That's Mr. Finn to You || Caleb Finn (re-editing)

24. Caught

*New Years Eve 2018*

Caty Jones' POV

I had my backpack looking around for Cassandra. I stand on my tiptoes searching through the crowd for them. I continue walking until I see Cassandra, and Caleb with a sign. My eyes began watering as I covered my mouth with my hand. I ran straight to Caleb embracing him for the first time in three weeks. He embraces me back squeezing me tightly for a second before letting me go.

"I missed you," He says to me.

"I missed you too," I say back. Cassandra gives me a hug which I hugged her back.

"Hey, how was hanging out with your friend?" I asked Cassandra.

"Oh, Lillie! Yeah, she's great. I'm great. We had fun, got caught up," She smiles at me but her body actions such as moving around and leaning back and forth tell me she's uncomfortable. I could tell she was hiding something.

"Lillie?" I questioned.

"My sister. They started talking at my Birthday Party," Caleb reassures to me. I nod processing that they basically spent all Christmas Break together...

"Did you two hook up while I was gone? Or something..." I asked exchanging glances with both of them.

"No. I've been at home or at my parents. Cassandra was either with Lillie or with our parents too," They didn't seem suspicious so I shrugged it off.

"Can we head home so I can unpack? I have so much to tell about America!" Caleb widen his eyes at me and looked at Cass. Oh...

-

Caleb Finn's POV

"I'm gonna finish unpacking!" Caty exclaimed from her bedroom closing the door afterwards.

I whisper yell, "Why the hell did you tell me she was just visiting out of town?!"

"Well, she didn't want you to know. After finding out you were hooking up with Sam or whoever... I don't blame her for not mentioning it to you," Now I feel more guilt building inside me than I should.

"I would like to know the truth..."

"Sometimes the truth hurts ... I'm sorry I didn't tell you but it was her decision. Not mine," Cassandra exits with the last word slamming her bedroom door behind her too. I huff plopping myself onto their couch.

-

Cassandra's POV

Lillie was supposed to show up an Hour Ago. She promised me she'd be here. I just  try not assuming the worst or I'll be very pissed off. I plop myself on the recliner watching Caleb and Caty whisper things in their ear and giggle. Caleb says something to her making her laugh then kisses her right cheek tons of times. Caty and I make eye contact so, I turned my head away from them. I adjusted in my seat uncomfortably before they both stopped what they were doing completely.

"Are you alright? You keep glaring at us," Caty asked. I turn to her seeing concerned and Caleb raising a brow at me. I roll my eyes inhaling deeply before I speak.

"Yes, I'm alright. I wasn't doing it intentionally... I'm uh... I'm just seeing someone ... I - I miss them," I shrug not making eye contact with them. I sighed closing my eyes for a split second before I finally look at them. They're both staring at me eyes widen in shock.

"So, you're ... dating someone?" Caty asked me. I raised a brow at her.

"Is that a problem?" I questioned their odd behavior. Why were they both acting foreign and weird?