Finn Wolfhard Imagines (Book 2)

Cheater(P3) - Finn

Read Part 1 and 2 on Book One if you haven't

Recape: Finn cheated on you with some girl so you cheated on him with his best friend Cole. The next morning he walked in on y'all and was heartbroken. Cole explaining about how he was in love with you and then someone leaked pictures of you and him kissing after you explain to Finn that it's over. Made a video to explain and lie and say the break up was mutual. I wonder where you guys are now

Age up: Forgot to mention on old one, you guys are nineteen.

Requested by

Song: I Need To Be Alone by Girl in Red

~

Exactly nine months, and Finn and I haven't spoken, he barely even spoken to Cole until now. Cole and I are still together, and him and Finn are just now hanging out like everything's been normal. I try to avoid him as much as possible but it's hard, his face is everywhere I go. An article, online, in person, and in my dreams. There are times when I literally wanna tear my hair out and scream like batshit crazy. I never told Cole this, but I think I still have feelings for Finn. Apparently as soon as I caught him cheating, he dropped contact with that girl he was with. At least that's what I've heard from Nick.

"Hey babe." Cole murmurs, waking up next to me. His bare chest was touching my bare back as he wraps his arm around me. "You wanna go golfing with me today? Finn, Quincy, and Nick's coming."

I sighed, desperately wanting to say no. "Yeah, let me take a shower first."

"Can I join?" He wiggles his eyebrows.

"As much as I like the idea, no." I giggled, however when I closed the door firmly behind me, everything disappears. I became dull.

When I got out I was dressed in a Nirvana shirt,blue jeans and black boots. Cole was already ready, looking flawless as usual. "Ready?" He asks as I applied minimal mascara. As much as I wanted to lay on the bed and pass out, I nodded.

What Cole didn't tell me was that Nick was picking us up, Quincy in the passenger and Nick in the back. I had no choice but to sit in between Cole and Finn, my eyes flickering at Finn who was trying his hardest to not look my way. His earbuds were in and he said a subtle hi to Cole.

I sighed, staring straight ahead as Cole places his hand on my thighs. I could feel Finn eyes on Cole's hand who was rubbing in circular motions. I bit the inside of my cheek, wanting to be anywhere but here. My hand was lightly shaking, taking deep breathes. Finn finally looked away, but not without looking at me. He knew that I didn't want to be here.

Nick also notice my discomfort, trying to start a conversation with me. "Y/n." He clears his throat. "Aren't you going on that trip to Tokyo next month?"

"Yeah, I'm going with my cousins for my birthday."

"Well if you want any suggestions, hit me up. Tokyo was a blast while I was with Quincy and Finn. You should definitely try to visit anywhere you can."

"I'll make note." I winked. "I'll be gone for two weeks."

"Lucky you." He laughs.

Cole wraps his arm around me a few minutes later, sharing his earbud with me. I gave him a smile, kissing his cheek. Cole decides to tease me by moving his head back, the both of us forgetting everything and giggling as he goes in to kiss me. "Cole!" I whined as he moved back again, dodging a kiss. "Quit being so fucking complicated all the time."

"No, it's fun seeing you get angry. You look adorable." I began to pout, my bottom lip quivering. "No baby not the tears!"

I turned away from him dramatically, suddenly realizing Finn was watching us the whole time. And he didn't look happy. Our eyes met and I couldn't move, frozen in the spot. After a few moments Cole made me turn to him, kissing me softly. "I love you."

Holy shit.

Did he just....

In front of Finn?

Oh shit

Fuck my life

No

No

No

Thankfully Nick slammed on his brakes therefore I couldn't answer. The downside, my head banged against something hard and I felt blood flowing out of my nose. Finn was the quickest to react, grabbing tissues and delicately dabbing my nose. "Are you okay?" He asks sincerely.

"Yeah..."

"I got it from here." Cole says, grabbing the tissues from him. "Babe that looked rough."

I let out a harsh laugh. "You think?"

We arrived to the golf course and I stayed back, watching Cole teach Finn how to golf. I laughed quietly on Finn making a joke and calling him coach Cole. Nick sat down next to me, giving me a glum look. "You doing alright?"

"Yeah..." I liked, fiddling with my bracelet.

"You sure?" I nod, even though he could see clearly through my lie. "Um...if you need to talk about anything, I'm always here." I gave him a small smile, watching him walk off.

Cole turn towards me, laughing at something Quincy was doing. "Babe come here! I wanna teach you how to to play golf!" I sighed, reluctantly making my way towards him. "Hang on, I gotta call my uncle. Uh Quincy, help her out."

I look at him, seeing in glue to his spot. "I don't know how!" He laughs. "Have someone else." I glared at him, knowing he's too lazy to walk three feet in this heat. "I can help you..." Finn says quietly. I swear someone knock the breath out of my lungs. "Okay."

Not saying directions because idk golf

He instructs me on how to play, showing me how to swing and all. I just stood there until he handed me the(literally forgot the name, I'll call it the stuck) stick. I did a few swings, seeing him watch me intently. "Here, let me instruct you." I know he didn't meant to make it seem like he was pulling a move, but my insides were going crazy as he wraps himself from behind. I closed my eyes for a moment as he put his hand in mine, taking a moment to control myself. Finn swung with me and I could feel his breath, he was so close to be our bodies were pressed together, I could feel his heartbeat. And I likes the way it was beating rapidly as if it'll explode any second. I shut my eyes tight as he let out a sigh, his hot breath hitting my neck. If Finn knew that he got a reaction out of me without meaning too, he didn't show it. However, Nick raised his eyebrows at me, Quincy unsure on what to do.

I stood up straight, feeling Finn tighten his grip on me, almost like an embrace. I felt his lips open ready to speak.

"Hey!" Cole barks out of nowhere. Finn and I jumped apart, Cole practically running his way to us. "I got this." He was practically growling at Finn, I could picture saliva coming out of his mouth.

"I-I'm sorry." Finn says quickly.

Cole's P.O.V

"Yeah, I'll be over tomorrow for the barbeque. Y/n can't make it though." I mumbled a few words before hanging up. I started waling back to where we were, freezing in my tracks. The sight infuriated me.

Finn had his arms around Y/n, showing her a swing. I just stood there, seeing Finn tighten his grip on her an looking her the way he used to. It looked as if he was craving her touch, he was looking at her the way I do. I should've known. Finn would always bring her up, asking on how she was. It always got me angry but I kept my cool, saying she's fine. I know this may sound rude but I purposely make her hickies in plain sight for Finn. He did her wrong and now he has to pay the price. She's fucking beautiful and I want it known that she's mine now.

But that wasn't what made me boiling with anger, it was the way Y/n reacted to his touch. I saw the way she bite her lip, her eyes fluttering as he let out a breath that touched her bare skin. I growled with anger, storming over.