Creepy Pasta x reader

Five

"Just please let me explain myself" You begged. He nodded and loosened his grip, calming himself down in with his thoughts. "When Jeff told me that he was going to kill some other people I decided to come back here because I couldn't watch him do that to multiple people in one night, it was just torture. So while I was walking through the forest I felt like someone was watching me from the trees so I began to run but I was stopped by someone. I can't remember what he looked like but he read my mind! He knows that im with you and gave me this to give to you guys. I didn't know what it was but the string felt different. He told me to close my eyes and when I did I was in this dream where all of you guys were there and some other people that I didn't know but you all hated me for some reason. I think it was the string but when I woke up he was gone and I just came back here." You explained. Fear was the only feeling you had. "Liu" EJ whispered to himself. "who is Liu?" You asked nervously. "He is Jeff's brother. Jeff was his younger brother and he carved his smile out the one night then went to the hospital. When he came back he killed Liu. The only one who cared for him, protected him and helped him no matter what. Liu woke up in the hospital and killed the nurse since she called Jeff a demon. His limbs are attached by stitches that were made with this string. It is a lot stronger then other string so he stays together. He is a creepy pasta and someone, im guessing the man you were stopped by, took him apart." BEN explained. You were shocked. "he also killed his parents the same night he killed his brother" Toby added. We heard someone opening the door. "Ben put this in your hat!" I yelled in a whisper. Jeff walked in covered in blood splatters from head to toe. "Hello Jeff" Slender said. "Hey slendy" Jeff said sounding different. "Are you alright?" Slender asked. "I feel weird, that's all, im going to my room" He said before disappearing. "Wait, Jeff, what's making you feel weird?" Masky asked. "I feel like, my brother is near me. Like in the room. I don't know anymore. I killed him he shouldn't be alive mostly because he is also a creepy pasta. I shouldn't be able to feel like he is here. He treated me as if I was helpless. I hate him!" Jeff vented. You fought the urge inside to not tell him but you had to it was killing him. "We have his string from his stitches!" You yelled. He glared at you. "What! Where the hell is it!" He yelled as Ben handed him his hat. Jeff took out the roll of string and looked at it. "how the hell do you have this?" He asked angrily. Ben made him sit down while you explained everything to Jeff. "why did I look so upset? I killed him" He asked. You shrugged. "Wait you said that you were stopped by someone right? Was this him? Try your best to remember, you got this" Josh said handing you a picture after scrambling through the books under the table. You nodded scared at the sight of him. "GOD DAMMIT" I yelled. I walked away for a minute and Noha chased after me. Once we came back and I was calm, we explained who he was. After a few minutes of calming down and trying to find something to do someone knocked on the door. Noha checked to see if everyone who lives in the mansion is in the room and everyone was there. She cautiously opened the door to see a wooden box with '-A' on it.  Nervously she picked it up and opened it to see a hat. She held up the hat asking if anyone recognized it. Bens eyes went wide and he darted towards the hat. " It's Lost Sliver's hat" He mumbled. You knew Lost Sliver he was from pokemon sliver. He had no arms and was completely gray except the blood dripping from his eyes. He was shy like Hoodie and was harmless. There was a note in the hat and Ben read it out loud. "Oh how much fun it was to end another pasta's life. Mostly because he couldn't fight back. What a shame. Oh and expect more boxes arriving soon. I would be scared if I were you" Ben finished throwing the note on the table.  "He is planning to kill all of us. We need to find more people. Now" Toby said. "I-I ag-gree" Hoodie said. Everyone's eyes turned towards you. "are you ready to be a creepy pasta?" I asked turning towards you