saying he's been sloppy in the ring and he hasn't been arriving on time for meetings. He's dropped a weight class too," she gossiped as you grew concerned. Had he really been doing that bad? After you and Foxy were done with your food you found your way back towards the men's locker room only to hear a commotion. "She's mine! You could have gotten with anyone else! You just had to go and choose Y/N," Colby yelled as he pushed at Jeffrey's chest before going to punch him. Before he could Jeffrey put him in a headlock. "Stop! Let him go!" You demanded as Jeffrey became angrier. "He came at me! He deserves it!" You shook your head and kicked Jeffrey in his groin. He let go of Colby and groaned in pain. "Are you kidding me? You just kicked me in the balls for him? We're done. Go and be with a cheater!" Jeffrey yelled out before limping away from the scene. Colby was leaning over trying to catch his breath as you walked over to him. There were dark circles under his eyes and his face looked slimmer than it'd been before. "Foxy told me about your weight loss. Have you been eating?" You asked while leading him to an empty chair. He sighed and took a deep breath. "Please come back," he pleaded with tears in his eyes. You could see that he was a mess. "You hurt me, Colby," you whispered as he cried harder. "I know. I'm sorry," he answered. You sighed and took a deep breath before deciding to give him another shot. You loved him and he was clearly going to continue hurting himself from the guilt. You lifted his head and kissed him. He didn't respond initially but when he did he pulled you close to him and kissed you back. "I love you," he'd whispered before pulling your body closer to his.

Roman: You and William didn't work out so you were single once again. It wasn't as bad as you thought it had been. It was actually better than having to give yourself to someone. You'd come to the conclusion that you should have just been alone after Joe. You were walking back to your station when you realized Joe was due for a haircut. You hadn't given him one since the breakup and you weren't exactly prepared to interact with him. Just when you were about to arrive at your stylist station you were roughly pulled into the men's locker room. Just as you were about to panic you realized it was Joe. He had tears in his eyes as he sat you down on one of the benches. "You had a miscarriage? I got the medical bills in the mail." He spoke. Your heart dropped at his words. He'd finally found out what you'd been hiding from him. Tears welled up in your eyes as you looked down at your hands. You were ashamed that your body was too weak to carry his child. That you failed at something you should have been able to do. "Tell me, baby. Tell me the truth," he pleaded as he got on his knees in front of you. You couldn't take it anymore. You should have told him from the beginning but now was the time. "It happened while you were away. I-I didn't want to tell you because I should have been able to do it. I should have been able to handle it," you admitted before he took a deep breath. "You could have told me. You should have told me," he said as tears tracked further down his face. "I couldn't. I didn't want you to be like this. I didn't want you to feel the loss," you cried as he pulled you closer to him. "I thought you cheated on me. I treated you horribly. I wish you would have just told me. We could have gone through this together. It wasn't your fault. It's still not your fault," he told you as you both cried harder. "I'm sorry," you whimpered. The two of you continued to grieve together until you were both just sitting in the silence. "I love you. Please come home, Y/N," he whispered before kissing your temple. You nodded and kissed him with salty lips before he pulled you even closer.

Dean: You were looking over the names and hometowns of the Superstars performing later that night when a hand grazed your backside. "You finally got rid of that psycho. Now we can finally begin what we've both wanted for the longest time," Cory whispered in your ear as your blood ran cold. Ever since you'd found out about his sneaky conversation with Jonathan you'd cut him off completely. "Get away from me," you demanded as he pushed up against you further. "I finally got the two of you to break up. It only took a few lies to get that brute to believe me," Cory admitted as he now grabbed your breasts. You whimpered in fear as he tightened his grip on your body. "Tell me you want it," he whispered in your ear. Before you could tell him let you go again he was pulled off of you. When you turned around it was Jonathan punching Cory over and over. It took Fergal and two other Superstars to separate Jonathan and Cory. "It's over, man. It's over!" Fergal yelled as he pushed Jonathan away. "He lied. He tried to keep us apart. He touched Y/N!" He's lucky he's breathing," Jonathan growled as Fergal's eyes widened. He looked at you before telling you that if Jonathan was what you wanted then it was alright. He would still be your friend. When you and Jonathan were alone you sighed and looked over at him. You could tell he was beating himself up for not believing you. "It's alright, Jonathan. You don't have to worry about it," you tried to reassure him. He looked up at you and hit his head with the palm of his hand. "I ruined the best thing in my life because I believed that jealous prick. Then on top of that he touched you," he groaned. You shook your head and grabbed his face before kissing him. "Let's just start over. I know it's crazy but what's dating The Lunatic Fringe without some crazy?" You smiled before kissing him again. "I will never find a woman like you," he smiled before kissing you again.

Requested by: @Moxleygal
Please let me know if you like it!