Finn Wolfhard Imagines (Book 2)

Cheater(P4) - Finn

Song: Sad Happy by Circa Waves

That evening when we got in the car, I was going to get in the middle but Cole grabbed me, making me have window seat. He didn't growl at Finn no more, he just spoke like they were best friends. Which they are. But I saw the menacing glare he gave Finn whenever he looked my way. Finn was oblivious though.

When we got to Quincy's apartment, Cole's phone dinged and I saw a name that caught my attention. "Hey Cole...why is your ex texting you?" Everyone frozed on the spot and Cole quickly turned to me. He spoke without hesitation. "I'm not cheating!"

"I didn't say you were...I'm just curious." I said, now skeptical.

"Check my phone, I swear." And I did, relived that there was nothing. Just his ex trying to hit him up. I saw a few texts to where he tells her to fuck off. "You believe me?"

I began to laugh loudly. "Yes...but I'm mad you lied to me. You've never told me she was texting. But don't worry, I'll handle this."

"Should I be worried?" He asks, chuckling. I shake my head, wrapping my arms around his waist. In Quincy's I sat in between Finn and Cole. Cole wasn't happy but he didn't say anything.

I watch them engage on Mario Kart, shaking my head at their profanities. "You guys have some serious issues."

"Deal with it." Finn yells, furiously mashing buttons on his controller. "Damn you Nick!" I purposely slap his controller out of his hand, laughing at his overdramatic expression. "I'm next!"

"Don't play just yet! The pizza guy is here!" I saw Cole, him, and Nick jump up like little kids, racing to the delivery boy. Finn and I just ignored them, continuing the game.

Finn bit his lip, furiously trying to get past me. "You're so dead."

"Not if I kill you first." I shot back, shoving him slightly. He curses, getting his car back into control. I raised my eyebrows, throwing any weapon I had at him. Near the finish line I got up, kocking his body to the floor. His controller when flying across the room as I won first place. Finn groans in a pillow, glaring at me. "You cheated."

"How dare you make such accusations." I said with mock innocence, giving him a horrified look. He shakes his head, tackling me. I squealed loudly, trying to pry him off me. "If you didn't suck so much I wouldn't have won!"

"You pushed me!"

"No I didn't! Casper did!" I shot back. Finn pressed his body against mine, putting my hands over my head so I could stop trying to throw hands at him. "Finn." I whined, stopping my movements.

He grins before it suddenly dawned on him on our position. And so did I. Now I'm thinking I shouldn't have cheated. "Uh..." There were no words, we just looked at each other. Both of us wanting the same thing but not making a move. I don't think we were even breathing. He slowly releases his grip from me, and I moved my hands to tangle them in his arm. Finn let's out a shaky groan as I tugged on him hair, our lips crashing. There was no hesitation, no teasing, we dove for it. I don't know what we were doing expect that Finn was deepening the kiss as much as he could, our tongues dominating. I moaned through the kiss, wanting more. Finn couldn't keep his hands off me, until the door burst open.

We went flying across the room, seeing Nick with wide eyes. "W-What?" His voice was high pitched, trying to puzzle the pieces together. We quickly shushed him. "Oh god." He let's out. "Y/n...Cole is going to be heart broken....w-why!"

Finn and I looked at the ground shamefully. "Things just got out of hand."

"I already knew you guys were still nuts about each other but Y/n, you're with Cole. Is this some triangle? Finn cheats on you, you cheat on Finn, and now you cheat on Cole with the cheater? God this is too much." The door burst open again, seeing Cole and Quincy carrying the boxes.