The Shield Preferences

You're Best Friends & You Have A One Night Stand | Pt. 2

Please vote & comment. Enjoy!

Seth: Your throat was dry when you woke up. Your body felt sore and heavy as you tried to sit up. Your vision was blurry as you groaned. You couldn't remember anything from last night so you were still unaware that Colby was lying next to you. You felt a cool breeze on your chest and you realized that your body was bare. Colby groaned next to you which made you jump in fear before falling off the bed. "Y/N?" He asked before wiping his eyes. Your eyes widened as you realized that you'd been in bed with your best friend while naked. "C-Colby? What the hell is going on?" You asked before grabbing the sheet from the bed to cover yourself. He groaned as he sat up, "I know you don't remember last night but I sure you can put the pieces together." You blushed a scorching red as you tried to remember. Flashbacks of Colby's lips on your body and your hands scratching down his back filled your head. Your body shivered at the memory. "We...We slept together. I can't believe this," You said in almost a whisper. Meanwhile, Colby had a pit in his stomach as he thought of what was to come. He feared you'd be angry and not want anything else to do with him. "Y/N, we can talk about it," he offered. You scoffed and ran a hand through your hair. "This is so embarrassing," you mumbled. Colby's brow furrowed as he cocked his head to the side, "Embarrassing? Shocking, yes. But not embarrassing. What do you have to embarrassed about?" You blushed, "You saw me naked! We were intimate! You've seen everything now." It was his turn to scoff. "So what? I know we're best friends but last night was amazing. Don't tell me you don't remember the way you felt. You didn't want to stop," he said as he slid to your side of the bed. You were still on the floor until he wrapped his arms around you and picked you up. You were a mess as you tried to hide your burning cheeks away from him. "We should at least consider everything. That fact that I can't get you out of my head is enough reason for me to ask you to give this, us, a try," he continued. You sighed as he wrapped his arms around you. It did feel nice to have someone. Someone you could be yourself around as well. Colby placed his finger under your chin before lifting your face up. He pecked your lips once before you felt that feeling again. The feeling of letting go of everything thought in your head to enjoy the moment. "We can try," you whispered before turning around to straddle him. His smile was enough confirmation that the two of you could be happy.

Roman:  You stretched and moaned as you woke up. Memories of last night made you smile as you went to turn on your side. Your intention was to ogle your date but the face that was before you made you gasp and sit up. "Joe?" You asked out loud. He stirred beside you making the sheet fall right above his bare bottom. He was lying on his stomach as he settled down. You placed your hand on your forehead as you thought of the odds of your date being your best friend. Once your blindfolds had come off it was too dark to see each other's faces so you hadn't known it was Joe until now. His arm moved towards you as he searched for your body. It was a lazy attempt at a cuddle but it was cute nonetheless. "Mm, baby? Why are you up?" He asked with his voice slurred and his eyes still closed. You tensed up as he placed his hand on your lap. You felt awkward and nervous. "Joe?" You asked. He hummed in response before opening his eyes. He didn't seem shocked as he pulled your body into his. You stared at him with wide eyes. He was alright with the fact that he'd slept with his best friend. "It's me! Y/N! I can't believe we ended up together! Why the hell are you alright with this?" You whisper yelled before he kissed your forehead. "I know it's you. I've known for a little while actually," he admitted. You frowned, "How?" "I woke up at dawn to order the strawberries and I saw your face. It was perfect, you know? The sun was lighting up your skin and your hair was all over the place. It was a shame you weren't awake for the strawberries," he whispered in your ear. You shivered at his words before he let his hand travel to your bum. He squeezed you as your arms wrapped his neck. "We could worry about ruining our friendship or we could enjoy starting something new. I hope you're thinking what I'm thinking," he said before kissing your neck. Joe had left more than enough marks on your body but he wasn't done. "Yes," you whispered before wrapping your finger in his hair. He groaned and rolled over so that he was hovering above you. The way he made you feel was far too intense to let go.

Dean:  You had already been awake for at least an hour and you'd been massaging Jonathan's head the entire time. He was peaceful as he slept. You smiled as you thought of how attractive he looked with a ball of blankets covering his groin. You ran your hands over his chest and stared up at his face. You couldn't believe you'd never thought of Jonathan as more than anything but a best friend. He was gentle and completely selfless. He made you feel beautiful and weightless. You drew circles with your index finger on his beard as he began to stir. "Mm, good morning," he said in a voice that made you bite your bottom lip. "Morning," you said before kissing his cheek. He smiled and placed his hand on your cheek, "You are a wild woman. To think I would have never known if I hadn't kissed you. Your breasts are out of this world too." You smacked his chest and blushed, "Stop! We're not supposed to talk about those things. It's still early." He scoffed, "I've seen everything. Early is not a factor when it comes to us." You shook your head but kissed him anyways. "What if we can't make this work?" You asked. He frowned and tightened his hold on you, "Giving up is not an option. I've waited too long for this. I know we can make this work if we keep our minds open." Your heart swelled at how much he wanted to be with you. It was a little shocking because he was usually quiet when it came to things like this; relationships. "I don't know what you've done to me Jonathan Good but I can't say no to you. I don't even want to leave this bed," you smiled. He chuckled and kissed your forehead. He loved how beautiful you looked with a bare face. He didn't think you needed makeup or fancy clothes. He wanted you for what you possessed inside. Jonathan liked you despite your mannish habits. Hell, he'd kiss you even if you had sauce all over your face like last night. He'd wanted to do so anyways. "Did you know you have a nice set of lungs. I thought you busted my eardrum last night," he teased. You hid your face in his chest as your face turned red. "I like a loud woman. Compliments me," he continued. You sighed in contentment and hoped that everything would work out for the two of you. Despite not having an initial attraction to your best friend you wanted to cuddle with him after wrecking each other's bodies. You wanted him to tease you as you cuddled. You wanted Jonathan more than anything.