A year and a half now and no word from (Y/N) about her feelings for me. I thought I got somewhere with that flight but it looks like I haven't. I'll still wait. If I can wait a few years to bring her back to Oz, I can wait for her to make a choice. I found a new musical to take her to tonight and pretty much everyone in Oz is coming to watch it. Glinda recently revealed that she used to know the Wicked Witch of the West and told their story which someone made for the stage.
Apparently, she went to school with the witch along with two men who don't seem to exist anymore. It's like they did once but then disappeared. I'm sure we'll get answers in this musical. I'm nervous to watch it, however. I don't know why but I am. What could I possibly be nervous about? I wasn't around when all that happened. Believe it or not, I was two days old before I met (Y/N) and Dorothy so I don't know what we'll be watching. But I suppose laying on my bed thinking about this won't get me to the theater.
I got up and looked for (Y/N). She's probably in her room putting on a new dress I gave her. This musical is like a special event according to a lot of people in the city so I gave her a special dress for a special occasion. It was a light blue dress with flowers on the collar, on her waist, and on the ends of her sleeves before they become puffy. I knocked on her door telling her it was time to go. When she opened the door to reveal how she looked, I knew I was staring.
She looked amazing! Stunning! Beautiful! Every word that means beautiful is what I'd use to describe how she looked. After I regained my senses, I took her to the theater where everyone was flocking to see the show. We met up with Tinman and Lion before going to our box with them. We sat down and waited for the show to start. We met the Wicked Witch who's name was actually Elphaba. I've heard that name before but where?
As the show went on, we met the two men who don't exist anymore. Fiyero and Boq. More names I've heard but don't remember. Either way, this Fiyero was in love with Elphaba to the point I guessed what had happened to him. But my guess was very much wrong. By act two, Fiyero helped Elphaba escape some guards and he was put in the... what? In the cornfield? But I never saw him. I think you could see the visible confusion on my face.
The next scene was Elphaba casting a spell on Fiyero to save him from dying or feeling pain. That doesn't explain why he's in the cornfield! But I get my answer at the end of the show which made my heart drop. It was me. I went back to the castle where I took Elphaba out of a trap door. She faked her death and... I'm Fiyero. But, I didn't do that! I don't remember any of this!
I just remember being stuffed and sewn by the Munchkin Farmer then put on that pole to scare away the crows! I'm not Fiyero! I can't be! I looked at (Y/N) whose face I'll never forget. She looked betrayed and then angry. I tried to explain but she stormed off. I ran after her. She has to understand!
"(Y/N)! I swear to you, I don't remember any of that! I didn't help the witch!" I said
"Then why does that show say otherwise? How do I know you're not lying to me?" (Y/N) asked me
"You have to believe me! I honestly have no memory of ever knowing Elphaba! The only memory I have of her is when we met her while trying to get you and Dorothy to the Wizard and trying to take her broom! And why would I help someone who tried to set me on fire twice?! I never loved her, (Y/N)! I love you! You have to believe me, please!"
"No! You lied to me! You lied to Dorothy! You lied to Tinman and Lion! You lied to everyone! I'm going to find Glinda tomorrow and I'm going back to Kansas! And I won't say goodbye to you!"
(Y/N) continued to walk off. I tried to speak but she told me to shut up so I said nothing. I was left in the hallway. We should have never gone to see this show. I honestly have no memory of any of that. I don't remember being Fiyero, I don't remember having any love for the witch, I don't even remember helping her after she supposedly faked her death!
I sat down against the wall feeling like such a fool. All this time I've tried to win her heart has been ruined in two hours. And I'll never see her again. I can't bear to lose her like this. I felt a tear fall at the thought of her leaving forever. But I wiped it away when I saw Tinman, Lion, and Glinda approach. Glinda has some explaining to do.
"I hope you have an explanation for the things I don't remember because (Y/N) thinks I'm a lier and wants to go back to Kansas," I said standing up to confront Glinda properly.
"It's true, you were Fiyero and Tinman was Boq. And you both loved the Wicked Witches. Elphaba casted that spell to save you both from dying but came to me for a favor. She asked me to cast a spell to wipe your memories of her and your pasts for your own safety," Glinda explained
"Then what was the final scene for?! Because now (Y/N) and maybe the whole of Oz thinks the Witch is still alive and I still love her! Well, I never did! I love (Y/N) and I will love her for the rest of my life even if she'll never love me back! No one will listen to me after this so you better explain to them exactly what you told us and fix the damage you and the writer of this show caused! I have to talk to (Y/N) and try to explain everything whether she'll listen to me or not."
I walked away to find (Y/N). I have to explain before this night haunts me for the rest of my life. I just hope (Y/N) will understand. I'm not trying to keep her here, I just want to explain what happened before she decides she wants to leave.
YOU ARE READING
Love in Oz (Scarecrow x Reader (Wizard of Oz fanfiction))
Fanfiction(Y/N) (L/N) is your everyday country girl who lives in Kansas. There, she's made friends with Dorothy Gale. Despite (Y/N) being a few years older than Dorothy, they become great friends and have been for a long time. But when a tornado rips through...
