If It Kills Me 》Andrew Siwicki x OC x Brendon Urie

THIRTEEN; girls/girls/boys

Brendon's POV

I woke up in boxers next to Hayley in her bedroom. It took me a minute to think of why, and the memory flooded my mind. I had sex with her?!?

I sat there for a moment, thinking about the whole night, when the room's silence was broken by Hayley's phone ringing. And the ringtone was one of Panic!'s songs- Girls/Girls/Boys.

Never did I think that I
Could be caught in the way you got me.
Girls love girls and boys!

She woke up and answered it, my arm still wrapped over her waist. "Hello?..... What do you want?..... No way! You broke up with me, remember? You accused me of cheating on you with Brendon. But you know what? He and I are together now, so fuck off with you're whole 'I want you back now' bullshit!" She hung up and laid back down, frustrated.

"So we're together now?" I asked with a smirk as she turned over, surprised. Hayley pressed her lips to mine.

"No, I just had sex with my best friend because he still loves me. Of course we're together now," She ruffled my hair a little bit.

I turned Hayley onto her back and climbed on top of her, kissing her as I held myself up with my arms. Hayley placed her hands on the back of my neck and pulled me closer to her.

As soon as I was starting to get really into the moment, she pushed me off to the side. "I need a shower first."

Hayley stood up in her bra and underwear and grabbed clothes from her closet. I jumped up and wrapped my arms around her waist. "Mm, I need a shower too. And you only have one..."

"Really? That's you're way of flirting?" She looked up at me with her big, beautiful eyes. I have her the puppy dog face. "Nooo. Puppy dog eyes don't work on me."

Hayley walked into the bathroom and closed the door, but she didn't lock it. I waited until the water had been running for a minute, then walked in as quietly as I could.

Hayley's POV

I could have sworn I heard noise, but Brendon was probably walking around in my room. Then, the shower curtain was pulled back and Brendon stepped over the wall of the bathtub and into the hot water.

"Brendon!" I smacked his arm.

"What? You didn't lock the door. That was practically an invitation to join you," Brendon smiled and kissed me. I stepped back and felt the cold wall on my bare back. "You know you love me."

"And you know you love me," Since I was out of the water, I used my foot and turned it cold. When Brendon felt the cold water he screamed.

"Hey! That's cold!" Brendon yelled with a big, goofy smile on his face. He turned the knob back to warm. "Also, I recognized that song you use for you ringtone."

"Oh yeah. I've been using it since that album came out."

"And never did I think that I!" Brendon sang.

"Could be caught in the way you got me!"

"Girls love girls and boys!"

We laughed and I kissed him. Brendon kissed back and, well, you can guess where that went.