That's Mr. Finn to You || Caleb Finn (re-editing)

26. The truth speaks?

*January 4th, 2019*

Caty Jones' POV

"Caleb, why did you bring me here?" I asked him as we stood in an empty parking lot. He's insane because it's nearly midnight, we're in an empty parking lot, and he's been in a really good mood. It frightened me a bit.

"Don't you recognize this place? It's where I asked you on a date and you hardcore rejected me," I chuckle recalling that. That was way back in September... A lot really has changed since then.

"Yeah, I recall. Why are we here exactly?" I asked crossing my arms against my chest. He turned to me looking me straight in my eyes.

"That was the first time... in a long time I've been rejected by a girl," He finally confessed I knew he wasn't lying after. I could just tell.

"Well, I barely knew you. And you're my psychology teacher," I reply. He nodded as he looked around.

"Caty Jones, will you do the honor of finally being my girlfriend?" He asked me causing my eyes to widen in surprise. I've never had a relationship before. I've only seen movies and television shows about romance and drama.

"Yes," I finally say with a smile. He pulls me in for a hug holding me tightly.

-

I wake up feeling super ill. I'm sweaty, I feel hot. I have a headache and severe nausea. I swing my legs over the bed slowly then turn to the nightstand to see it's only 5:43 in the morning. I slowly get up walking to the bathroom. The aroma of dirty laundry instantly makes me run to the toilet throwing up anything I ate at two this morning. I wipe my mouth with toilet paper throwing it in the toilet. I felt so groggy and disgusting I was tempted to go home. I didn't want him to wake up hearing me puke my guts out. Which is what it felt like.

I sigh slowly getting up. I exit the bathroom grabbing my bag from his room. When I head out of his bedroom towards the kitchen I saw Daniella sitting at the dining table.

"Good Morning," She greeted me. I mumbled a hello before sitting at the table scrolling through my feed on twitter to see what the heck is going on.

"What're you doing awake?" I asked her. I waited for her to reply.

"I often have breakfast to make for Caleb at seven or eight. I mostly do paper work or organize his papers because he's a mess at times. Being a professor and all... I also heard you throwing up in the bathroom," I really wished she hadn't heard me.

"So, you're back?" I asked. She nodded her head, yes.

"Have you visited your brother lately?" She randomly asked. I was stunned that she even mentioned him. Considering what he did months back.

"No... Why?" I questioned her weirdly.

"I think Caleb hasn't told you everything," She said continuing her paperwork.

What the hell did that mean?! I asked myself. I get up exiting his house. I called Cassandra to find out she's oddly awake at this hour. I ask for her to come get me and that I'll explain later. She showed up within fifteen minutes due to this place looking like a ghost town.

I got into the passenger side. As we both sat there awkwardly.

"What's going on?" She asked curious as to why she has to come get me. My car wasn't here obviously so, I couldn't head home as I wanted to.

"I think we're going to visit my brother," her eyes widen in horror as I was being completely serious. I wanted to hear each side of this story that apparently Caleb was hiding from me.

-

"I'm so shocked. My little sister finally decides to visit me," Aiden says. I roll my eyes trying to avoid his snarky attitude. Aiden looked terrible than he did three years ago. His hair was longer and much more messy, he had a black eye, and a busted lip. He didn't look similar to who my brother use to be.

"Why are you here?" He asked harshly.

"I thought you would actually want to see me," I say through gritted teeth just as harsh as he was.

"If you're seeing that Caleb guy. No. I don't," He finally said. He was still hand cuffed I noticed after a moment of studying him. We were talking through a glass between us with a thing on the left side that could make us hear each other.

"Why? What dirt do you have?" I ask him. He chuckled and his eye color turned slightly darker then normal.

"You know my girl that died in the car accident? Well, she was seeing him back then... One day ... she found out she was pregnant. Didn't know if it was mine or his. So, I killed her. And hurt people Caleb was getting close to. Including you, because I found out through my sources that you two were sneaking off behind closed doors. When Courtney did what she did. I could tell he was weak for you. He didn't want to fuck up like he had prior," My eyes were watering. I didn't know if it was true. I wiped away a tear that fell down my right cheek.

She cheated?...

"I actually liked her. It would've been your child and you didn't know-"

"She refused to get that thing tested, Caty. Oh! Let me warn you now... If he gets you pregnant... and I somehow find out. I will fucking murder his ass," My eyes widen as the police officers took him away because they heard him loud and clear. More tears were falling down and I tried wiping them away. It was difficult due to how shaky my hands were. I get up leaving the prison rushing straight into Cassandra's car. It was currently 11:14am. I didn't feel like eating anything.

"What happened...?" I shook my head as I held my hands in my hands sobbing loudly. I didn't care anymore. I just broke letting it all out. I felt Cassandra pull me in for a hug. I let her as everything I felt that I've held in for so long. I let escape.

Caleb Finn's POV

"Daniella! Have you seen Caty? She left without saying anything!" I exclaimed through my house while I was getting ready for the day.

"She said she was gonna visit her brother... She also felt really sick so she went home!" She replied. My eyes widen in shock as I hear that. I don't know what's more frightening. The fact she's had morning sickness these past couple days or the fact she's visiting her brother in prison when I don't want her to do that.

I run out of the room in a rush grabbing my keys and wallet. Trying to hurry and put my shoes on.

"Why didn't you tell me this when I woke up this morning!?" I exclaimed at her.

"She deserves to know about why you have beef with Aiden!" She yells. I groan I'm tired of my past effecting our relationship. I go down the stairs exiting the front door heading straight for her place.

_____________________________________

Do you think Aidens insane? Do you think Aiden is telling the truth? Do you think Caty is pregnant and Caleb knows?