Broken (Jeff Hardy x reader)

Chapter 4

Athena's POV

It was Smackdown and I was getting dressed. I heard a knock. I answered it with only half of my gear on. Jeff came in.

"I thought you were wearing nothing on the bottom for a sec." He chuckled while sitting down.

"So you walk in anyways?" I ask.

"Well why not?" He asked. I blushed.

"Because I don't think brothers see there sister's body." I smiled.

"I don't want to be your brother." He said. I stopped what I was doing.

"What? Why?" I asked. I turned around. He was right behind me causing me to jump a little.

"Because I can't li-" He stopped himself.

"Just forget I ever said that." He sat back down. I looked into his love filled eyes. I just wanted to kiss him. 

"Ok? Cover your eyes I need to change." I sighed. 

"I wish I could see." He said under his breath.

"What?" I chuckle.

"Nothing!" He smirks. I sigh. I take of my top. 

"Stop looking." I said.

"I'm not!!" He yelled. I turned around and covered my chest with my top. He quickly covered his eyes. I laugh.

"Come here." He says. I put on my gear and walk over. I nod my head. He hugs me tight. I really should've pulled away but it felt so right. I felt him feeling my back. I was sitting on his lap facing towards him. We were still hugging.

"I love you." He whispers in my ear.

"I-" I got cut off by a knock at the door. I jumped up. I sighed. I answered it and saw my sister.

"I just came to-" She looked at Jeff. "Sorry did I interrupt something?" 

"Nope. You didn't. It was nothing important. Right Jeff?" I smiled.

"To me it was." He denied.

"But to me it wasn't." I chuckle nervously. I lied. Of course it meant something but I am not good at all of this love stuff. He gives me his hurt eyes. I knew he could see my love filled eyes but I tried not to show them. 

"Ok well good luck on the match." She smiled. "Also your match is soon start heading over to gorilla.

"Thank you." Me and Jeff responded. She left and I closed the door. 

"So it meant nothing?" He asked.

"Yes... No... I don't know!!!" I sighed. "I'm confused with my feelings." I walked out and walked over to gorilla. 

"This match is set for a one fall! Introducing first the team of Jeff Hardy and Athena!!! And there opponents the team of Jimmy Uso and Naomi!!!" The announcer yelled. The bell rang and Naomi and I started. We locked up. I kicked her stomach. Then her face. I went on the top turn buckle and jumped off. I fell on her. I went for the pin but she kicked out at 2. She did her finisher on me. I pulled her leg. She fell. I tagged Jeff. Jimmy came in the ring. They fought for a little. Then Jeff did a twist of fate into a swanton bomb. He tagged me after I was recovered. I got in the ring and did a twist of fate on Naomi. I did a swanton bomb. I didn't pin her yet. I grabbed her by the hair. I threw her head against the mat. Then I did P.T.O. She tapped. I smiled. My theme played. Jeff came in the ring. We hugged. Then he kissed me!!! This was not on the script!! What the heck??? I didn't kiss back because I was in shock. He pulled away.

"I'm so sorry." He said.

"Jeff I-" 

"No! I'm sorry! I have to go!" He left the ring. I actually liked it. So what do I do? Do I go back and kiss him? Yes. I left the ring and ran after him but he was already backstage. I sighed.