That's Mr. Finn to You || Caleb Finn (re-editing)

25. "I gotta Fetish for -"

Caleb Finn's POV

I had a feeling something was going on between them. I could tell by the way Cassandra would look at Lillie. The way she acted when Lillie was around, how shy or flustered she'd get. Her body language spoke for her a lot. She also had this sparkle and adoration in her eyes every time she would stare at Lillie. It's a look I've never seen any guy give. I imagine that's how I look around Caty.

"I forgot some things. I'll leave you two be," Caty walked through the kitchen going straight towards her room closing the door behind her.

"So, when I asked-"

Cassandra cut me off, "It wasn't official yet.." I nod as I give her the bag of things we got her.

"Happy New Years," I tell them before rubbing the back of my neck exiting the house. I couldn't even believe that she basically lied to me. I sigh remembering when I fucked up a month ago.
So many secrets were being held. Mine wasn't the only one under the roof. I still regret hooking up with her. Every single cell in my body told me, no. The intoxication told me, yes. But, I hope Samantha understood.

"You alright?" I hear someone ask. I turn to see Caty there. She crossed her arms against her chest and her strap was sling over her left shoulder.

I smile at her, "Yeah... I just didn't expect..." I rub the back of my neck awkwardly. She slightly tilted her head at me wondering what I was talking about.

"I asked Cassandra if something was going on between her and my Sister. She said that they were just friends. I didn't fully believe it... When I brought them towels they both moved away from each other quickly. I just sensed that it wasn't just friendly," I was telling her the truth. I just sensed something was different with their relationship.

"Look, it's none of our business. I'm completely supportive because obviously my sister is a Lesbian. You could think what you want about it. Lets go," I nod as I helped her into the passenger seat before I went to the drivers side getting in. I start the car giving it a minute. I notice Caty's body shape was slightly different then the last I saw her.

I brush it off heading to my place.

-

"So, your room? The red room? The pool? What did you want to do?" Caty asked me as we walked into my house. I stand in front of Caty turning around realizing how short she really was. I cross my arms against my chest studying her. She raised a brow at me curious as to why I was blocking the way.

"Have you been feeling good? Are you well? Have you had some like sickness?-"

"Where the hell are these questions coming from?" Caty asked. She wasn't acting suspicious. So, I knew she wasn't hiding anything from me.

"When was the last time you had your menstrual cycle?" I asked her waiting for an answer.

"I had mine a week ago... it was short," She looked like she was questioning me. I nodded as I turned around heading to the red room. I really feel like cutting the contract. I wanna be with her. Not because a stupid paper said so. I really want her to be my girlfriend. I heard footsteps coming downstairs to see Caty. Her phone wasn't on her, the duffle bag wasn't over her shoulder. It was just her.

"Pick any item you would like for me to use," I tell her excusing myself to change out my nice dress clothes.

{ READ AT YOUR OWN RISK OTHERWISE SKIP TO THE END }

Caty Jones' POV

I look at all the things that were hung up or on shelves. There were so many things to choose from. I grab a blindfold, four leather belts, a small black paddle, and a machine looking thing. I set them down on the bed grabbing my two-set lingerie putting it on the bed.
I turn so my back was towards the door. That was slightly open. I took off my shirt then my shorts. I unclipped my bra taking the straps off letting it fall to the floor. I take my underwear off stepping out of the pile clothes on the floor together. I grab my bottom piece putting that on before the top. I turned to see Caleb's shoulder is leaning against the doorframe. As he studied me.

"Step out of the door real quick," He said.

"Yes, sir," I say exiting the red room. He goes in closing the door. I sat on the steps waiting for him to finish everything he was doing until I suddenly heard the door open. I stood up walking towards the red room. I enter to see Caleb nowhere. When I suddenly hear the door slam and my arms are behind my back.

"You've been naughty, Missy," He said in my ear taking me to the corner where the leather belts are prepared. He hooks me up with all four belts making me stand restrained. He put the blindfold on me causing me not to see. Every once in a while I would 'attempt' as if I was trying to escape but failed.

"You deserve a punishment, Kitten," He whispered the nickname in my ear. The way that word rolled off his tongue. His Australian accent sounding lower and huskier than its normal tone was really making me turned on. I couldn't see anything so I knew if I heard a certain sound I knew which side of the room it was coming from. I felt him literally rip my lingerie off so I was completely naked.

I suddenly felt a cold paddle to my ass. I gasp at first taken me by surprise because he was sneaky. He did it again and again. I would hiss or gasp from the unexpectedness I was feeling. I was really liking how dominant he was being. I heard him shuffle a couple things then I felt him kissing my lips. I kissed him back until he pulled back gently hitting my breast.

"Kitten," He whispered in my right ear feeling his hot breath on my skin. I bit my lip feeling my cheeks turning pink and my nipples harden. He was making me feel sexually frustrated. I craved Caleb like a chocolate bar I really wanted. I wanted the blood to run through my veins. I wanted to experience something so good I wouldn't even walk straight.

"Fuck... Caleb," I said really seductive and breathy like. I really wanted to get under his skin like he was doing to me. I felt his lips kissing my shoulder going to the other one. He kissed down my spin causing me to slowly arch my back due to his touch. Along with how badly it effected me.

"Jesus, Caty..." He said moaning as I felt his tongue lick my special area. I'm assuming he moved from behind me to in front of me. I felt his tongue continue licking me making me squirm a lot. He held my legs apart as he continued. I moaned loudly feeling myself reach my high. I felt him stop undoing the belts immediately. He made me walk to the bed going doggy style. My hand kind of cuffed to the bed. I heard a wrapper open. I figured it was the condom. I felt him slide inside me causing us both to gasp.

"Fuck... you're tight," he mumbled under his breath. I felt him thrust at a slow pace. Then I felt him go at a much normal pace. He lightly spanked me causing me to gasp. My moans became louder if he pushed himself deeper inside of me.

"Fuck... Caleb," I moaned as his pace slowly went faster.

"What did you say?!" He asked in a sexual darker tone. I bite my lip trying to muffle my moans so they weren't loud.

"Fuck... Daddy," I moaned loudly as he pushed himself deeper in. He went faster and faster. The thrusts becoming sloppier and sloppier by the second. My moans were loud. At some point I ended up screaming his name. He unbuckled my hands making me lie on my back. Cuffing me to the bed frame. I feel him pat my area making my back arch. He unexpectedly pushed himself inside of me. I gasped, "Oh, fuck..."

He began at a normal pace. Thrusting deeper and deeper within me. I gripped the sheets more aggressively as they became more and more sloppy. We both moaned loudly again reaching our high until I felt him deeply thrusting meaning his finished. He did that two or three more times then got off of the bed. I waited for a few minutes while he did his thing.

At some point I felt him unbuckling the cuffs off my hands. I felt a dip on the bed feeling his hands take off the blindfold me. I see the room is dark with only candles lighting the room up. He was still hard and he hovered me. I pulled him towards me pressing my lips aggressively against his. I wrapped my legs around his torso deepening the kiss. Suddenly, his member was inside of me. I gasped as I felt him thrust more and more. I dug my nails into his skin going down his back. I felt him aggressively making love bites on my neck. I decided to do the same to him. He'll regret it in the morning.

_____________________________________

Hope you enjoyed ;) if you read through it. What do you think will happen next?