Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
It was your three year anniversary of dating Sam and he had rented a nice cozy cabin for the weekend to celebrate. After spending one night in the cabin he surprised you this morning by making you breakfast in bed.
As you ate your breakfast Sam handed you a package to open and inside was a beautiful dress. You complimented his taste and asked where you were going to wear the fancy dress to and he joyously informed you that he had made a dinner reservation at a nice restaurant near by.
"Sam! Hurry up we're going to be late for our dinner reservation!"
"Just a minute...I'm looking for my tie." Sam yells back to you since you're waiting downstairs.
You ponder in your thoughts for a minute until you remember that you had tied his tie yourself only thirty minutes ago. You walk up the stairs to the master bedroom in suspicion. Before entering the bedroom you see Sam frantically throwing the sheets around obviously looking for something.
"Hey...we should get going honey."
Sam looks back and is at first surprised to see you but then he stands up and walks towards you.
"I found it." Sam says gesturing to the tie around his neck.
"Good." You say with a small smile and the two of you make your way to the car.
The whole way to the restaurant and even now as you sit across from him at dinner you can't help but feel like something was off with Sam. He seemed shy and nervous which also made you shy and nervous as well because he rarely acted like this.
"Is something wrong? Is Dean okay? Or...is it me?" You finally ask him not being able to hold back the burning question.
Sam looks up from his menu with a look of confusion at your words.
"What? No...nothings wrong. Actually it...sort of feels like everything is going right for once." Sam says along with showing the warmest smile you've ever seen him give off.
"Okay." You say with a quick smile as you look back down at your menu.
He really did seem like Sam, but the hunter part of you was wondering if he was a shapeshifter or something else entirely. Sam hardly ever lied to you and him lying about the tie earlier couldn't be shaken from your mind.
The waiter that was serving the two of you for the evening came to take your order. You ordered first and as Sam was ordering you sneakily tuck a sterling silver knife that was on the table into the long sleeve of your dress.
When the waiter leaves Sam says to you, "Let's go out to the private balcony, I hear they have a great view of the snow covered mountains."
You agree with him in order to not raise suspicion, but that doesn't stop your heart from nearly beating out of your chest with fear. Maybe your hunter senses were way off with this one but you know that Sam always wants you to be careful and aware.
When you take in the sight of the view on the balcony after Sam opens the double doors you're momentarily in awe. You're the first to step out onto the balcony and you nearly forget about feeling in danger until you feel Sam's hand come down on your right shoulder.
Acting in a flash you grab his hand on your shoulder and turn around. Slipping the silver knife out of your sleeve you quickly slice the palm of his hand before he knows what's happening.
"Ahh! Owww! (Y/N) what...I'm me! It's me...okay!" Sam tells you backing away from you with his hands up.
"Oh my! Sam I'm...I'm sorry you just. Why did you lie to me earlier?!"
"Lie to you? I didn't."
"You did, you lied about needing to find your tie and you haven't been acting like yourself ever since we left for dinner."
"You're right I've been acting differently because I have an important question for you...and I don't know how you will respond."
"Well...go ahead what...what is it Sam?"
You both stare each other down for what feels like forever until Sam walks towards you and he stops when he's a few inches away from you. His hands rest on the sides of your face as he places a soft kiss on your forehead. The next thing he does immensely surprises you and your knees begin to weaken as he gets down on one knee.
"(Y/N)...earlier I wasn't looking for my tie I was looking for this." Sam says as he pulls out a small black box opening it to reveal a ring inside.
"And before you try to nearly kill me again I'd like to ask you if you will marry me?"
There are a million questions and what ifs running through your mind, but somehow you manage to give him an answer that you're sure comes straight from your heart.
