cadnis oneshots so i can get some f*cking sleep

i think i wanna marry you

happy wednesday friends!! this is a request fill for Aubrey_Plaza_Stole_HappiestSeason on Ao3! the actual prompt was very long, but the gist was cadnis trying to surprise one another and a whole lot of misunderstanding, so i kind of wiggled it into a proposal thing.

also, in one of the earlier chapters i said cady's middle name was allison just because i liked the way it sounded, but i was browsing erika henningsen's instagram and found out that she thinks it's jane because of jane goodall and i like that much better. so, it's jane now. enjoy!
————-
"Damian!" Janis calls from the bedroom she shares with Cady in their New York apartment.

"What?!" He calls back.

"Is Caddy home?" She asks loudly, wondering why one of them didn't just go to the other.

"No!"

"Then come here!"

He comes strolling in casually with a bagel, chewing a mouthful. "Wha' you wan'?"

"Finish chewing, I don't want you to choke," Janis demands, knowing him well. He listens, thankfully, swallowing his bite and coming to sit next to her on the bed.

"Okay, what is it?"

"I want to propose to Caddy," Janis rushes out. Exactly as she expected, he sucks in a large gasp, dropping his bagel to press a hand over his heart. "Can you help me?"

"Yes!" He says excitedly. "Oh my god, finally!"

"Finally? We're twenty-two, dude," Janis says, confused. She'd thought they were a bit young to be thinking of marriage.

"Literally everyone in our friend group expected you to get engaged before we started college and elope," Damian responds, leveling her with a single look.

"We'd only been dating for, like, four and a half months by the time you and I left, what the hell kind of toxic relationship did you think we have?!" Janis demands.

"You two were absolutely revoltingly in love, you would've done it and found a way to make it work. I'm just glad you've calmed down a little," Damian jokes.

"Hm," Janis huffs, thinking. They had gotten into things pretty quickly in high school. Their temporary long distance relationship had actually done them a lot of favors. "Anyway, can you help me?"

"Yes, of course! How do you want to do it?" He asks, lying down on his tummy and taking another bite of his bagel.

"I was thinking when we go home for Christmas? Like, on Christmas Eve, maybe. I wanted to take her to some fancy 'holiday' dinner and then take her on a walk to the clearing by that pond where we had our first date, and propose there?" She says quickly. She's planned it for a while, but she still wants to make sure it doesn't sound dumb.

"Aww," Damian coos. "That sounds great, she'll love it. What do you want me to do?"

"Help me pick a ring, first of all. And then, since you're coming back to Illinois with us, help me decorate the place with, like, candles and pretty lights and stuff?" Janis asks, looking to him for approval again.

"Done. You wanna go shopping now?" He asks, shoving the rest of his bagel in his mouth.

"Um... yeah, why not? I'll be ready in a minute," She says, pushing him to the door.

————-

Little did Janis know, Cady was across town with Regina, Gretchen, and Karen coming up with a proposal plan of her own. She'd asked them out on a coffee get-together, trying to bribe them into helping her plan everything.