Female creepypastas x male reader

Ch.34

          ~Warning Sexual Themes~
         "Is she asleep?" Jill asks me as I return to the group of girls, all sitting in the living room. "Yeah, after I read a story to her, she fell right asleep." The girls and I are going to play adult spin the bottle truth or dare and we definitely don't want Sally to see us. "Good. Now let's have some fun." Benny says as she rubs her hands together with a devilish smirk. I took a few aspirins before I decided to join in on the fun just in case I get a headache. "Here Y/n," Angel pats the ground between her and Clockwork, "I saved a spot for you." Well, that was nice of her. Yeah, it was. I sit where in the vacant spot and greet both of my neighbors, "Hey Angel. Hey Clockwork." Clockwork greets me with a small "Hi." As for Angel, her greeting is a little more personal. She places her left hand on my upper thigh right next to my boy, "I can't wait to play with you." My cheeks heat up at her comment, "You're staying in my room tonight." She places a kiss on my cheek and I'm pretty sure my face has evolved into a cherry.
          Slenda saves my blushing downward spiral by clearing her throat, "Okay girls... And boy, before we start the game, I have some news to tell you. Everyone, except for Y/n, remembers my sister my sister Zalga, right?" Wait... Slenda has a sister? Apparently so. Why wasn't we informed about this earlier? I don't know, now shush. But they- Voice, for once in our life, can you be quiet? I'm starting to get aggravated at myself. Ugh, fine. Thank you. The girls give her murmurs of yes's. "Well, she's going to be in town for a bit and she and her assistant is going to be staying with us until she gets done doing what she has to do." Jess raises her hand like she's in school, "Is her assistant a boy or girl?" "Actually, her assistant is a boy." The girls share murmurs between one another and I can't help but grin. Another boy in the manor? Yes! I can't wait! "What's with the grin Y/n?" Jane asks me, which makes all the girls look at me. I just give them a bigger grin, along with a stretch, "Oh, its nothing. Its just that its going to feel good to have another male in the house, that's all." My arms go back beside my body, along with a smack from Angel, "What? Are you getting tired of us or something?" I shake my head, "Its not that, its just gonna feel good to have another male here. Now I can go do things that I wouldn't usually do." "Like?" Ann asks for the girls. "I don't know... Fishing?" All the girls shudder at that. "Just like a boy. Go fishing with other boys." I smirk at Masky's comment. Point received.
            "Anyways, that is the good news. The bad news is that I still haven't figured out where The Goatman is." Dang it. "Is that it, Slenda?" Slenda's attention turns toward Benny, and she nods. "Alrighty then." Benny gives the air a single clap, "Let's play." "Y/n, since you're the only boy here, you can spin first, then who ever it lands on has to pick truth or dare. If they pick dare, they have to do their dare, but if they refuse, there will be consequences, understood?" Everybody agrees to Slenda's terms, then we begin the game. I grab the green bottle and look at the girls, "Here we go." I give it a good spin and it lands on... Hoodie. I give her a small wave, "Hey Hoodie." Two red dots meet my gaze, but she returns to wave, "Hi Y/n." "Truth or dare?" She thinks about it for a second, "Hmm... Dare." I don't want to begin the game off by making everything sexual, but I want to begin it by helping each other by becoming more comfortable with each other. The date I had with Jacky made me wanna try to get the girls out of their comfort zone especially when dealing with their looks. So one of my main goals besides having fun with the game is to help out the girls with their insecurities.
           "Okay Hoodie, I have a dare for you, but its not what none of you think. I'm going to try and help you girls with your insecurities by daring you to do things you normally wouldn't do, okay?" I see all the girls look at each other kind of confused in my peripheral vision, so I continue with the dare. "Hoodie, I dare you to take off your hoodie." "W-what?" I crawl over to in front of Hoodie and grab her hands, "Hoodie, trust me on this okay?" I look back to the others and explain why I'm doing this. "Girls, today on my date with Jacky, both of us had a talk about insecurities and I got to thinking that I should help each one of you to come out of your shell sorta speak. I mean, I feel like we all should try to do things that we usually feel uncomfortable doing to help us become more comfortable about who we are." My attention goes back to Hoodie, she still seems kind of nervous by the way she's squeezing my hands. "Trust me." I let go of her hands and back up. "See, I'm going to do it myself." I take off my shirt and I hear the girls gasp. "Yeah Y/n! Take it all off!" Jill says with a whistle. I just give her a look, but then my attention goes back to Hoodie, "See? I'm coming out of my comfort zone by taking off my shirt and you know how I feel about going shirtless around y'all."
           "Y/n's right Hoodie." Everyone's attention focuses on Jacky. Jacky reaches for her mask and takes it off. All the girls gasp again, but as for me, I give her a big smile. "Y/n helped me come out of my comfort zone by explaining that inner beauty is all that matters." I look back at Hoodie, "So, what do you say?" She looks at Masky and she just gives her a nod and to my and everyone's surprise, Masky takes off her mask. "Come on Hoodie, Jacky and I both did it, now you can too." Hoodie looks back at me, "Okay, I'll do it." She removes her yellow hoodie and everyone cheers. Hoodie then gives me a small kiss, then Masky, "Thanks Y/n." "No problem girls." I go back to my vacant seat with a smile.            "That was extraordinary Y/n. You could be a life coach." Angel whispers to me and I blush some, "Thanks." "Okay Hoodie, spin the bottle." Slenda instructs and she obeys. The bottle lands on Benny. "Awe yeah! Lay it on me Hoodie, I pick dare." A smirk crawls on Hoodie's face, "Okay Benny, I dare you to take off your costume and put on some casual clothes." "What?!" I can't help but chuckle a little. This should be good.
         "Come on Hoodie, you're killing me!" "How can I? You're already dead." Benny sends a death glare her way, but her smirk doesn't leave her face. "Why I oughta." Benny eventually complies and strips down to her lime green underwear and I can't help but avert my eyes with a blush. Big mistake. "What's a matter Y/n? It isn't like you haven't seen me underdressed before." My cheeks are an inferno. I look back at Benny, "That's true, but I still have my respect for women and avert my eyes when they aren't decent, unless its during sex." She puts a hand over her heart, "What a gentleman... Speaking of being a gentleman, be one and give me your shirt and pants." "What?" She gives me a smirk, "You heard me. Be a gentleman and give up your clothes." Sigh. Grumbling, I give up my clothes and hand them to her. Cat whistles fill the air and I can't help but feel vulnerable and deceived of some of my dignity. Remember, we are helping the girls to come out of their comfort zone. I let out a sigh, the voice in my head is right. Do it for them. "Thanks Y/n." My clothes are baggy on her, but I have to admit she looks cute.
            "My turn." Benny spins the glass bottle and it lands on Jess. "Oh snap Jess! Truth or dare?!" Jess leans over and gives her a big grin, "Dare." Benny mirrors her grin, "I dare you to make out with Jane for a minute." Both Jess's and Jane's eyes go wide. "Oh heck nooooo!" "Not happening." Jane seconds Jess. "You have to, its a dare!" "Its not happening Benny." Jess informs her. "Fine," Benny drops her hands on her lap, "then you have to face the consequences." I arch a brow, "What's the consequences?" Benny looks at me with a devilish smirk, "The group or a person of the challenger's choosing has to do something painful to the wuss." I gulp. I hope Jess will change her mind.
           My hope is good enough. Jess changes her mind and convinces Jane to do it somehow, so they start to make out. My stomach becomes a flipping volcano. I try to look away and I succeed, but every now and then I sneak a peek... What? Its in my nature. After the minute ends, I finally look up straight. "Enjoy the show Y/n?" Jess asks wiping her mouth along with Jane. "It was... Nice." They both blush at my comment, "Glad you liked it." Jess coughs and clears her throat and spins the bottle. My eyes go wide when it lands on me. Crap! We're doomed. Thanks for the feedback Captain Obvious. No problem. "Y/n... Truth or dare?" Pick dare, so we won't look like a wuss. I was planning on it. "Dare please." "Awe, he said please. But unfortunately for you Y/n, being polite won't save you from this one." Oh no. "I Jess, dare you Y/n to strip down to your birthday suit and let Slenda grind on you until the bottle lands back on you."
         You've got to be joking. I look over at Slenda to see her turn crimson. Man up and do it. "If its okay with Slenda." Her face meets mine, "I'm okay with it Y/n." I sigh and stand up, then lose the black boxers in one swift move. All of the girls' faces blush blood red and I can't help but smirk. Haha, the tables have turned. I walk over to Slenda and offer her a hand up, "Ready?" She looks up and accepts my hand, "When you are." I swap positions with her and help her onto my lap. Just the pressure of a beautiful woman on my boy is enough to wake him up. "Man Y/n, you're just as big when your not hard." I blush at Benny's compliment, "Thanks." Slenda let's me put my hands on her waist so I can help her balance on me. "Don't worry Y/n, I'll try not to get you too worked up." I give her a small smile and kiss her cheek, "I appreciate it... You mind spinning for me?" She reaches for the bottle kind of seductively, "Not at all."
           After she gets done spinning it, the bottle lands on Clockwork. I fight my urges to let out a moan as I ask the question. "Clockwork, truth or dare?" She rubs her arm, "Truth please." I thought she might pick truth. "Okay... Would you mind going on a date with me this week?" Her cheeks light up, "W-what?" I give her a small smile, "We don't really spend anytime together and I want to make it up to you. So, would you go on a date with me this week?" A smile appears on her face, "I'd love to." She reaches down and spins the bottle. I'm so happy she said yes, but I'll be even more happy if that bottle lands on me again. My boy is starting to get harder to tame. "How are you holding up Y/n?" Jess asks with a smirk, but I just give her a sneer, "Like a boss." "That's funny Y/n because the boss is about to help you hold something else up soon." Slenda let's out a little chuckle, "I don't know Jess, he's pretty hard to crack." That ain't the only thing that's hard. Not helping voice. Sorry.
            Angel. It lands on Angel. Crap. "Angel, truth or dare?" "Truth, my dear girl. I'm an angel, I shall not lie." This should be good. "Is it true that you are sex obsessed with Y/n?" Angel blushes at that. Wow, I didn't know Clockwork would ask such a question. She clears her throat, "Um, yes, that is true. And it will still be true even after I get done with him tonight." She sends a wink my way, which doesn't help my soon to be boner. Thank God, when she spins the bottle it finally lands on me again. "My time is up Y/n." Slenda kisses me on the cheek as she gets up off me. Its about time, I don't think we could control ourselves much longer. "Y/n, darling, truth or dare?" "Truth." Plain and simple. "Hmm... Okay, out of all the girls you've slept with, who was the best in bed?" My eyes go wide and everyone's attention falls on me. "Oh snap, that's an interesting question." And a hard one Benny.
             I give myself some time to think. They we're all great in bed. "Um... I have to say that-" A scream from above us interrupts my answer. "Crap! Sally!" I shimmer some underwear and some PJ bottoms on me and teleport to Sally's room. When I get there, I see her hiding under the blanket from a bat that broke in her room from the window. Glass is everywhere on the floor and the bat is circling around her head. "Aah! There's a bat! There's a bat in my room!" She screams at the air. "Don't worry Sally, I'll get it!" The bat is going haywire in her room like the crazy bird from the island did to mine. Suddenly, the bat stops in mid air when it hears my voice. It looks over in my direction and I can see it has red eyes just like the bird, then I realize, its The Goatman. "Goatman!"
          The bat laughs and to my surprise it speaks. "Ha! We meet again, but its too bad that we can't have a chat. I gotta get going, but I'll be back for you Y/n L/n! Ha! Ha! Ha!" He flies out the window before I can have a chance to swat at him again. I rush over to Sally, "Sally, are you alright?! Did he hurt you?!" "Y/n?!" She pulls the blanket down to her eyes, "Is the bat gone?!" I pick her up and hold her close. She clings to my neck for dear life. "Yeah, he's gone." I kiss her head. The door then flies open and we see the rest of the gang standing there. "Y/n! Sally! Are you two okay?!" Slenda and Ann comes rushing to our sides in an instant. "What happened here?! And why is there glass everywhere?!" Jess asks in concern. I transfer Sally over into Slenda's arms, then I go over to the window and try to spot him, but its too dark and the forest is heavily populated with thick trees. " I think he's gone... For now." I feel a cold hand on my forearm. Looking over I see that Jane's beside me, "Who's gone Y/n?" I look back at the whole group and tell them the bad news. "The Goatman was here. And he knows me by name."