𝐁𝐔𝐓 𝐃𝐀𝐃𝐃𝐘 𝐈 𝐋𝐎𝐕𝐄 𝐇𝐈𝐌 - 𝐌.𝐒 ( ✔︎ )

𝟎𝟏𝟐. who to believe?

♥.｡.♥.｡.:ᡣ𐭩୨⁠♡ৎᡣ𐭩:.｡.♥.｡.♥

LIES. IT WAS ALL JUST A bunch of fucking bullshit. you knew matt was jealous of ethan because ethan wouldn't ever pull some crazy shit like that on you. he was innocent and one of the sweetest boys you knew. matt had to have been making it up.

the whole morning matt was acting weird since you had woken up. you had finally decided to ask him what was up when you were in the kitchen making breakfast. matt was at the stove cooking you and him some eggs while you sat at the counter. he was silent, and usually he talks a lot in the morning and the tension between you both was extremely high and unsettling. you knew you had to ask him what was up with him, because it was really starting to concern you. but what came out of matt's mouth was unexpected, and you didn't believe one second of what he said.

"what's up, baby? you've been really quiet this morning. i'm worried about you." you asked, taking a sip from your water in front of you.

matt turned around with two plates of eggs. he knew it was now or never and he couldn't miss this opportunity. he cleared his throat, setting the plate in front of you then setting his on the counter across from you. "it's ethan, babe. last night at the party i'm not sure you remember what he did with you. well, what he tried to do." matt finally spoke.

you looked matt dead in the eyes. "what happened, matt?" you asked, a hint of fear in your tone.

"y/n, i caught him taking you towards the stairs. look, i'm not totally sure what he was trying to do. but i assume it wasn't gonna be anything you wanted." matt paused, dragging a hand through his hair then continuing. "he told you i had left you to go cheat on you with addison but that was not at all what i was doing, alright? baby, i don't know what that guy was trying to do with you but it scared me and i just think for the better you should stay away from him. i know how much you like ethan but i just don't want him doing anything to you."

everything was coming back to you. you remembered matt leaving you during the party with addison so she could talk to him and you remembered ethan coming over to you to keep you company. however, you didn't remember ethan trying to take you upstairs or telling you that matt was cheating on you. that didn't sound like ethan. he wouldn't do that.

"matt, that sounds nothing like ethan. he wouldn't ever do anything like that." you scoffed.

"y/n, i swear." matt looked dead serious but you weren't buying it.

"okay, then what were you doing with addison? for a whole hour?" you cocked your head at your boyfriend.

"y/n, come on. she was fuckin' upset with something going on with her parents and she just wanted to talk to someone and she said i was the only person she trusted." matt explained. "i shouldn't have left you for a whole hour, but she was really upset."

"so you'd leave your girlfriend for an hour who was drunk out of her mind for a girl who you think is annoying and you don't like to comfort her instead?" you asked, your tone cocky. "not to mention leaving your girlfriend alone in an absolute frat house in the middle of a dance floor."

"come on, i didn't even know you were that drunk, y/n." matt defended.

"that drunk? seriously, matt?" you scoffed again. "do you hear yourself right now? not to mention you are also making up some lie about ethan just because you're jealous that i have a friend who's a guy. i'm allowed to have friends, matt."